| Matter of Armison (Gannett Co., Inc.—Commissioner ofLabor) |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 08079 [122 AD3d 1101] |
| November 20, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of the Claim of Samantha M. Armison,Respondent. Gannett Company, Inc., Appellant; Commissioner of Labor, Respondent.(Claim No. 1.) In the Matter of the Claim of Timothy P. Miller, Respondent. GannettCompany, Inc., Appellant; Commissioner of Labor, Respondent. (Claim No. 2.) In theMatter of the Claim of Leslie S. Luther, Respondent. Gannett Company, Inc., Appellant;Commissioner of Labor, Respondent. (Claim No. 3.) In the Matter of the Claim ofTheron V. Wiggins, Respondent. Gannett Company, Inc., Appellant; Commissioner ofLabor, Respondent. (Claim No. 4.) In the Matter of the Claim of Martin J. Redder,Respondent. Gannett Company, Inc., on Behalf of Gannett Satellite InformationNetwork, Inc., Appellant; Commissioner of Labor, Respondent. (Claim No. 5.) In theMatter of the Claim of Jonathan R. Morris, Respondent. Gannett Company, Inc.,Appellant; Commissioner of Labor, Respondent. (Claim No.6.) |
Zinser Law Firm, Nashville, Tennessee (L. Michael Zinser, pro hac vice) andWoods, Oviatt, Gillman, LLP, Rochester (Andrew A. Ryan of counsel), forappellant.
James W. Cooper, Warrensburg, for Samantha M. Armison and others,respondents.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, New York City (Mary Hughes of counsel),for Commissioner of Labor, respondent.
Satterlee Stephens Burke & Burke, LLP, New York City (Mark A. Fowler ofcounsel), for New York News Publishers Association, amicus curiae.
Devine, J. Appeals from 12 decisions of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board,filed January 4, 2013, which ruled that claimants were entitled to receive unemploymentinsurance benefits.
These six claimants contracted with Gannett Company, Inc. and Gannett SatelliteInformation Network, Inc. (hereinafter collectively referred to as Gannett) to delivernewspapers and other publications. After the Commissioner of Labor deemed claimantsto be employees and therefore eligible to receive unemployment insurance benefits,Gannett objected and requested a hearing on the determination. The Administrative LawJudge held a combined hearing and, as is pertinent here, sustained the initialdetermination as to four of the claimants, continued in effect the initial determination asto another claimant and overruled the initial determination as to the final claimant. Uponappeals by Gannett and the Commissioner of Labor, the Unemployment InsuranceAppeal Board, following a combined hearing, found claimants and all similarly situatedpersons to be employees. Gannett now appeals to this Court.
Gannett insists that claimants were independent contractors and that the Board'sdecision was not supported by substantial evidence and was arbitrary and capricious.Whether an employer-employee relationship exists "is a factual determination for theBoard, and its decision will be upheld if supported by substantial evidence" (Matter of John Lack Assoc., LLC[Commissioner of Labor], 112 AD3d 1042, 1043 [2013]; see Matter ofConcourse Ophthalmology Assoc. [Roberts], 60 NY2d 734, 736 [1983]; Matterof Wright [Central Transp., Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 58 AD3d 988,989 [2009], lv dismissed 12 NY3d 843 [2009]). "While no single factor isdeterminative, control over the results produced or the means used to achieve thoseresults are pertinent considerations, with the latter being more important" (Matter of Automotive Serv. Sys.,Inc. [Commissioner of Labor], 56 AD3d 854, 855 [2008] [citations omitted];see Matter of John Lack Assoc., LLC [Commissioner of Labor], 112 AD3d at1043). Here, while there is evidence to support a contrary outcome (see Matter of Interlandi [CremosaFoods Co., LLC—Commissioner of Labor], 70 AD3d 1150, 1151[2010]), we find that the record contains substantial proof to support the Board's findingthat Gannett exercised control over claimants' work. Gannett assigned claimants specificroutes within predetermined delivery areas, required proof of a driver's license andvehicle insurance where a vehicle was used to make deliveries and, while claimants werepermitted to use a substitute carrier to fulfill delivery duties, they were required bycontract to provide Gannett with proof that the substitute had a driver's license andinsurance if a vehicle would be used to complete deliveries. Additional contractualprovisions included, among other things, requirements that claimants remove unsoldpublications from newspaper racks, ensure that racks were properly maintained, reservepublications of vacationing customers and create and maintain accurate circulationrecords that could be turned over, upon notice, to Gannett. Further, Gannett controlledother aspects of claimants' activities, including directives to not insert or attach "foreignmatter on, into or with copies of any publication, nor insert copies of any publication intoor with copies of any other publication" without receiving Gannett's approval.Notwithstanding the existence of evidence in the record that could weigh in favor of afinding that claimants were independent contractors, including that the operatingagreements expressly designated claimants as independent contractors, in light of theindicia of control that Gannett had over claimants, we find that substantial evidencesupports the Board's decisions in these matters (see Matter of O'Connor [2020Powervision, Ltd.—Commissioner of Labor], 67 AD3d 1302, 1303 [2009];Matter of Aubrey [NGT Lib.,Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 8 AD3d 803, 804-805 [2004]).
Finally, we consider Gannett's claim that the Board failed to acknowledge and applyDepartment of Labor guidelines for determining the existence of an employer-employeerelationship within the newspaper industry, thereby rendering the underlyingdeterminations arbitrary and capricious. Although the Board's written decisions do notspecifically refer to Department guidelines, we conclude that the instant decisions arewholly consistent with such guidelines and their express adoption of well-established"common law tests of master and servant." Importantly, the guidelines emphasize that anindividual is considered an independent contractor "only when free from control anddirection in the performance of services."[FN*] In its consideration of the nature ofclaimants' relationship to Gannett, the Board's decisions reflect its consideration of theDepartment guidelines and employer-employee principles upon which they werebased.
The remaining contentions not addressed herein have been considered and found tobe unavailing.
Stein, J.P., Garry, Rose and Lynch, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisions areaffirmed, without costs.
Footnote *:The Departmentguidelines caution employers to seek a formal determination of the status of thosepersons providing services for purposes of unemployment insurance, which Gannettfailed to do.