| Matter of Scinta (ExamOne World WideInc.—Commissioner of Labor) |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 00268 [113 AD3d 959] |
| January 16, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of Kellene V. Scinta,Respondent. ExamOne World Wide Inc., Appellant; Commissioner of Labor,Respondent. |
—[*1] Francis J. Smith, Albany, Kellene V. Scinta, respondent.
Appeals from two decisions of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, filedJune 8, 2012, which ruled, among other things, that ExamOne World Wide Inc. wasliable for unemployment insurance contributions based on remuneration paid to claimantand others similarly situated.
ExamOne World Wide Inc. is engaged in the business of providing medicalinformation and laboratory results to insurance companies to assist them in underwritingvarious types of insurance. It retained individuals with phlebotomy licenses, such asclaimant, to act as insurance examiners for the purpose of obtaining blood specimens,administering laboratory tests and taking medical histories from insurance applicants.After claimant ceased working for ExamOne and applied for unemployment insurancebenefits, the Department of Labor issued an initial determination finding that claimantwas eligible to receive benefits and that ExamOne was liable for contributions basedupon remuneration paid to claimant and others similarly situated. An Administrative LawJudge sustained this determination following a hearing and the Unemployment InsuranceAppeal Board concurred, ruling that claimant and others similarly situated wereemployees of ExamOne, not independent contractors.[FN*] ExamOne now appeals.[*2]
Initially, it is well settled that the existence of anemployer-employee relationship is a factual issue for the Board to decide and its decisionwill be upheld if supported by substantial evidence (see Matter of ConcourseOphthalmology Assoc. [Roberts], 60 NY2d 734, 736 [1983]; Matter of Cobrin [TelecomConsulting Group NE Corp.—Commissioner of Labor], 91 AD3d 992[2012]). Where, as here, medical professionals are involved, the pertinent inquiry iswhether the purported employer exercised overall control over the work performed(see Matter of Salamanca Nursing Home [Roberts], 68 NY2d 901, 903 [1986];Matter of Guidicipietro [Hariton& D'Angelo, LLP—Commissioner of Labor], 24 AD3d 1159, 1160[2005]).
Here, evidence was presented that claimant responded to an advertisement forexaminers posted by ExamOne on craigslist and, after completing an applicationdetailing her qualifications and passing a background check, she was hired and signed anindependent contractor agreement like that provided to all examiners. She was paid apercentage of the amount that ExamOne received from the insurance clients based uponthe fee schedule for services prepared by ExamOne that was attached to the independentcontractor agreement. In addition, ExamOne provided claimant and other examiners withan instruction manual and forms required by the insurance companies and a laboratorycollection kit containing necessary medical supplies. Notably, representatives fromExamOne reviewed the completed forms to make sure they were in compliance withnecessary requirements. Moreover, while claimant and other examiners were free to workfor other employers, they could not assign work to others without ExamOne's approval.ExamOne also found replacements for examiners who canceled on short notice andfielded complaints about examiners' performances. Furthermore, ExamOne providedclaimant and the examiners with identification badges that they were to wear whenconducting exams. It also paid them regardless of whether it was paid by the client.
Notwithstanding other proof in the record that could support a contrary result, theforegoing constitutes substantial evidence supporting the conclusion that ExamOneretained sufficient overall control over important aspects of the work of claimant andother similarly situated examiners to be considered their employer (see Matter ofGuidicipietro [Hariton & D'Angelo, LLP—Commissioner of Labor], 24 AD3dat 1160; Matter of Skeete [Cooper Sq. Nurses Registry—Commissioner ofLabor], 253 AD2d 926 [1998], lv denied 93 NY2d 802 [1999]; Matter ofBoone [Shore Rd. Community Serv.—Sweeney], 245 AD2d 617, 619 [1997]).Therefore, we find no reason to disturb the Board's decision. We have consideredExamOne's remaining contentions and find them to be unpersuasive.
Peters, P.J., Rose, Stein and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisions areaffirmed, without costs.[*3]
Footnote *: It appears that theDepartment of Labor issued two case numbers in the matter at hand, resulting in acombined hearing and identical decisions in each case by both the Administrative LawJudge and the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board (see Matter of Richins [QuickChange Artistry, LLC —Commissioner of Labor], 107 AD3d 1342, 1343n 1 [2013]).