| Matter of Winters v Advance Auto Parts |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 05005 [119 AD3d 1041] |
| July 3, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| 1 In the Matter of the Claim of Jeffrey Winters,Appellant, v Advance Auto Parts et al., Respondents. Workers' Compensation Board,Respondent. |
Martin, Harding & Mazzotti, LLP, Niskayuna (Crystal R. Peck of Bailey,Kelleher & Johnson, PC, Albany, of counsel), for appellant.
Walsh & Hacker, Albany (Glenn D. Chase of counsel), for Advance Auto Partsand another, respondents.
McCarthy, J. Appeals (1) from a decision of a panel of the Workers' CompensationBoard, filed January 3, 2012, which ruled that claimant voluntarily removed himself fromthe labor market and denied his claim for workers' compensation benefits, and (2) from adecision of the full Board, filed January 10, 2013, which adhered to the Board panel'sdecision.
Claimant injured his back while working for Advance Auto Parts, and thereafterworked intermittently both at Advance Auto and at a new employer, LKQ BroadwayUsed Auto Parts. After he was terminated from LKQ for absenteeism, claimant ceasedworking and received unemployment insurance benefits. A Workers' Compensation LawJudge subsequently concluded that claimant's separation from employment was due to hiscompensable back injury and that he did not voluntarily withdraw from the labor market.A panel of the Workers' Compensation Board reversed in a split decision, and claimantboth appealed to this Court and sought full Board review. The full Board also determinedthat claimant's awards must be rescinded, finding that claimant failed to producesufficient evidence of an attachment to the labor market. Claimant appeals from thatdecision as well.
[*2] We reverse." 'Where a claimant has a permanent partial disability but there has been nofinding of involuntary retirement, the claimant has an obligation to demonstrateattachment to the labor market with evidence of a search for employment within medicalrestrictions,' " and the Board's determination in that regard generally will not bedisturbed if its findings are supported by substantial evidence (Matter of Bobbitt v PeterCharbonneau Constr., 85 AD3d 1351, 1351 [2011], quoting Matter of Peck v James Sq.Nursing Home, 34 AD3d 1033, 1034 [2006]; see Matter of Zamora v New YorkNeurologic Assoc., 19 NY3d 186, 191-192 [2012]; Matter of Launer v EuroBrokers, 115 AD3d 1130, 1131 [2014], lv denied 23 NY3d 906 [2014]). Nevertheless, "even though there is in the recordsubstantial evidence to support the determination made," the Board's "failure to conformto [its] precedent will . . . require reversal on the law as arbitrary" if theBoard has failed to explain the reason for its departure (Matter of Charles A. FieldDelivery Serv. [Roberts], 66 NY2d 516, 520 [1985]; see Matter of Dicob v AMFBowling, Inc., 77 AD3d 1034, 1036 [2010]). As relevant here, the Board haspreviously determined that a claimant remains attached to the labor market when he orshe is actively participating in, among other things, a job-location service—such asOne-Stop Career Centers—or Board-approved vocational rehabilitation, and that aclaimant's credible testimony regarding that participation is sufficient to establishattachment to the labor market (see Employer: Classic Bindery Inc., 2011 WL3612749, *2, 2011 NY Wrk Comp LEXIS 3997, *5-6 [WCB No. G021 5031, July 27,2011]). The Board here expressly found claimant's testimony that he was activelyparticipating with One-Stop to be credible but, because claimant did not providedocumentation of his participation, the Board concluded that he failed to adequatelydemonstrate attachment to the labor market. The Board purported to rely upon a priordecision, Employer: American Axle (2010 WL 438153, *4-7, 2010 NY WrkComp LEXIS 2560, *12-20 [WCB No. 8030 3659, Feb. 4, 2010]), in determining thatdocumentation was necessary but, while American Axle held that documentaryevidence of active participation in One-Stop constitutes evidence of attachment to thelabor market, it required documentary evidence only in connection with a claimant'sindependent job search (id.). American Axle, therefore, does not providean adequate basis for distinguishing Classic Bindery.
Moreover, Classic Bindery cannot be distinguished, as the employer andworkers' compensation carrier argue, on the ground that claimant failed to comply with adirective of the Workers' Compensation Law Judge to provide documentation of hisparticipation with One-Stop. Although the Board was entitled to require suchdocumentation and to draw a negative inference as to the credibility of claimant'stestimony based on his failure to comply with the directive (see Matter of Peck vJames Sq. Nursing Home, 34 AD3d at 1034; Employer: Freezer QueenFoods, 2007 WL 3356628, *3, 2007 NY Wrk Comp LEXIS 9925, *8-9 [WCB No.8030 5219, Nov. 6, 2007]), the full Board here expressly found claimant's testimony tobe credible.[FN*]Under these circumstances, the Board has not adequately explained its departure from itsprior precedent. Accordingly, the decision of the full Board must be reversed and thematter remitted to the Board for further proceedings (see Matter of Dicob v AMFBowling, Inc., 77 AD3d at 1036; Matter of Hernandez v Taco Bell, Inc., 52 AD3d 891, 893[2008]).
[*3] Lahtinen, J.P., Rose, Lynch andDevine, JJ., concur. Ordered that the appeal from the January 3, 2012 decision isdismissed, without costs. Ordered that the January 10, 2013 decision is reversed, withoutcosts, and matter remitted to the Workers' Compensation Board for further proceedingsnot inconsistent with this Court's decision.
Footnote *:The Board panelapparently drew a negative inference based upon claimant's failure to comply with thedirective to submit documentation. The Board panel's decision, however, was supercededby the decision of the full Board, and claimant's appeal from the Board panel decisionmust be dismissed (Matter of Launer v Euro Brokers, 115 AD3d at 1130 n).