Powell v City of New York
2011 NY Slip Op 04727 [85 AD3d 429]
June 7, 2011
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 10, 2011


Adam Clayton Powell, IV, et al., Appellants,
v
City of NewYork et al., Respondents.

—[*1]Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP, New York (Howard Epstein of counsel), for appellants.

Michael A. Cardozo, Corporation Counsel, New York (Jane L. Gordon of counsel), forrespondents.

Order and judgment (one paper), Supreme Court, New York County (Michael D. Stallman,J.), entered January 27, 2010, which granted defendants' motions for summary judgment, deniedplaintiffs' cross motion for summary judgment, and declared that neither Asphalt Green norBobby Wagner Walk is subject to the public trust doctrine, and therefore, the City of New Yorkis not required to obtain legislative approval before commencing demolition, construction oroperation of an access ramp and marine waste transfer station located at East 91st Street inManhattan, unanimously affirmed, without costs.

In October 2004, the City of New York announced a proposed Comprehensive Solid WasteManagement Plan (SWMP), which would include the building of a new solid waste marinetransfer station (MTS) on city-owned property at East 91st Street and the East River inManhattan, the site of a former MTS that was last operated in 1999. The goal of the SWMP is toconvert the City's existing MTSs to enable waste to be containerized on site, thereby making thewaste suitable for out-of-city barge and rail export.

In this action, plaintiffs seek a judgment declaring that defendants cannot proceed with theconstruction and operation of the East 91st Street MTS without authorization from the New YorkState Legislature.[FN*]Plaintiffs maintain that because the project will encroach upon alleged parkland for nonparkpurposes, the public trust doctrine requires prior legislative approval of the plan. In particular,plaintiffs contend that the demolition and reconstruction of the MTS, [*2]including an access ramp leading to it, will constitute alienation ofthe Asphalt Green sports center and Bobby Wagner Walk, a pedestrian thoroughfare along theEast River. According to plaintiffs, Asphalt Green will lose storage area beneath the currentaccess ramp during the construction period, and the construction and operation of the MTS willdiminish the public's use and enjoyment of both areas.

Both sides sought summary judgment, and in an order entered January 27, 2010, the motioncourt granted defendants' motions and denied plaintiffs' cross motion. The court concluded thatneither Asphalt Green nor Bobby Wagner Walk is a dedicated parkland subject to the public trustdoctrine. Alternatively, the court found that even if the areas were parklands, the City's planwould not result in a substantial intrusion on the lands so as to implicate the public trust doctrine.Accordingly, the court declared that the City was not required to obtain legislative approvalbefore commencing demolition, construction or operation of the MTS and access ramp. We nowaffirm.

Under the public trust doctrine, state legislative approval is required before parkland can bealienated or used for an extended period for nonpark purposes (Friends of Van Cortlandt Parkv City of New York, 95 NY2d 623, 630 [2001]). A parcel of land may constitute a parkeither expressly, such as by deed or legislative enactment, or by implication, such as by acontinuous use of the parcel as a public park (Matter of Angiolillo v Town ofGreenburgh, 290 AD2d 1, 10-11 [2001], lv denied 98 NY2d 602 [2002]; Matterof Lazore v Board of Trustees of Vil. of Massena, 191 AD2d 764, 765 [1993]). Such animplied dedication may exist "when a municipality's acts and declarations manifest a present,fixed, and unequivocal intent to dedicate" (Riverview Partners v City of Peekskill, 273AD2d 455, 455 [2000]).

The motion court properly concluded that Asphalt Green and Bobby Wagner Walk do notconstitute parkland subject to the public trust doctrine. Neither area has ever been mapped orexpressly dedicated as a public park. Nor are these properties parks dedicated by implication.Asphalt Green was not acquired by the City for park purposes. Indeed, a 1989 assignment of apart of Asphalt Green to the Department of Parks includes a condition that the land not beformally "mapped" as parkland, which shows an unambiguous intent that the site not bededicated as a public park. Moreover, Asphalt Green is operated by a non-city entity and thepublic's access is restricted 70% of the time to those who pay substantial membership fees. As forBobby Wagner Walk, the Department of Transportation owns the property, and it functionsprimarily as a thoroughfare, which distinguishes it from a park. Thus, plaintiffs cannot establishan unequivocal intent to dedicate these areas as public parkland.

Even if the subject properties could be considered parks, the reconstruction of the accessramp and MTS would not result in a "substantial intrusion on parkland for non-park purposes"(Friends of Van Cortlandt Park, 95 NY2d at 630). Neither the temporary loss of somestorage space under the existing access ramp nor the minimal encroachment onto the subjectproperties will substantially interfere with access to or use of the facilities. Furthermore, theconstruction is scheduled to mostly occur at night and last only 22 to 24 months overall, withonly 11 months [*3]needed for demolition and reconstruction ofthe access ramp.

We have considered plaintiffs' remaining arguments and find them unavailing.Concur—Andrias, J.P., Saxe, Moskowitz, Richter and Manzanet-Daniels, JJ.

Footnotes


Footnote *: This Court previously affirmed ajudgment dismissing a separate CPLR article 78 proceeding brought by a community groupchallenging the City's plan to build the East 91st Street MTS (Association for Community Reform Now ["ACORN"] v Bloomberg, 52AD3d 426 [2008], lv denied 11 NY3d 707 [2008]). We rejected various challengesto the project and found that the proposed MTS would not cause any significant changes to theexisting land uses or overall character of the neighborhood (id. at 427).


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.