| Matter of Guidarelli v Brassard |
| 2011 NY Slip Op 07470 [88 AD3d 1147] |
| October 21, 2011 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Peter J. Guidarelli et al.,Appellants, v Arthur Brassard et al., as Commissioners of the Schenectady CountyBoard of Elections, et al., Respondents, and Jacquie Hurd et al., Appellants, et al.,Respondents. |
—[*1] Michael T. Brockbank, Schenectady, for Jacquie Hurd and others, appellants. Christopher H. Gardner, County Attorney, Schenectady (Nicholas E. Tishler, Niskayuna, ofcounsel), for Arthur Brassard and others, respondents.
Per Curiam. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Kramer, J.), entered October 13,2011 in Schenectady County, which dismissed petitioners' application, in a proceeding pursuantto Election Law § 16-104, to compel respondent Schenectady County Board of Electionsto place petitioners' names on the row or column with other candidates nominated by theindependent body known as the Alliance Party for the offices of member of the SchenectadyCounty Legislature, District 1 and member of the Schenectady City Council for the November 8,2011 [*2]general election.
Petitioner Peter J. Guidarelli submitted petitions to respondent Schenectady County Board ofElections naming him as a candidate for the office of member of the Schenectady CountyLegislature, District 1, representing both the Republican Party and the ConservativeParty,[FN*] as well as an independent body known as the Alliance Party, in the November 8, 2011 generalelection. Similarly, petitioner Richard Patierne submitted petitions to the Board naming him as acandidate for that same office representing both the Republican Party and the IndependenceParty, as well as the Alliance Party. Petitioner Phillip Tiberio submitted petitions to the Boardnaming him as a candidate for the office of member of the Schenectady City Councilrepresenting both the Republican Party and the Conservative Party, as well as the Alliance Party.Thereafter, the Board produced a sample ballot for proposed use in the general election that,rather than listing petitioners on the line for the Alliance Party, listed them on the two party linesfor which they had filed, with the words "The Alliance Party" above their names on theRepublican line on the ballot. Petitioners thereafter commenced this proceeding seeking tocompel the Board to place their names on the Alliance Party line. Supreme Court dismissed thepetition and petitioners and certain respondent candidates (hereinafter collectively referred to aspetitioners) now appeal.
We affirm. The gravamen of petitioners' claim as set forth in their brief is that Election Law§§ 7-104 and 7-106 operate with mutual exclusivity such that the former governsonly "ballots to be used on [traditional] voting machines," while the latter governs "paper ballotswhich are to be counted by a ballot scanner," which is the type of voting machine used by votersin Schenectady County. Our task is to determine the legislative intent by considering the ElectionLaw as a whole and, where possible, harmonizing the parts of the statute with each other (see Matter of Lewis Family Farm, Inc. vNew York State Adirondack Park Agency, 64 AD3d 1009, 1013-1014 [2009]; Matter of Kittredge v Planning Bd. ofTown of Liberty, 57 AD3d 1336, 1339 [2008]).
Petitioners first argue that the interpretation they urge is consistent with the fact that the titleof Election Law § 7-104 is "Ballots; form of, voting machine." However, this fact alonecannot be dispositive inasmuch as the optical scanning machines at issue are voting machines(see Election Law § 7-202 [4]).
Petitioners further urge that certain provisions in the two statutes appear to be overlapping orredundant, evincing the Legislature's intent that the two be construed to state separaterequirements for different types of ballot. Election Law § 7-104 contains many provisionsthat appear essential to the construction of the ballot regardless of the type of machine withwhich the ballot is to be used, and those provisions do not appear in Election Law § 7-106.For example, Election Law § 7-104 requires that the party name or other designation and adesignating letter and number be affixed to each candidate's name; provides that the titles ofoffices may be arranged horizontally or vertically on the ballot; provides a limit on the number oflines on which certain candidates may appear; requires that a closed fist with an index fingerextended pointing to the party or independent body row or column be printed on the ballot; andrequires that candidates for the offices of governor and lieutenant governor appear in the same[*3]row or column. While Election Law § 7-106 wasamended in 2010 to make specific reference to paper ballots that are to be counted by a ballotscanner, and includes specifications particular to ballots that are to be printed rather than appearon the face of a voting machine, we do not read these requirements to be inconsistent with orabrogate the ballot requirements set forth in Election Law § 7-104 (see L 2010, ch165, § 1, as amended; seegenerally Matter of Castelli v NRG, 85 AD3d 1414, 1416 [2011]; Mohawk Val. SkiClub v Town of Duanesburg, 304 AD2d 881, 884 [2003]).
Finally, to the extent that petitioners challenge the constitutionality of Election Law §7-104 as applied to them, that challenge is not properly before us inasmuch as there is noindication in the record that the Attorney General was given the requisite notice (seeCPLR 1012 [b] [1]; Executive Law § 71 [1]; People v Woodard, 83 AD3d 1440, 1442 [2011], lv denied17 NY3d 803 [2011]; People vDavis, 68 AD3d 1653, 1654 [2009], lv denied 14 NY3d 839 [2010]). On thisrecord, therefore, we are constrained to affirm Supreme Court's order.
Mercure, J.P., Peters, Malone Jr., Kavanagh and Stein, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order isaffirmed, without costs.
Footnote *: A party is an entity whosecandidate received at least 50,000 votes in the previous gubernatorial election.