| People v Freeman |
| 2020 NY Slip Op 50398(U) [67 Misc 3d 1205(A)] |
| Decided on March 12, 2020 |
| Criminal Court, Bronx County |
| Johnson, J. |
| This opinion is uncorrected and will not bepublished in the printed Official Reports. |
Decided on March 12, 2020
The People of the State of New York, against Joel Freeman,Defendant. |
2018BX019980
Appearances of Counsel [FN1]:
For the People: Divya Ramaswamy, Esq., Assistant District Attorney, BronxDistrict Attorney's Office, 198 East 161st Street, Bronx, NY 10451
For the Defendant: Alexandra Valdez, Esq., Bronx Defenders, Criminal Defense Practice,360 East 161st Street, Bronx, NY 10451
Jeanine R. Johnson, J.
By notice of Motion to Dismiss, filed on January 31, 2020, Defendant moves todismiss the complaint herein pursuant to Criminal Procedure Law (hereinafter "CPL")§§30.30(1)(b) and 210.20(1)(g). Having reviewed the Defendant's movingpapers, the People's Affirmation in Opposition, and the relevant documents in the officialcourt file, this Court grants the Defendant's Motion to Dismiss the accusatory instrumentherein.
The accusatory instrument, sworn to by PO TAREQ RABADI of PATU,shieldNo. 28904, states that on or about July 14, 2019 at approximately 12:21 AM atNorthwest corner of Bronxdale Avenue and Morris Park Avenue, County of the Bronx,State of New York:
Deponent is informed by PO Gurmeet Singh of 49 PCT, shield# 027660,that at the above time and place, he was responding to a radio run involving a recentmotor vehicle accident, at the above-mentioned location, a public roadway, and observeddefendant standing beside a gray 2003 Acura MDX, New York State licenseplate#CAS7207, which was overturned, and a 2010 Jeep, New York State license plate#GZJ3503, with drivers side rear-enddamages.
Deponent is further informed byinformant, that when defendant was asked what happened, defendant stated in sum andsubstance: I WAS DRIVING AND ANOTHER CAR CUT ME OFF AND CLIPPEDMY VEHICLE AND I LOST CONTROL AND FLIPPEDOVER.
Deponent is further by informant, thatinformant observed defendant to have a strong odor of an alcoholic beverage emanatingfrom his breath, bloodshot watery eyes, and to be unsteady on his feet. Deponent isfurther informed by informant, that defendant stated in sum and substance: I WASCOMING FROM MY BROTHER'S PARTY AND I HAD A FEWBEERS.
Deponent states, that he present whendefendant was administered a chemical test of the defendant's breath and that thedefendant's blood alcohol content as displayed on the breath analysis machine was.13 ofone percentum by weight.
Defendant was chargedby criminal complaint and arraigned on July 14, 2019, with, Operating a Motor VehicleWhile Under the Influence of Alcohol or Drug in violation of Vehicle and Traffic Law(hereinafter "VTL") §§§1192(2); 1192(3) and1192(1).
The Defendant moves to dismiss theaccusatory charges herein pursuant to CPL §§30.30(l)(b) [*2]and 210.20(l)(g)[FN2] because the People have exceeded the statutory maximum period of 90 days to bring thematter to trial. The People, by Affirmation in Opposition, dated February 6, 2020, opposeDefendant's motion.
RELEVANT STATUTES
CPL § 30.30(1)(b). Speedy trial. TimeLimitations.
(1) Except as otherwise provided in subdivision three, a motion madeunder paragraph (e) of subdivision one of §170.30 or paragraph (g) of subdivisionone of section 210.20 must be granted where the people are not ready for trialwithin:
(b) ninety days of the commencement of acriminal action wherein a defendant is accused of one or more offenses, at least one ofwhich is a misdemeanor punishable by a sentence of imprisonment of more than threemonths and none of which is a felony.
CPL §170.30(1)(e). motion to dismiss information,simplified information, prosecutor's information or misdemeanorcomplaint.
(1) After arraignment upon an information, a simplified information, aprosecutor's information or a misdemeanor complaint, the local criminal court may, uponmotion of the defendant, dismiss such instrument or any count thereof upon the groundthat:
(e) The defendant has been denied the right to aspeedy trial.
CPL §245.20(2). Automatic Discovery.
(2) Duties of the prosecution. The prosecutor shall make a diligent, goodfaith effort to ascertain the existence of material or information discoverable undersubdivision one of this section and to cause such material or information to be madeavailable for discovery where it exists but is not within the prosecutor's possession,custody or control; provided that the prosecutor shall not be required to obtain bysubpoena duces tecum material or information which the defendant may thereby obtain.For purposes of subdivision one of this section, all items and information related to theprosecution of a charge in the possession of any New York state or local police or lawenforcement agency shall be deemed to be in the possession of the prosecution. Theprosecution shall also identify any laboratory having contact with evidence related to theprosecution of a charge. This subdivision shall not require the prosecutor to ascertain theexistence of witnesses not known to the police or another law enforcement agency, or thewritten or recorded statements thereof, under paragraph (c) or (e) of subdivision one ofthis section.
CPL §§245.50(1) and (3). Certificates ofcompliance; readiness for trial.
(1) By the prosecution. When the prosecution has provided the discoveryrequired by subdivision one of section 245.20 of this article, except for any items orinformation that are the subject of an order pursuant to section 245.70 of this article, itshall serve upon the defendant and file with the court a certificate of compliance. Thecertificate of compliance (hereinafter "COC") shall state that, after exercising duediligence and making reasonable inquiries to ascertain the existence of material andinformation subject [*3]to discovery, the prosecutor hasdisclosed and made available all known material and information subject to discovery. Itshall also identify the items provided. If additional discovery is subsequently providedprior to trial pursuant to section 245.60 of this article, a supplemental certificate shall beserved upon the defendant and filed with the court identifying the additional material andinformation provided. No adverse consequence to the prosecution or the prosecutor shallresult from the filing of a certificate of compliance in good faith; but the court may granta remedy or sanction for a discovery violation as provided in section 245.80 of thisarticle.
(3) Trial readiness. Notwithstanding theprovisions of any other law, absent an individualized finding of exceptionalcircumstances by the court before which the charge is pending, the prosecution shall notbe deemed ready for trial for purposes of section 30.30 of this chapter until it has filed aproper certificate pursuant to subdivision one of this section.
VTL §§§1192(1), (2) and (3). Operating amotor vehicle while under the influence of alcohol or drugs.
(1) Driving while ability impaired. No person shall operate a motor vehiclewhile the person's ability to operate such motor vehicle is impaired by the consumptionof alcohol.
(2) Driving while intoxicated; per se. Noperson shall operate a motor vehicle while such person has.08 of one per centum or moreby weight of alcohol in the person's blood as shown by chemical analysis of suchperson's blood, breath, urine or saliva, made pursuant to the provisions of section elevenhundred ninety-four of this article.
(3) Driving whileintoxicated. No person shall operate a motor vehicle while in an intoxicatedcondition.
CALCULATION OFTIME
July 14, 2019 - July 17, 2019 (3 dayschargeable)
On July 14, 2019, Defendant was arraigned in BronxCriminal Court in Part AR3. He was represented by Alexandra Valdez, Esq. The Peoplewere not ready. The Defendant was released on his own recognizance and the matter wasadjourned to AP4 on July 17, 2019 for conversion and hardship hearing.
July 17, 2019 - August 19, 2019 (33 dayschargeable)On July 17, 2019, the matter was calendared in Part AP4.The Defendant withdrew his application for a hardship hearing. The People were notready. The matter was adjourned to Part AP4 on August 19, 2019 for conversion.
August 19, 2019 - October 5, 2019 (44 dayschargeable)
On August 19, 2019, the matter was calendared in AP4.The People were not ready. The matter was adjourned to Part AP4 on October 5, 2019for conversion.
On October 2, 2019, the People filed a supporting depositionand statement of readiness.
October 5, 2019 - November 13, 2019 (0 dayschargeable)
On October 5, 2019, the matter was heard in AP4. ThePeople were deemed converted and the Defendant was arraigned. The Defendantrequested motion schedule. The matter was adjourned to Part AP4 on November 13,2019 for response and decision.
On October 31, 2019, the Defendant filed anOmnibus Motion.
November 13, 2019 - December 11, 2019 (0 dayschargeable)
On November 13, 2019, the matter was calendared inAP4. The People filed an Affidavit in Opposition to Defendant's Omnibus Motion. TheCourt denied Ayala/Atkins hearing, ordered a Mapp/Johnson/Ingle/Huntley/Dunawayhearing, and referred Sandoval to the trial court. The matter was adjourned to Part AP4on December 11, 2019 for hearing and trial.
December 11, 2019 - January 9, 2020 (9 dayschargeable)
On December 11, 2019, the matter was calendaredin AP4. The People were ready. The Defendant was not ready. The matter was adjournedto Part AP4 on January 9, 2020.
January 9, 2020 - January 24, 2020 (5 dayschargeable)
On January 9, 2020, the matter was calendared in AP4.The People were not ready and requested January 10, 2020, to file a COC AutomaticDisclosure and statement of readiness. The matter was adjourned to Part AP4 on January24, 2020.
On January 14, 2020, the People filed an Automatic Disclosure,COC and statement of readiness.
January 24, 2020 - February 20, 2020 (0 dayschargeable)
On January 24, 2020, the matter was calendared in AP4.The People filed a supplemental COC and statement of readiness. The Defendantchallenges the COC and the People's readiness due to the missing memo books of PoliceOfficer Genesis Vasquez and Police Officer Chanta James. The People detail severalattempts to ascertain the memo books but never receive or provide the Court with adefinite answer as to their existence. The Court deemed the People's COC invalid.Following the Courts ruling the Defendant requested a motion schedule. The Defendant'sMotion to Dismiss was due January 30, 2020. The People's response was due February 6,2020. The matter was adjourned to Part AP4 on February 20, 2020 for this Court'sdecision.
The Defendant filed the instant Motion to Dismiss for speedy trial on January 31,2020. The People filed their Affirmation in Opposition on February 6, 2020.
ANALYSIS
The issue at hand is whether the People should be charged the entire period fromJanuary 1, 2020 through January 14, 2020, or only January 1, 2020 through January 9,2020. The Defendant contends that due to the changes in the statute, effective January 1,2020, the People's statement of readiness from December 11, 2019 became invalid untilthey provided all newly discoverable material and filed a COC. The Defendant assertsthat the People exceeded their speedy trial time prior to filing a proper COC and the caseshould be dismissed. The People argue they have not exceeded their speedy trial time.The People assert they remained ready the entire time between December 11, 2019 andJanuary 9, 2020 because they stated ready on December 11, 2019 and the case wasadjourned at the request of defense. The People concede they should be charged [*4]from January 9, 2020 through January 14, 2020. ThePeople also argue the Court should find an exceptional circumstance based on theirefforts to obtain discovery, charge them with eighty-five days and rather than dismiss, asanction be imposed at trial.
The top count of the accusatory instrument is anunclassified misdemeanor requiring that the People be ready for trial within ninety daysof commencement of the criminal action. CPL §30.30(1)(b). Successful motionsunder CPL §30.30 must demonstrate the existence of an unexcused delay in excessof the statutory maximum. see People v. Santos, 68 NY2d 859 (1986). Prior to January 1,2020, the People were considered ready for trial when there was no legal impediment totrying their case and the People communicated their actual readiness in open court orserved written notice of readiness to the court and defense counsel. see People v. Brown,28 NY3d 392 (2016); see also People v. Kendzia, 64 NY2d 331 (1995). Although thereis a presumption that a statement of readiness is truthful and accurate (People v. Sibblies,22 NY3d 1174 (2014), on January 1, 2020 the law changed. The mandate pursuant toArticle 245 of the CPL requires the People to file a COC stating they have met theirdiscovery requirements within fifteen days of the inception of a criminal matter to bedeemed ready for trial and invoke the presumption.[FN3]CPL §§245.10(1)(a); 245.50(3). The People's "failure to declare readinesswithin the statutory time limit will result in dismissal of the prosecution unless the Peoplecan demonstrate that certain time periods should be excluded." People v. Price, 14 NY3d61, 63 (2010).
The new mandate also provides that "absent an individualizedfinding of exceptional circumstances by the court" the speedy trial time shall not betolled until a proper certificate has been filed. CPL §245.50(3). Exceptionalcircumstances have been found where a necessary witness was not available due to amedical reason or some circumstance outside the control of the prosecutor. see People v.Goodman, 41 NY2d 888 (1977) (unavailability of complainant for medical reasons); seealso People v. McLeod, 281 AD2d 325 (1st Dep't 2001) (exceptional circumstancesfound where police officer was disabled due to arm cast). However, exceptionalcircumstances have not been found due to inadequate staffing, overwork ordisorganization in the prosecutor's office. People v. Sturgis, 38 NY2d 625, 628-29;People v. Warren, 85 AD2d 747 (2d Dept 1981); see also People v. DiMeglio, 294 AD2d239 (1st Dept 2002).
As the People were ready on December 11, 2019, andthe adjournment was at the request of defense counsel this Court finds the periodbetween December 11, 2019 through January 1, 2020 excludable pursuant to CPL§30.30(4)(b); see People v. Worley, 66 NY2d 523 (1985); see also People v.Cambridge, 230 AD2d 649 (1st Dept 1996). The People exceeded their statutory timelimitation by four days when they filed their Certificate of Compliance, AutomaticDisclosure and statement of readiness on January 14, 2020.[FN4]Here, exceptional circumstances do not exist as the People; i) did not communicate anysuch circumstances on the record on the January 9, 2020, ii) inferred full knowledge ofthe impending expiration when stating their intention to file a COC on January 10, 2020and iii) are imputed to have had the existent discoverable material in theirpossession.[FN5]CPL §245.20(2). Thus, the Court cannot make a finding that an individualizedexceptional circumstance exist in this case to modify the speedy trial clock. This Courtnotes the gravity of the allegations in this case but is constrained from issuing a differentdecision and must rule consistent with the legislative mandate. Therefore, the People arecharged ninety-four [*5]days as of January 14, 2020,which is over their statutory allotment and the case against Mr. Freeman must bedismissed.
CONCLUSION
In view of the foregoing, the Court finds a total of ninety-four (94) dayschargeable to the People. Accordingly, Defendant's Motion to Dismiss under CPL§§30.30(1)(b) and 170.30(e) is granted.
This constitutes thedecision and order of the Court.
Dated: March 12, 2020
Footnote 1:ADA DivyaRamaswamy, Bronx County, New York, District Attorney's Office, for the People.Alexandra Valdez, Esq., Bronx Defenders, Bronx County, New York, for the Defendant.
Footnote 2:The instant matter doesnot contemplate an indictment. As such, the Court's decision is not based upon theprescriptions of C.P.L. §210.20(1)(g) but instead the standard as prescribed byC.P.L. §170.30(1)(e).
Footnote 3:Upon specificcircumstances, including exceptionally voluminous materials or discoverable materialsare not in the prosecutor's actual possession despite diligent and good faith efforts, apossible thirty-day extension is permissible to the file the required COC. CPL§245.10(1)(a).
Footnote 4:This Court will notconduct a review regarding the validity of the Certificate of Compliance as the Peopleexceeded their statutory time prior to the filing date.
Footnote 5:Upon further diligencethe People did produce a portion of the outstanding material on January 27, 2020.