| Saratoga County Water Auth. v Gibeault |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 01120 [103 AD3d 1017] |
| February 21, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| Saratoga County Water Authority, Plaintiff and Third-PartyPlaintiff-Respondent, v Robert E. Gibeault et al., Defendants. Malcolm Pirnie,Inc., Third-Party Defendant-Appellant. |
—[*1] Dreyer Boyajian, LLP, Albany (John J. Dowd of counsel), for plaintiff andthird-party plaintiff-respondent.
Stein, J. Appeal from that part of an order of the Supreme Court (Nolan Jr., J.),entered October 19, 2011 in Saratoga County, which denied a cross motion by third-partydefendant for summary judgment dismissing the third-party complaint against it.
In 2007, the County of Saratoga obtained permanent rights-of-way and easementsfrom various property owners—including defendant Debra J. Caccavo's deceasedhusband and defendants Wayne R. Smith and Caroline Smith—in the Town ofMoreau, Saratoga County, for the purpose of installing and operating a water line. Toassist the County in obtaining the required easements, it retained third-party defendant,Malcolm Pirnie, Inc., to perform various [*2]services,including "assisting the County in acquiring easements on real property from realproperty owners to install the water . . . line." Once the easements wereobtained, the County assigned them to plaintiff, the public water authority responsible forthe County's water system. Construction and installation of the water line commenced in2008. However, adjacent property owners, defendants Robert E. Gibeault and Jill A.Gibeault, asserted ownership of certain property over which plaintiff claimed that it hadvalid easements and was installing the water line. After installation of the water line wascomplete, the Gibeaults filed a correction deed dated December 11, 2008, whichpurported to correct a deed from 1977 between Robert Gibeault and the individual fromwhom he purchased his property. The correction deed set property line boundaries thatwould result in certain of plaintiff's easements falling within the Gibeaults' property.
As a result of this dispute, plaintiff commenced the instant action against, amongothers, the Gibeaults seeking a judgment pursuant to RPAPL article 15 and a declaratoryjudgment establishing that it had free and unfettered access to the easements at issuehere. Plaintiff also sought an injunction preventing the Gibeaults from interfering with orobstructing its use of the easements, as well as compensatory and punitive damages andcounsel fees. The Gibeaults filed an answer with counterclaims alleging, as relevant here,that they were the owners of the subject property and that plaintiff's installation and useof the water line constitutes a continuing trespass and taking, poses a safety risk to themand has reduced the value of their property. Plaintiff filed an answer to the counterclaimsand also asserted a "third-party action" against Malcolm Pirnie for indemnification andcontribution.
In a March 2011 order, Supreme Court denied motions by each of the parties forsummary judgment.[FN1]Plaintiff then moved to reargue, and Malcolm Pirnie cross-moved for summary judgmentdismissing plaintiff's claims against it.[FN2]The court denied the motions, prompting Malcolm Pirnie to appeal.
We affirm. As Malcolm Pirnie framed the issues raised by its cross motion forsummary judgment, it had the burden of establishing that it was not negligent as a matterof law (see Alvarez v Prospect Hosp., 68 NY2d 320, 324 [1986]; Lewiarz v Travco Ins. Co., 82AD3d 1464, 1466 [2011]). In support of its cross motion, Malcolm Pirnie points tothe fact that, in the March 2011 order, Supreme Court found that a search of the publicrecords and an examination of the chains of title to the subject property would not haverevealed a connection between such property and the Gibeaults. Malcolm Pirnie claimsthat this finding constitutes the law of the case (see Martin v City of Cohoes, 37NY2d 162, 165 [1975]) and, as a result, plaintiff cannot establish that it was negligent inthe manner in which it obtained the easements. We disagree. The court's earlier findingdoes not foreclose a finding of negligence on the part of Malcolm Pirnie, as plaintiffasserts that the Gibeaults put Malcolm Pirnie on notice of their claims of ownership ofthe subject property and Malcolm Pirnie did not do enough outside the search of thepublic documents to ascertain the proper boundary lines in connection with theeasements.
In this regard, Malcolm Pirnie relies upon the affidavit of a surveyor who outlinedthose [*3]steps that should be taken—in additionto searching the public records—when easements are acquired from landowners.Such steps include "a site visit . . . and a field survey . . . using. . . any ground markers," as well as consultation with surrounding propertyowners. The surveyor concluded that these steps were completed here. However, evenassuming that this affidavit was sufficient to meet Malcolm Pirnie's initial burden ofdemonstrating its entitlement to summary judgment (see Dewey v Gardner, 248AD2d 876, 878 [1998]), plaintiff has presented admissible proof in opposition,establishing the existence of questions of fact as to whether Malcolm Pirnie wasnegligent in the manner in which it performed under its agreement with the Countywhich could trigger a duty to indemnify. For example, plaintiff points to the affidavit ofRobert Gibeault, in which he asserts that the Gibeaults refused all offers made to them tosell an easement to plaintiff, that they notified plaintiff and its agents that they had aclaim of ownership to the subject property both before and during the water lineinstallation process and that "[p]laintiff's agents grew increasingly dismissive andunapologetic" to their concerns. Significantly, the Gibeaults also asserted that theyconfronted agents of plaintiff working on the site, pointing out various boundary-linelandmarks that they claimed were evidence of their ownership of the subject property,but that Malcolm Pirnie directed workers on the site to remove any impediments on theproperty, including such landmarks. If found credible, such evidence could establish thatthe Gibeaults put Malcolm Pirnie on notice of their claims of ownership of the subjectproperty and that Malcolm Pirnie did not do enough to ascertain the appropriateboundary lines as a result of the Gibeaults' claims. Considering these unresolved factualissues and the fact that Malcolm Pirnie's obligations under its agreement with the Countyare unclear,[FN3]we are unable to conclude, as a matter of law, that Malcolm Pirnie was not negligent inthe manner in which it procured the easements or that a duty to indemnify did not arise.As a result, its cross motion for summary judgment dismissing plaintiff's claims against itwas properly denied.
Finally, we reject Malcolm Pirnie's contention that judicial estoppel precludesplaintiff from asserting that it was negligent because plaintiff had previously claimed thatthe Gibeaults were not the record owners of the subject property. Inasmuch as plaintiffhas not yet succeeded in maintaining its position that the Gibeaults' claims to ownershiprights over the subject property are invalid, the doctrine is not applicable (see Kilcer v Niagara MohawkPower Corp., 86 AD3d 682, 683 [2011]; Kittner v Eastern Mut. Ins. Co., 80 AD3d 843, 846-847[2011], lvs dismissed 16 NY3d 890 [2011], 18 NY3d 911 [2012]; Town of Caroga v Herms, 62AD3d 1121, 1124 [2009], lv denied 13 NY3d 708 [2009]; Popadyn v Clark Constr. & Prop.Maintenance Servs., Inc., 49 AD3d 1335, 1336 [2008]). Moreover, we seenothing inherently contradictory in plaintiff's position that the Gibeaults do not own thesubject property, but that if the easements are ultimately determined to be invalid,Malcolm Pirnie should be held responsible for its alleged negligence in procuring theeasements.
Mercure, J.P., Spain and McCarthy, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is affirmed,with costs.
Footnote 1: Malcolm Pirnie'smotion sought summary judgment dismissing the Gibeaults' counterclaims againstplaintiff.
Footnote 2: The Gibeaults alsomoved to renew their motion for summary judgment.
Footnote 3: The agreement betweenthe County and Malcolm Pirnie does not appear in the record.