Matter of Meaney v Village of Johnson City
2012 NY Slip Op 04265 [95 AD3d 1640]
May 31, 2012
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, June 27, 2012


In the Matter of Martin Meaney, Petitioner, v Village of JohnsonCity et al., Respondents.

—[*1]Hinman, Howard & Kattell, L.L.P., Binghamton (Paul T. Sheppard of counsel), forpetitioner.

Coughlin & Gerhart, L.L.P., Endicott (Paul J. Sweeney of counsel) and Goldberg Segalla,Syracuse (David E. Leach of counsel), for respondents.

Peters, P.J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order of theSupreme Court, entered in Broome County) to review a determination of respondent Mayor ofthe Village of Johnson City demoting petitioner from the grade of captain to firefighter first class.

At all relevant times, petitioner served as a captain in the Village of Johnson City FireDepartment and was president of its firefighters' union. Over several months in 2010, fire chiefStephen Hrustich learned of several incidents where airpacks used by his officers had beentampered with. During the same period, petitioner reported to Hrustich that someone had rifledthrough his personal gear. Petitioner asserted that his airpack was not among the disturbed itemsand that he never told Hrustich otherwise; Hrustich, however, reported that petitioner's airpackhad also been tampered with.

Hrustich subsequently complained of the airpack tampering to the Village of Johnson CityPolice Department and, in the course of the ensuing investigation, petitioner denied that hisairpack had been tampered with in a brief conversation with a police detective. Petitioner faceddisciplinary action pursuant to Civil Service Law § 75 as a result of that interaction and,following a hearing, the Hearing Officer found him guilty of multiple counts of misconduct andincompetence. Upon review, respondent Dennis Hannon, the Mayor of the Village of JohnsonCity, consulted with the Village Board of Trustees, adopted the Hearing Officer's findings in their[*2]entirety and demoted petitioner. Thereafter, petitionercommenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding, which was transferred to this Court pursuant toCPLR 7804 (g).

While we have examined and are unpersuaded by the bulk of petitioner's claims, we agreewith him that substantial evidence does not support the determination of guilt (see Matter of Rauschmeier v Village ofJohnson City, 91 AD3d 1080, 1082 [2012], lv denied 19 NY3d 802 [2012]).Hannon's determination stems solely from petitioner's interaction with the police detective, and isbased upon petitioner's failure to disclose information regarding other officers' complaints aboutthe airpack tampering, as well as his ostensibly false claim that his airpack had not beentampered with.[FN1]With regard to the former, the detective's sole objective in speaking to petitioner was to learnabout the tampering with his airpack. Petitioner denied that any such tampering had occurred,after which the detective immediately ended the conversation and told him that "we don't need to. . . discuss it any further." The charges are accordingly based upon petitioner'sfailure to disclose information that was neither solicited nor relevant to the conversation, andunder no reasonable view of the evidence can it be said that his silence was willful or indicativeof "some dereliction or neglect of duty" on his part (Matter of Weatherlow v Board of Educ.of Jamestown City School Dist., 236 AD2d 855, 856 [1997]; see Matter of Ridge Rd. Fire Dist. vSchiano, 16 NY3d 494, 499 [2011]).

Likewise, the Hearing Officer's finding that petitioner had discussed airpack tampering withHrustich does not constitute "such relevant proof as a reasonable mind may accept as adequate tosupport" the conclusion that he misled the police detective (Matter of Ridge Rd. Fire Dist. vSchiano, 16 NY3d at 499; see Matter of Rauschmeier v Village of Johnson City, 91AD3d at 1082). Petitioner complained that someone had meddled with his personal equipmentbut, notably, Hrustich only stated that he reported "an issue" with regard to the airpacktampering. Indeed, the airpack in question was stored in a vehicle used by other officers, severalof whom detected the tampering and complained about it. Petitioner steadfastly denied havingfound any tampering himself, however, and the record establishes that he would not have had theopportunity to do so insofar as he did not personally inspect the vehicle equipment.[FN2]In short, while it could be argued that petitioner misled Hrustich into believing that he hadpersonally discovered evidence of airpack tampering, the record is devoid of evidence that he liedto the police detective about a discovery he did not actually make. Thus, the Hearing Officer'sconclusion to the contrary must be annulled.

Mercure, Rose, Lahtinen and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isannulled, without costs, petition granted and petitioner is reinstated to the grade of captain withfull back pay.

Footnotes


Footnote 1: Petitioner was not charged withmaking inaccurate statements to Hrustich and, thus, cannot be disciplined for allegedly makingsuch statements (see Matter of Auxier vTown of Laurens, 23 AD3d 912, 913 [2005]; Matter of Brown v Saranac Lake Cent.School Dist., 273 AD2d 785, 785 [2000]).

Footnote 2: The individuals who actuallychecked the equipment in the vehicles testified, and both their testimony and contemporaneousdocumentary evidence demonstrated that all airpacks were in good working order on the daypetitioner's personal equipment was disturbed.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.