| Matter of Flores v Fischer |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 06916 [110 AD3d 1302] |
| October 24, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Antonio Flores, Petitioner, v Brian Fischer,as Commissioner of Corrections and Community Supervision,Respondent. |
—[*1] Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Peter H. Schiff of counsel), forrespondent.
Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order of theSupreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review (1) a determination of respondentwhich found petitioner guilty of violating certain prison disciplinary rules, and (2) adetermination of the Department of Corrections and Community Supervision denying arequest under the Freedom of Information Law.
Petitioner was charged in a misbehavior report with assaulting an inmate, violentconduct, possessing a weapon, being out of place, leaving an assigned area, having anunreported injury and violating lock-in procedures. The report relates that an inmate wasobserved on G-block with bleeding puncture wounds to his head and body. A respondingcorrection officer observed petitioner performing porter duties onG-block—despite the fact that he was not assigned to porter duties or to be in thatarea—with blood on his shirt and in possession of a bloody towel. A subsequentsearch of petitioner revealed certain injuries and a weapon sheath in his pocket.
At the subsequent tier III disciplinary hearing, petitioner pleaded guilty to having anunreported injury, being out of place and leaving an assigned area. Thereafter, he wasfound guilty of those and the remaining charges and the determination was affirmed onadministrative [*2]appeal. Petitioner also filed a requestpursuant to the Freedom of Information Law (see Public Officers Law art 6[hereinafter FOIL]) with the Department of Corrections and Community Supervision(hereinafter DOCCS) for copies of DOCCS Directive Nos. 4004 and 4091, which wasdenied. This CPLR article 78 proceeding ensued, challenging both the determination ofguilt and the denial of his FOIL request for a copy of DOCCS Directive No.4004.[FN*]
Petitioner is precluded from challenging the determination of guilt regarding thecharges to which he pleaded guilty (see Matter of Brown v Fischer, 73 AD3d 1362, 1363[2010]). As for the remaining charges, the misbehavior report, documentary evidenceand hearing testimony provide substantial evidence supporting the determination of guilt(see Matter of Fowler vFischer, 106 AD3d 1344, 1345 [2013], lv denied 21 NY3d 865 [2013];Matter of Williams vFischer, 102 AD3d 1044, 1044 [2013]). Although the incident was notwitnessed, the circumstantial evidence and the reasonable inferences drawn therefromprovide a sufficient basis for a finding of guilt (see Matter of Howard v Fischer, 108 AD3d 950, 950[2013]; Matter of Johnson vGoord, 40 AD3d 1335, 1336 [2007]).
Turning to petitioner's procedural arguments, we reject his contention that he wasimproperly denied copies of certain go-around slips, as those documents no longerexisted at the time he made the request (see Matter of Gomez v Fischer, 89 AD3d 1341, 1341-1342[2011]). We also reject petitioner's argument that the fact that he was not provided with acopy of the unusual incident report denied him the right to present relevant documentaryevidence, as the report had not been completed at the time of the hearing. A preliminaryreport was read into the record and the final report does not contain any informationexonerating petitioner (seeMatter of Justice v Fischer, 67 AD3d 1286, 1286-1287 [2009], lvdenied 14 NY3d 709 [2010]). Finally, the Hearing Officer did not err in allowing acorrection officer to identify the stains on petitioner's shirt and towel as blood throughcommon observation, and petitioner did not have a right to have DNA tests conducted onthose items (see Matter of Johnson v Goord, 40 AD3d at 1336; Matter of Jackson v Smith, 6AD3d 1016, 1017 [2004], lv denied 3 NY3d 667 [2004]).
Contrary to respondent's contention, petitioner's challenge to the denial of his FOILrequest is properly before us. Regarding such requests, "there is a presumption thatgovernment documents are available for inspection, and the burden rests on the agencyresisting disclosure to demonstrate that they are exempt under Public Officers Law§ 87 (2) by articulating a specific and particularized justification" (Matter of Gomez v Fischer, 74AD3d 1399, 1400 [2010], lv dismissed 15 NY3d 858 [2010]; see Matter of Applegate vFischer, 89 AD3d 1303, 1304 [2011]). Although the basis of the denial ofpetitioner's request was that the disclosure may endanger the life or safety of a person(see Public Officers Law § 87 [2] [f]), we fail to see how the disclosure ofDOCCS Directive No. 4004, which pertains to the specifications for creating unusualincident reports, poses a danger to lives or to anyone's safety (see e.g. Matter ofBeyah v Goord, 309 AD2d 1049, 1052 [2003]). Accordingly, the directive must bedisclosed.
Rose, J.P., McCarthy, Spain and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Adjudged that thedetermination finding petitioner guilty of violating certain prison disciplinary rules isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed to that extent. Adjudged that thedetermination denying petitioner's Freedom of Information Law request is modified,without costs, by directing the Department of Corrections and Community Supervision torelease to petitioner Directive No. 4004; petition granted to that extent; and, as somodified, confirmed.
Footnote *: Petitioner's challenge onappeal to the denial of his FOIL request for DOCCS Directive No. 4091 is not properlybefore us, as he did not raise it in his petition (see Matter of Washington v Fischer, 85 AD3d 1484, 1485[2011]).