| Matter of Cruz v City of N.Y. Dept. of Children'sServs. |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 09074 [123 AD3d 1390] |
| December 31, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of the Claim of Tiffany Cruz, Respondent,v City of New York Department of Children's Services, Appellant. Workers'Compensation Board, Respondent. |
Michael A. Cardozo, Corporation Counsel, New York City (Meghan McKenna ofcounsel), for appellant.
Polsky, Shouldice & Rosen, PC, Rockville Centre (Patrick M. Conroy ofcounsel), for Tiffany Cruz, respondent.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, New York City (Iris A. Steel of counsel),for Workers' Compensation Board, respondent.
Peters, P.J. Appeal from a decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filed April1, 2013, which ruled that the self-insured employer was not entitled to take an offsetunder Workers' Compensation Law § 29 against the schedule loss of useaward.
Claimant was involved in an automobile accident while she was working for theself-insured employer. She filed an application for workers' compensation benefits basedon injuries sustained in the accident and was out of work from October 23, 2008 untilDecember 28, 2008. A Workers' Compensation Law Judge (hereinafter WCLJ)established her claim for work-related injuries to her right hip, right arm, neck and back,and awarded her benefits of $550 per week during the time that she was out of work.Claimant subsequently settled her third-party action with the employer's consent.Thereafter, the parties stipulated that claimant had a 15% schedule loss of use of her rightarm and a WCLJ awarded her benefits for 46.8 weeks in accordance with Workers'Compensation Law § 15 (3) (a). The WCLJ directed the employer to pay$550 per [*2]week for the 9.4 weeks immediatelyfollowing claimant's injury, listed as temporary total disability, and $550 per week for thenext 37.4 weeks, listed as permanent partial disability. In computing the net schedule lossof use award paid to claimant, the employer deducted, in addition to payments alreadymade and counsel fees, a sum of $3,310 representing an offset from the third-partysettlement. Claimant objected to the computation on the ground that the employer wasnot entitled to take an offset from the third-party recovery against the schedule loss of useaward. The WCLJ agreed and the Workers' Compensation Board upheld this decision.The employer appeals.
We affirm. Workers' Compensation Law § 29 provides that a carrier orself-insured employer that pays workers' compensation benefits has the right to offsetfuture payments of compensation against proceeds recovered by a claimant in athird-party action as long as such payments do not constitute first party benefits made toreimburse a claimant for basic economic loss or payments made in lieu of first partybenefits under the No-Fault Law (see Workers' Compensation Law§ 29 [1], [1-a], [4]; Insurance Law §§ 5102 [a], [b]; 5104[a]; see also Matter of Brisson vCounty of Onondaga, 6 NY3d 273, 277-278 [2006]; Dietrick v Kemper Ins.Co. [American Motorists Ins. Co.], 76 NY2d 248, 251 [1990]). Basic economic lossincludes payments, not exceeding $50,000, for items such as lost earnings of up to$2,000 per month for three years after the date of the accident (see Insurance Law§ 5102 [a] [2]; see also Matter of Brisson v County of Onondaga, 6NY3d at 278; Matter of Figelman v Goldfarb, 257 AD2d 721, 722 [1999], lvdenied 94 NY2d 753 [1999]). Payments that are considered reimbursement for basiceconomic loss or that are made in lieu thereof are not subject to the offset provisions ofWorkers' Compensation Law § 29 (see e.g. Matter of Allen v Enterprise Rent-a-Car, 38 AD3d970, 971 [2007], lv denied 9 NY3d 802 [2007]; Matter of Figelman vGoldfarb, 257 AD2d at 723). The dispositive question presented on this appeal iswhether that part of the schedule loss of use award associated with claimant's 9.4 weeksof lost time falls within this category, despite the fact that it was initially labeled aspayment for "temporary total disability."[FN1]
We conclude that it does. The employer contends that this portion of the scheduleloss of use award corresponds to claimant's actual lost time and that the offset provisionsapply because the $550 weekly portion of the award exceeded the $2,000 per monththreshold and represented earnings during the first 9.4 weeks (see Insurance Law§ 5102 [a] [2]). However, "[t]he weekly rate and number of weeks in theschedule are merely the measure by which an award is calculated" and, "although adecision by a WCLJ or the Board lists the award as covering certain dates, liability for aschedule award arises as of the date of the accident and 'payment of the schedule award isnot allocable to any particular period of disability' " (Matter of Allen vEnterprise Rent-a-Car, 38 AD3d at 971, quoting Matter of Briggs v Village ofHamilton, 136 AD2d 442, 444 [1988]; see Matter of Schmidt v Falls Dodge, Inc., 19 NY3d 178,182 [2012]). Here, regardless of how the award was labeled, claimant received only 46.8weeks of compensation—that is, the total amount to which she was entitled for a15% schedule loss of use award under Workers' Compensation Law § 15(3) (a). Inasmuch as claimant received only a schedule loss of use award, the award is notallocable to any particular time period, and the fact that the monthly rate of the awardexceeded the $2,000 threshold in Insurance Law § 5102 (a) (2) is irrelevantto the employer's right of offset.[FN2] Accordingly, there is no basis todisturb the [*3]Board's decision.
Stein, Garry, Egan Jr. and Devine, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision is affirmed,with costs to claimant.
Footnote 1:On appeal, the employerconcedes that the remainder of the schedule loss of use award is not subject to any offset.
Footnote 2:The employer contendsthat Matter of Allen v Enterprise Rent-a-Car (supra) expresslydistinguishes between the portion of a schedule loss of use award associated with aperiod of temporary total disability and the portion associated with a period of permanentpartial disability (id. at 970-971). However, we note that in Matter of Allen vEnterprise Rent-a-Car (supra), unlike here, the period of temporary totaldisability associated with certain schedule loss of use award payments occurred morethan three years after the claimant's injury, setting it outside of the statutory definition ofloss of earnings from work (see Insurance Law § 5102 [a] [2]).