Corica v Rocking Horse Ranch, Inc.
2011 NY Slip Op 03950 [84 AD3d 1566]
May 12, 2011
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, July 6, 2011


Diane Corica et al., Respondents, v Rocking Horse Ranch, Inc.,Doing Business as Rocking Horse Ranch, et al., Appellants.

—[*1]Roemer, Wallens, Gold & Mineaux, L.L.P., Albany (Matthew J. Kelly of counsel), forappellants.

Fellows, Hymowitz & Epstein, New City (Steven R. Hymowitz of counsel), forrespondents.

McCarthy, J. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Zwack, J.), entered August 12,2010 in Ulster County, which partially denied defendants' motion for summary judgmentdismissing the complaint.

Plaintiff Diane Corica (hereinafter plaintiff) and her husband, derivatively, commenced thisnegligence action seeking damages for injuries she sustained as the result of her falling off ahorse at defendants' horseback riding ranch. Plaintiffs' claim arises out of allegations that, amongother things, defendants failed to properly instruct plaintiff on how to control a horse, failed toprovide her a horse of the proper size and demeanor, and that defendants' trail guides were notsufficiently trained and failed to respond when her horse began bucking. Following joinder ofissue and discovery, defendants moved for summary judgment dismissing the complaint basedupon the doctrine of assumption of risk. Supreme Court partially granted defendants' motion, butfound questions of fact as to whether defendants properly instructed plaintiff as to how to controlthe horse and whether the trail guides had the opportunity to—but failed to—assistplaintiff once the horse began bucking. Defendants now appeal.

"A participant in a recreational activity such as horseback riding assumes risks which [*2]are inherent in and arise out of the nature of the activity and [i]t iswell established that an inherent risk in sporting events involving horses is injury due to thesudden and unintended actions of the animals, including those actions which result in theparticipant being thrown or falling" (Dalton v Adirondack Saddle Tours, Inc., 40 AD3d 1169, 1171[2007] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]). Further, "[a]n assessment of whether aparticipant assumed a risk depends on the openness and obviousness of the risks, the participant'sskill and experience, as well as his or her conduct under the circumstances and the nature of thedefendant's conduct" (Rubenstein v Woodstock Riding Club, 208 AD2d 1160, 1160[1994]). Participants will not be deemed to have assumed unreasonably increased risks (seeMorgan v State of New York, 90 NY2d 471, 486 [1997]; Huneau v Maple Ski Ridge, Inc., 17 AD3d 848, 849 [2005]).

On the day of the accident, plaintiff was placed at the end of a line of eight or nine otherriders, with a trail guide positioned directly behind her. Plaintiff claims that, before the linemoved, her horse bucked, but she was able to maintain control and remain in the saddle. A fewminutes later, while the line had still not moved, her horse bucked again. Plaintiff testified that,although she did not fall, she never regained control of the horse. According to plaintiff, minuteslater,[FN*]the horse bucked a third time and plaintiff was thrown off.

Plaintiffs raised a triable issue of fact regarding whether the lack of response by the trailguide positioned directly behind plaintiff increased the inherent risk of injury. Daniel Pett,defendants' stable manager, testified that an important aspect of a trail guide's responsibility is towatch out for bucking horses and, in the event that a horse bucks, the trail guides were instructedto control the horse by, among other means, riding alongside and grabbing its reins. JuanMartinez, the trail guide that was positioned directly behind plaintiff that day, testified that he didnot have time to react, in that he never observed the horse bucking or plaintiff in any distress andwas unaware that she was in any trouble until she fell off the horse. This testimony wascontradicted by Pett, however, who, despite being 20 to 25 yards away from plaintiff, testifiedthat he heard plaintiff scream and observed the horse buck two or three times with plaintiffholding onto the horse's neck prior to her falling. Plaintiff also testified that the horse buckedthree separate times over the course of several minutes, providing enough time for Martinez toassist her. Martinez testified that had he seen the horse bucking, he could have gone over to thehorse within a couple of seconds to try to stop it. Viewing this evidence in a light most favorableto plaintiffs as the nonmovants (seeHickey v Arnot-Ogden Med. Ctr., 79 AD3d 1400, 1401 [2010]), Supreme Courtproperly determined that plaintiffs raised a triable issue of fact regarding whether Martinez hadenough time to bring plaintiff's horse under control and whether his lack of response heightenedthe inherent risk of plaintiff falling (seeLipari v Babylon Riding Ctr., Inc., 18 AD3d 824, 825-826 [2005]; Millan vBrown, 295 AD2d 409, 410 [2002]; cf. Fintzi v Riverdale Riding Corp., 32 AD3d 701, 702 [2006],lv denied 8 NY3d 812 [2007]; Lee v Maloney, 270 AD2d 689, 691 [2000]).

Plaintiffs also raised a triable issue of fact regarding their claim that defendants [*3]enhanced the inherent risk of horseback riding by failing to instructplaintiff on how to control a horse. She had previously ridden horses on only four occasions overthe prior 20 years. Plaintiff was voluntarily participating in an "advanced" trail ride, but shetestified that she had never been on a horse that bucked and did not know how to control a horsein such a situation. Although defendants presented plaintiff's "check-in" form indicating that shewas an advanced rider, she contends that she did not check that box and that staff membersrushed guests through the process of signing forms. Plaintiff did not attend a ridingdemonstration held daily by defendants, which defendants recommended. She did not ask for anyriding instruction prior to or during the ride, but some of defendants' employees testified that afew basic instructions were customarily given to all riders when they mounted their horses,including how to control a horse; plaintiff testified that no one gave her such instructions.

Plaintiff did not ask for any help controlling the horse, despite the fact that there were threetrail guides assigned to the ride and, in her opinion, the horse was agitated the entire time she wason it. However, when she mentioned that she felt uncomfortable, an employee reassured her thatshe looked fine. She also testified that she twice attempted to engage in "small talk" with a trailguide, but he failed to respond or acknowledge her; she did not later attempt to talk to him abouther difficulties. Under these circumstances, we conclude that plaintiffs raised a triable issue offact as to whether defendants' failure to provide her with basic instruction prior to herparticipating in a ride "constitute[d] a substantial cause of the events which produced the injury"(Benitez v New York City Bd. of Educ., 73 NY2d 650, 659 [1989] [internal quotationmarks and citation omitted]; see Morgan v State of New York, 90 NY2d at 485).

Peters, J.P., Spain, Kavanagh and Stein, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is affirmed, withcosts.

Footnotes


Footnote *: When first asked at herdeposition about the time lapse between the bucks, plaintiff was unsure. She later testified that itwas several minutes from when the horse first bucked until she was thrown from the horse. Heraffidavit on the motion, stating that minutes passed between the bucks, was therefore notinconsistent with her testimony.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.