| Matter of Fallon v Syracuse City School Dist. |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 07093 [77 AD3d 997] |
| October 7, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of Mary Fallon, Appellant-Respondent, vSyracuse City School District et al., Respondents-Appellants. Workers' Compensation Board,Respondent. |
—[*1] Wolff, Goodrich & Goldman, L.L.P., Syracuse (Robert E. Geyer Jr. of counsel), forrespondents-appellants.
Garry, J. (1) Cross appeals from a decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filedFebruary 13, 2009, which ruled, among other things, that claimant had involuntarily retired, (2)appeal from a decision of said Board, filed December 3, 2009, which denied claimant'sapplication for reconsideration or full Board review, and (3) appeal from a decision of saidBoard, filed December 4, 2009, which denied the application of the employer and its third-partyadministrator for reconsideration or full Board review.
Claimant, a teacher, sustained a neck injury in 2005 while moving heavy items around aclassroom. She has never been cleared to return to work and, in 2006, retired. Her workers'compensation claim was established, and a Workers' Compensation Law Judge determined thather injury constituted a permanent partial disability that had contributed to her decision to retire.Upon review, the Workers' Compensation Board initially found that claimant had voluntarilywithdrawn from the labor market. The Board later rescinded that decision and determined that,[*2]while claimant's decision to retire was related to herdisability, the medical evidence did not support a finding of permanent partial disability, andsuspended her benefits beyond the period when she was demonstrably disabled. These crossappeals ensued.[FN*]
We affirm. Contrary to claimant's argument, the Board was free to assess the duration andseverity of her disability notwithstanding the failure of the employer and its third-partyadministrator to raise that issue in its application for Board review (see Workers'Compensation Law § 123; Matterof Naylon v Erie County Highway Dept., 14 AD3d 932, 932-933 [2005]). Upon themerits, an orthopedic surgeon who conducted an independent medical examination of claimantoffered no firm opinion as to the permanency of her disability. Claimant's treating orthopedistopined that claimant's disability "most likely" would not improve, but had not examined her forseveral months, had no knowledge of her current condition and admitted that improvement waspossible. Given this equivocal evidence, the Board could properly determine that claimant failedto establish the existence of a permanent partial disability (see Matter of Scheriff v Wichmann Co., Inc., 18 AD3d 1060, 1062[2005]; Matter of Lawton v Endicott Johnson Corp., 8 AD2d 880 [1959]).
Similarly, substantial evidence supports the Board's finding that claimant involuntarilyretired in that her "disability caused or contributed to the decision to retire" (Matter of Pittman v ABM Indus., Inc.,24 AD3d 1056, 1057 [2005]; seeMatter of VanWinkle v Harden Furniture, 63 AD3d 1360, 1361 [2009]). Claimanttestified that she did not want to retire, but saw no viable way of rendering her job tolerablysedentary, and both she and her physician believed she was incapable of working as a teacher.Her treating physician denied directing her to retire, but did discuss the issue with her and opinedthat she could not perform her work duties given her disability. As that evidence supports afinding that claimant's disability contributed to her decision to retire, we will not disturb theBoard's determination (see Matter of VanWinkle v Harden Furniture, 63 AD3d at 1361;Matter of Disarno v Mattel/Fisher PriceInc., 25 AD3d 969, 970 [2006]).
Cardona, P.J., Mercure, Spain and Lahtinen, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisions areaffirmed, without costs.
Footnote *: Inasmuch as none of the partiesaddresses the appealed-from decisions denying their applications for full Board review, thoseappeals are deemed abandoned (seeMatter of Church v Arrow Elec., Inc., 69 AD3d 983, 984 n 3 [2010]).