Matter of Ahmed v City of New York
2015 NY Slip Op 04733 [129 AD3d 435]
June 4, 2015
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 5, 2015


[*1]
 In the Matter of Tanvir Ahmed et al.,Respondents-Appellants,
v
City of New York et al., Appellants-Respondents. Inthe Matter of Adelso Raul Delorbe et al., Respondents-Appellants, v City of New Yorket al., Appellants-Respondents.

Zachary W. Carter, Corporation Counsel, New York (Scott Shorr of counsel), forappellants-respondents.

Cuti Hecker Wang LLP, New York (Eric J. Hecker of counsel), for Tanvir Ahmed,Charbel Sfeir, Guy Vieux, respondents-appellants.

Fox Rothschild, LLP, New York (James L. Lemonedes of counsel), for Adelso RaulDelorbe, Pedro Sierra and Samson Zerai, respondents-appellants.

Meyer, Suozzo, English & Klein P.C., New York (Edward Pichardo ofcounsel), for amicus curiae.

Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Margaret A. Chan, J.), entered April 11,2014, which granted the petitions to the extent of annulling certain "Health Care Rules"promulgated by respondent New York City Taxi and Limousine Commission (TLC), anddenied petitioners' request for restitution of funds deducted pursuant to those rules,unanimously modified, on the law, to grant petitioners' request for restitution of deductedfunds, and otherwise affirmed, [*2]without costs.

In 1971, the New York City Council created the New York City Taxi and LimousineCommission (the TLC) for the stated purposes of "continuance, further development andimprovement of taxi and limousine service" in New York City (New York City Charter§ 2300). The TLC is empowered "to adopt and establish an overall publictransportation policy governing taxi, coach, [and] limousine . . . services asit relates to the overall public transportation network of the city" and "to establish certainrates, standards of service, standards of insurance and minimum coverage; standards fordriver safety."

The New York City Charter expressly provides that the TLC's "regulation andsupervision shall extend to" matters including "issuance, revocation [and] suspension oflicenses for drivers, chauffeurs, owners or operators of vehicles," as well as "theestablishment of qualifying standards required for such licensees" (New York CityCharter § 2303 [b] [5]). The Charter further authorizes the TLC to"prescribe, revise and otherwise regulate reasonable rates of fare which may be chargedand collected" for taxi services (New York City Charter § 2304 [b]).Finally, the City Council authorized the TLC to promulgate "rules and regulationsreasonably designed to carry out" its purposes (New York City Charter§ 2303 [b] [11]; see Administrative Code of City of NY§ 19-503 [a] [same]).

Taxi drivers are compensated according to the rules set forth in title 35, chapter 58 ofthe Rules of the City of New York. Most taxi drivers lease medallion cabs from themedallion owners and make an average of $30,000 to $40,000 per year. The TLC setsmaximum lease rates that owners may charge drivers—for example, $115 for any12-hour day shift (see Rules of City of NY Taxi and Limousine Commission [35RCNY] § 58-21 [c]). Taxi passengers pay fares using cash, credit or debitcards, and taxi drivers retain fares and tips paid in cash (see 35 RCNY 54-17 [c],[e] [1] [I]). Medallion taxis use a computerized "Taxicab Technology System"(abbreviated as "TPEP") to handle credit and debit card payments. Each day (or undercertain circumstances, each week), medallion owners pay drivers the total amount of allcard payments made during the drivers' shifts, minus various surcharges (see 35RCNY 58-21 [f] [1]-[2]; 58-26 [h] [1]).

As to the drivers themselves, the City Council prescribes standards governing theirlicensure. To that end, the Code specifies that taxi driver license applicants must be "ofsound physical condition with good eyesight and no epilepsy, vertigo, heart trouble orany other infirmity of body or mind which might render him or her unfit for the safeoperation of a licensed vehicle" (Administrative Code § 19-505 [b] [3]).Applicants must be "examined as to [their] physical condition by a duly licensedphysician designated by the [TLC]" (Administrative Code § 19-505 [d]);applicants whose physical exams are "unsatisfactory" "shall be refused a license"(id.). The TLC may make renewal licenses "subject to the same standards andtests as are applicable for original applications" (Administrative Code§ 19-505 [h]). Upon notice and an opportunity for a hearing, the TLC maysuspend or revoke the license of any driver who fails to comply with any applicable Codeprovision (see Administrative Code § 19-505 [l]) or who poses a"direct and substantial threat to the public health or safety" (Administrative Code§ 19-512.1 [a]).

Most taxi drivers work as independent contractors, leasing medallion cabs from theowners; as independent contractors, drivers generally lack access to employer-fundedhealth insurance. Additionally, until February 2013, the TLC erroneously believed thattaxi drivers who were not entitled to health insurance from medallion owners were alsonot entitled to disability [*3]insurance. However, theNew York State Workers' Compensation Board advised the TLC that medallion ownerswho are legally required to provide workers' compensation benefits must also providethem with disability benefits. This disability coverage provides 50% of a driver's weeklyearnings, up to a maximum benefit of $170 per week. Therefore, a driver earning atypical sum of $35,000 per year, or about $700 per week, and covered only by standarddisability benefits, would receive less than 25% of that amount ($170) if disabled.

On July 12, 2012, after a public hearing, the TLC voted to approve amendments toits rules governing taxi fares. The amendments increased the fares by 17%; authorizedTPEP providers to deduct six cents per fare to be "dedicated for the purpose of providinghealthcare services and disability coverage for drivers"; and authorized medallion ownersto offset the six-cent charges from credit card payments that passengers made to drivers.According to the amendments, a portion of the proposed 17% fare increase would flowinto a fund for driver health care services; the fund would be managed by an outsideentity that would help drivers seeking health insurance to navigate the New York Statehealth exchange. The fund would also provide drivers with a "minimum level ofdisability insurance." The TLC was also to select a health care assistance entity toprovide driver health care and disability coverage.

On September 11, 2013, the TLC issued an Industry Notice that the new rules (thehealth care rules or the rules) would be effective beginning on October 1, 2013. Aspromulgated and effective, the health care rules authorized and directed TPEP providersto collect the six-cent per trip fee from medallion owners; required the fee to bededicated to "providing healthcare services and disability coverage for drivers"; directedmedallion owners to offset the six-cent charges from drivers' credit card receipts; anddirected owners to remit the charges to their TPEP providers (see 35 RCNY58-21 [c] [5] [viii]; [f] [1], [2], [5]; 75-25 [q] [2]).

Meanwhile, on February 6, 2013, the TLC issued a request for proposals (the RFP)from entities for provision of the services contemplated under the Health Care Rules. TheRFP stated that the selected contractor would use a projected $10 million in annual feesto, among other things, evaluate health insurance plans offered through the New YorkState Health Care Exchange, help taxi drivers navigate the Exchange and enroll in ahealth insurance plan, and obtain subsidies available under the federal Patient Protectionand Affordable Care Act (the ACA, commonly known as Obamacare). The RFP notedthat the navigation services would be in addition to navigation services already providedby New York State under the ACA, and were to be "specifically tailored to the needs ofthe taxi driver population."

An addendum to the RFP further provided that the selected contractor was tonegotiate for and buy short-term disability insurance coverage for some 30,000 full-timedrivers, with benefits of at least $300 per week for up to 26 weeks. Those disabilitybenefits were to be in addition to disability benefits provided by owners under theWorkers' Compensation Law. On September 25, 2013, the TLC awarded the healthcareservices contract to the New York Taxi Workers Alliance (NYTWA), an advocacy groupfor taxi drivers.

Petitioners[FN*]commenced this hybrid CPLR article 78 and declaratory judgment proceeding [*4]against respondents City of New York, TLC, and TLCCommissioner David Yasky, seeking a declaration that the health care rules were ultravires and violated the separation of powers doctrine or, in the alternative, a declarationthat the rules were arbitrary and capricious. Petitioners further sought a declaration thatthe award of the healthcare services contract to NYTWA violated the law and wasarbitrary and capricious. In their prayer for relief, petitioners sought an order annullingthe health care rules, as well as restitution of monies deducted from drivers' receiptsunder the health care rules.

In their answer to the petition, respondents provided an affidavit from a TLC DeputyCommissioner, who explained that the six-cent per-trip deduction was calculated togenerate about $10 million per year. That $10 million sum, in turn, was estimated tocover the "cost of enriched disability coverage" of "approximately $3 million" per year,and "provide enough funds to give drivers an appropriate level of healthcare support."The deputy commissioner did not, however, provide any detail as to how the TLCplanned to spend the remaining $7 million (after the $3 million cost of supplementeddisability insurance) of the annual $10 million.

The IAS court annulled the health care rules, finding that they were arbitrary andcapricious. In its ruling on the consolidated petitions, the court declared that inpromulgating the health care rules, the TLC exceeded the authority that the City Councildelegated to it, violating the separation of powers doctrine.

Tracking the four factors set forth in Boreali v Axelrod (71 NY2d 1 [1987]),the court found that the TLC had "engaged in its own cost-benefit analysis," which wasproperly a function for the legislature. The court also found that there was "no nexusbetween the requirements for a taxi driver license" as set forth in Administrative Code§ 19-505 (b) (3) (relied upon by TLC as legislative authority for the Rules),on the one hand, and "assisting taxi drivers with the [ACA] and supplemental disabilitycoverage," on the other. The court, accordingly, found that the TLC had not had the"benefit of legislative guidance," the second Boreali factor.

In addition, the IAS court held that, because the ACA makes express provision forhealth insurance navigation services and disability insurance coverage, "the legislativebranch has spoken" on these issues, militating towards a finding of excess of authorityunder the third Boreali factor. Finally, as to the fourth Boreali factor, the"special expertise" employed by the agency in promulgating the regulation, the courtfound, in effect, that the TLC did not have any special expertise in the field of taxi driverhealth care issues.

The court also rejected the TLC's assertion that the health care rules were rationalbecause they were "promulgated for the benefit of the taxi drivers who are independentcontractors without employer supported health insurance or disability coverage." In sodoing, the court found that the TLC had "provided no basis, rational or otherwise, for thesix cents deduction." The court added that the TLC had provided no "clear definedinformation on what the six cents are for besides paying for an outside contractor. . . to assist taxi drivers [to] navigate the [ACA]—assistance whichStates provide free of charge to applicants."

Likewise, the court rejected the argument that the award of the contract to theNYTWA was arbitrary and capricious, finding the argument academic in light of itsholding that the rules [*5]themselves were arbitrary andcapricious. The court added that, in any event, the challenge to the awarding of thecontract was untimely as it was not initiated within the requisite 10 days "from obtainingknowledge of the facts on which the challenge[ ] [was] based."

Notwithstanding its annulment of the rules, the court denied petitioners' request fordamages, i.e., restitution of the six-cent charges withheld under the Rules. In so doing,the court held that the "doctrine of governmental immunity shields respondents" frommonetary liability, because the promulgation of the Rules, which precipitated the claimfor monetary damages, "is an official action that involves the exercise of discretion orexpert judgment in policy matter, and is not exclusively ministerial."

TLC's "expansive mandate to develop and improve taxi and limousine service"notwithstanding (Greater N.Y.Taxi Assn. v New York City Taxi & Limousine Commn., 121 AD3d 21, 28[1st Dept 2014], stay granted 25 NY3d 957 [2015]), we find that TLC exceededits authority in promulgating the Health Care Rules (see Boreali v Axelrod, 71NY2d 1, 9-10 [1987]).

First, the record demonstrates that, in its attempt to establish a cost-effective structurefor promoting driver health, TLC, motivated by broad "economic and social concerns,"was making policy, and therefore was "operating outside of its proper sphere ofauthority" (Boreali, 71 NY2d at 12). Second, TLC manufactured a"comprehensive set of rules without benefit of legislative guidance" (id. at 13).TLC has certain delineated powers to ensure that drivers are capable of driving safely(see New York City Charter § 2300; Administrative Code of City ofNY §§ 19-505 [b] [3], [d], [h], [l]; 19-512.1 [a]). However, nothing inthe Charter or the enabling code provisions contemplates the establishment andoutsourcing of a miniature health insurance navigation and disability insurancedepartment. Third, no expertise in the field of health care services or disability insurancewas involved in the development of the rule (indeed, this is not TLC's area of expertise),a fact highlighted by the lack of technical discussion at the hearings on the proposed ruleamendments (see Boreali, 71 NY2d at 13-14; Matter of New York Statewide Coalition of Hispanic Chambers ofCommerce v New York City Dept. of Health & Mental Hygiene, 23 NY3d681, 701 [2014]).

The Health Care Rules also lack a rational foundation and are arbitrary andcapricious (see New York State Assn. of Counties v Axelrod, 78 NY2d 158, 166[1991]). The record demonstrates that the six-cent-per-trip charge was carefullycalibrated to generate a projected $10 million per year for use in providing drivers withhealthcare navigation services and supplemental disability insurance. However, therecord fails to show how the $10 million figure was determined or how the money is tobe spent. This is the essence of arbitrariness in rate-setting regulation (see New YorkState Assn., 78 NY2d at 167-168; see also Matter of Catholic Med. Ctr. ofBrooklyn & Queens v Department of Health of State of N.Y., 48 NY2d 967[1979]).

The municipal respondents concede that if the rules are invalidated, petitioners areentitled to a refund of monies collected thereunder (see CPLR 7806; Metropolitan Taxicab Bd. of [*6]Trade v New York City Taxi & LimousineCommn., 115 AD3d 521 [1st Dept 2014], lv denied 24 NY3d 911[2014]; Matter of Adams v Welch, 272 AD2d 642, 644 [3d Dept 2000]).Concur—Sweeny, J.P., Renwick, Andrias, Moskowitz and Gische, JJ. [PriorCase History: 44 Misc 3d 228.]

Footnotes


Footnote *:This appeal comprisestwo proceedings, the first by petitioners Tanvir Ahmed, Charbel Sfeir, and Guy Vieux(collectively, Ahmed) and the second by petitioners Adelso Raul Delorbe, Pedro Sierra,and Samson Zerai (collectively, Delorbe). Ahmed and Delorbe commenced theirproceedings separately and the IAS court consolidated the two proceedings for decision.The court also dismissed a third petition, Friendly Group, Ltd., et al. v City of NewYork et al. (index No. 100019/14). No appeal has been taken from the dismissal ofthat petition.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.