| Matter of Showers v Town of Poestenkill Zoning Bd. ofAppeals |
| 2008 NY Slip Op 09332 [56 AD3d 1108] |
| November 26, 2008 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Edward F. Showers, Appellant, v Town ofPoestenkill Zoning Board of Appeals et al., Respondents. |
—[*1] Patrick J. Tomaselli, Poestenkill, for respondents.
Stein, J. Appeal from that part of a judgment of the Supreme Court (Lynch, J.), entered April1, 2008 in Rensselaer County, which, in a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78, determinedthat certain real property owned by petitioner is not exempt from the Town of Poestenkill ZoningOrdinance.
The history of this matter is set forth in a prior decision of this Court (Matter of Showersv Town of Poestenkill Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 176 AD2d 1157 [1991], lv denied 79NY2d 754 [1992]). As relevant here, we affirmed a judgment of Supreme Court that certainundeveloped lots in petitioner's subdivision (lots 9 and 10) did not qualify as "[e]xisting lots ofrecord" under Town of Poestenkill Zoning Ordinance § 102-12, which would haveexempted the lots from the minimum one-acre requirement imposed by the zoningordinance,[FN*] thereby obviating the need for an area variance (id. at 1158).[*2]
In 2007, petitioner contracted to sell lots 9 and 10contingent upon his obtaining municipal approval to build a home on the combined lots.Respondent Code Enforcement Officer for the Town informed petitioner that a building permitcould not be issued for the two lots and referred petitioner to respondent Town of PoestenkillZoning Board of Appeals (hereinafter ZBA). Petitioner's subsequent application to the ZBA foran area variance was ultimately denied, prompting petitioner to commence this CPLR article 78proceeding.
Supreme Court held, among other things, that petitioner had failed to preserve his argumentthat lots 9 and 10, as combined, were existing lots of record because he did not raise it before theZBA. However, the court also went on to say that the argument lacked merit based upon thisCourt's decision in Matter of Showers v Town of Poestenkill Zoning Bd. of Appeals(supra). In all events, Supreme Court annulled the denial of the area variance on othergrounds and remitted the matter to the ZBA for further proceedings. Petitioner now appeals onlyfrom that part of the judgment which determined that the combined lots 9 and 10 do notconstitute an existing lot of record.
It is undisputed that petitioner failed to raise his contention that the combined lots 9 and 10were existing lots of record in the administrative proceedings on review herein and, therefore, theissue was not preserved for review by Supreme Court (see Matter of XO N.Y., Inc. v Commissioner of Taxation & Fin., 51AD3d 1154, 1155 [2008]; Matter ofRoss v Selsky, 49 AD3d 1065, 1065 [2008]). Thus, to the extent that Supreme Courtdetermined the merits of that contention, its determination is dictum. As such, Supreme Courtproperly excluded the determination from the decretal paragraphs of the judgment (see Matterof Sapp v Jones, 105 AD2d 574, 575 [1984]). Therefore, it is of no effect and petitioner isnot aggrieved thereby.
Cardona, P.J., Spain, Carpinello and Malone Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the appeal isdismissed, without costs.
Footnote *: The ordinance was enacted afterpetitioner's subdivision was approved.