| Matter of Dunham (Commissioner of Labor) |
| 2009 NY Slip Op 09134 [68 AD3d 1328] |
| December 10, 2009 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of Diane M. Dunham, Appellant.Commissioner of Labor, Respondent. |
—[*1] Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, New York City (Dawn A. Foshee of counsel), forrespondent.
McCarthy, J. Appeal from a decision of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, filedJune 5, 2009, which ruled that claimant was disqualified from receiving unemploymentinsurance benefits because her employment was terminated due to misconduct.
Claimant was a full-time agent for the employer, Regional Off-Track Betting Corporation,for approximately 3½ years before her termination in August 2008. During a routine audit,it was discovered that claimant's drawer was $20 short. She realized that she had sold $20 worthof lottery tickets to the manager of the adjacent bar that morning upon his promise that he wouldreturn promptly with payment, however, he had not yet done so. Claimant immediately retrievedthe money from the bar manager and gave it to the auditor. Shortly thereafter, having determinedthat the transaction constituted "credit wagering," the employer terminated claimant and disputedher application for unemployment benefits. A hearing followed, after which an AdministrativeLaw Judge ruled that claimant did not engage in misconduct and, therefore, was not disqualifiedfrom receiving benefits. However, the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board reversed thatdecision and denied claimant benefits. Claimant appeals, and we reverse.
Undoubtedly, conduct that is detrimental to an employer's interest constitutes misconductand [*2]will disqualify an employee from eligibility forunemployment insurance benefits (seeMatter of Clum [All-Lifts, Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 51 AD3d 1171, 1172[2008]; Matter of McKoy [LB&BAssoc., Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 27 AD3d 922, 923 [2006]). However,while an employee may have been fired for valid reasons, his or her behavior may fall short ofmisconduct and, therefore, he or she may still be entitled to receive benefits (see Matter ofClum [All-Lifts, Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 51 AD3d at 1172-1173; Matter of Pfohl [Hunter's Hope Found.,Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 9 AD3d 729, 730 [2004]).[FN*]Here, claimant admitted that she gave the lottery tickets to the bar manager without immediatelyreceiving payment in return, and denied that doing so violated the employer's policy againstcredit wagering. Her undisputed testimony established that this customary practice with the barmanager had occurred several times per week for years, and was engaged in by the employer'sother agents as well as claimant with the full knowledge of both the manager and assistantmanager, neither of whom ever indicated that it was against company policy. Significantly, noevidence was submitted that this custom was detrimental to her employer's interests. Under thesecircumstances, we cannot agree that there is substantial evidence to support the determinationthat claimant's behavior constituted misconduct warranting denial of benefits and, therefore, wereverse (see Matter of Clum [All-Lifts, Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 51 AD3dat 1173; Matter of Wlos [Commissionerof Labor], 42 AD3d 719, 720-721 [2007]).
Cardona, P.J., Peters, Rose and Kane, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision is reversed,without costs, and matter remitted to the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board for furtherproceedings not inconsistent with this Court's decision.
Footnote *: We acknowledge that, contraryto some of this Court's prior decisions, an employee's conduct need not be willful and wanton torise to the level of disqualifying misconduct (see Matter of Clum [All-Lifts,Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 51 AD3d at 1172 n).