[*1]
People v Georgiopoulos
2021 NY Slip Op 50380(U) [71 Misc 3d 1215(A)]
Decided on April 29, 2021
Supreme Court, Queens County
Lopez, J.
This opinion is uncorrected and will not bepublished in the printed Official Reports.


Decided on April 29, 2021
Supreme Court, Queens County


The People of theState of New York, Plaintiff,

against

Nick Georgiopoulos, Defendant.




01396-2019



People by: Assistant District Attorney Candi Green125-01 Queens Boulevard KewGardens, New York 11415

The Defendant by: Lisa Saltzman, Esq. Queens Defenders 118-21 QueensBoulevard, Suite 212 Forest Hills, New York 11375


Gene R. Lopez, J.

The defendant, Nick Georgiopoulos, is charged with Driving While Intoxicated (VTL §1192[3]), as a class E felony, Aggravated Unlicensed Operation of a Motor Vehicle in the FirstDegree (VTL § 511[3][a][i]), Aggravated Unlicensed Operation of a Motor Vehicle in theSecond Degree (VTL § 511[2][a][ii]), Operating a Motor Vehicle Without a License (VTL§ 509[1]), Driving in Excess of the Maximum Speed Limit (VTL § 1180[d][1]), andOperating a Motor Vehicle Without an Ignition Interlock Device (VTL § 1198[9][d]).

The People filed a certificate of compliance, pursuant to CPL § 245.50[1], on October30, 2020. The defendant now moves for a ruling deeming the People's certificate improper,arguing that the People failed to provide certain discoverable materials. The People oppose thedefendant's motion.

Relevant Law

On January 1, 2020, Article 245 replaced Article 240 of the Criminal Procedure Law. Thischange was a part of a package of criminal justice reforms intended to, inter alia, expanddiscovery in criminal cases. Shortly after these changes became effective, several amendmentswere made to the new law. (See NY Legis 56 (2020), 2020 Sess Law News of NY Ch 56[S 7506-B] Part HHH [McKinney's].)

Pursuant to CPL § 245.20, prosecutors are now required to disclose "all items andinformation that relate to the subject matter of the case and are in the possession, custody orcontrol of the prosecution or persons under the prosecution's direction and control." The statutefurther provides a non-exhaustive list of materials subject to disclosure under this provision.(CPL § 245.20[1].) CPL § 245.10 sets forth a timeline for these disclosures, requiringthe People to comply with this automatic discovery obligation within a certain period of time,except in cases with "exceptionally voluminous" discovery materials, where initial automaticdiscovery may be stayed for an additional thirty days without the need for a motion.

In making such disclosures, the statute explains:

The prosecutor shall make a diligent, good faith effort to ascertain the existence of materialor information discoverable under [CPL § 245.20(1)] and to cause such material orinformation to be made available for discovery where it exists but is not within the prosecutor'spossession, custody, or control; provided that the prosecutor shall not be required to obtain bysubpoena duces tecum material or information which the defendant may thereby obtain.

(CPL § 245.20[2].) And, importantly, "all items and information related to theprosecution of a charge in the possession of any New York state or local police or lawenforcement agency shall be deemed to be in the possession of the prosecution." (CPL §245.20[2].) Congruent with that provision, CPL § 245.55(1) directs that, "The districtattorney and the assistant responsible for the case, . . . shall endeavor to ensure that a flow ofinformation is maintained between the police and other investigative personnel and his or heroffice sufficient to place within his or her possession or control all material and informationpertinent to the defendant and the offense or offenses charged . . . ." The statute also explicitlydictates that "[t]here shall be a presumption in favor of disclosure" in interpreting Article 245(CPL § 245.20[7].)

In keeping with this principle, the People's discovery obligations are ongoing. Should theprosecution learn of additional material or information that it would have been required todisclose pursuant to CPL § 245.20, "it shall expeditiously notify the other party and disclosethe additional material and information as required for initial discovery under this article." (CPL§ 245.60.)

The new discovery law also, for the first time, ties the People's compliance with theirdiscovery obligations to the calculation of speedy trial time pursuant to CPL § 30.30. Now,the People must file a certificate of compliance upon satisfaction of their discovery obligationsunder CPL § 245.20[1]. (CPL § 245.50[1].) Therein, the People must affirm that "afterexercising due diligence and making reasonable inquiries to ascertain the existence of materialand information subject to discovery, the prosecutor has disclosed and made available all knownmaterial and information subject to discovery." (Id.) In addition to this statement, thecertificate must include a list of the discovery materials provided. (Id.) Moreover, if thePeople provide additional discovery in connection with their ongoing obligations outlined in CPL245.60, they must file a supplemental certificate "identifying the additional material andinformation [*2]provided." (CPL § 245.50[1].) Notably, thestatute also specifies, "No adverse consequence to the prosecutor shall result from the filing of acertificate of compliance in good faith and reasonable under the circumstances; but the court maygrant a remedy or sanction for a discovery violation as provided in section 245.80 of this article."(CPL § 245.50[1].)

At the same time, the law makes the certificate of compliance a prerequisite to the People'strial readiness within the meaning of CPL § 30.30. Pursuant to CPL § 245.50(3),"absent an individualized finding of special circumstances in the instant case by the court beforewhich the charge is pending, the prosecution shall not be deemed ready for trial for the purposesof section 30.30 of this chapter until it has filed a proper certificate pursuant to subdivision oneof this section." The statute further clarifies that, "[a] court may deem the prosecution ready fortrial pursuant to section 30.30 of this chapter where information that might be considereddiscoverable under this article cannot be disclosed because it has been lost, destroyed, orotherwise unavailable as provided by [CPL § 245.80(b)], despite diligent and good faithefforts, reasonable under the circumstances."[FN1] And CPL § 30.30 also now reflects this change, stating, "Any statement of trial readinessmust be accompanied or preceded by a certification of good faith compliance with the disclosurerequirements of section 245.20 . . . ." (CPL § 30.30[5]).

An order deeming a certificate of compliance improper, then, necessarily amounts to adetermination that the People's statement of readiness for trial is illusory. (See CPL§ 30.30[5]; People v Barnett,68 Misc 3d 1000, 1002 [Sup Ct NY Co 2020].) And the statute requires that "[c]hallengesto, or questions related to a certificate of compliance shall be addressed by motion." (CPL §245.50[4].) However, for the purposes of evaluating a claim concerning the validity of acertificate of compliance, the statutory scheme does not define what constitutes a "proper"certificate, which it makes the prerequisite to an announcement of trial readiness. (CPL §245.50[3].) Given that the statute specifies that "[n]o adverse consequences" shall adhere to thePeople based on the filing of a certificate that is filed "in good faith and reasonable under thecircumstances," (CPL § 245.50[1]), the most reasonable inference is that such a certificateis "proper" within the meaning of CPL § 245.50[3] and, thus, fulfills that section'sprerequisite to any valid statement of readiness by the People.

In this regard, numerous courts have found that belated disclosures should not invalidate acertificate of compliance that was made in good faith after the exercise of due diligence wherethe delay resulted from, for example, minor oversights in the production of material, delayeddiscovery of the existence of certain items, or a good faith position that the material in questionwas not discoverable. (See People vErby, 68 Misc 3d 625, 633 [Sup Ct Bronx Co 2020]; People v Gonzalez, 68 Misc 3d 1213(A), *1, 3 [Sup Ct Kings Co2020]; People v Knight, 69 Misc 3d546, 552 [Sup Ct Kings Co 2020];People v Lustig, 68 Misc 3d 234, 247 [Sup Ct Queens Co 2020]; People v Randolph, 69 Misc 3d770, 770 [Sup Ct Suffolk Co 2020]; People v Davis, __ [*3]NYS3d__, 2020 NY Slip Op 20298, 2020 WL 6576095, at *5-7[Crim Ct Bronx Co, October 9, 2020].) Indeed, in People v Erby, 68 Misc 3d at 633, acourt of coordinate jurisdiction addressing a discovery challenge observed:

As the legislative history of Article 245 indicates, and as the Article's sanctions and remediesprovisions suggest, the new discovery law, designed as it was to be remedial in nature, should notbe construed as an inescapable trap for the diligent prosecutor who professionally, assiduouslyand in good faith attempts to comply with their new and extensive requirements under thediscovery statute, but through no fault of his or her own is unable to comply with every aspect ofthe automatic discovery rules specified in CPL 245.20.

Similarly, in People v Knight, another court addressed a situation in which the Peoplehad provided "a very few [additional] discovery items" to the defendant after filing theircertificate of compliance. (69 Misc 3d at 552.) The court concluded that "[t]heir absence from theoriginal certificate of compliance does not vitiate it," reasoning that, "[b]y any measure it wasfiled 'in good faith' and 'reasonable under the circumstances'" and, thus, was "valid."(Id.)

In this court's view, good faith and due diligence are the touchstones by which a certificate ofcompliance must be evaluated. Accordingly, upon a challenge to a certificate of compliance, thePeople must articulate their efforts to comply with CPL § 245.20(1) with respect to thestatutory subsections or specific items of discovery at issue. If the People establish that theyexercised due diligence and acted in good faith in filing their certificate, their certificate ofcompliance shall be deemed valid. This may be accomplished by recounting the steps they tookto obtain certain materials or ascertain the existence thereof, explaining the reasons whyparticular items are outstanding, lost or destroyed, and submitting their good-faith arguments forwhy certain materials are not discoverable under the statute. On the other hand, where the Peoplefail to set forth their efforts to locate items of discovery or determine that they do not exist, or theefforts they describe do not amount to due diligence, their certificate may be invalidated.



The Present Motion

In his motion, the defendant claims that the People's certificate of compliance is invalid,because the People failed to provide a number of items under three categories of discoveryrequired by CPL § 245.20(1): police paperwork (CPL § 245.20[1][e]), reports andother paperwork concerning scientific tests (CPL § 245.20[1][j]), and certain reports andother evidence required for Vehicle and Traffic Law offenses (CPL § 245.20[1][s]). In thePeople's response, they address each item in turn.

The People's opposition papers, however, only describe their efforts to obtain the missingmaterials with respect to a few items. And, even for these items, they provide little informationabout the steps they took to obtain the necessary materials before filing their certificate ofcompliance. Further, for many items, the People's explanation for the absence of discoverablematerial is merely that it was not or is not in their actual possession. In relying on this argument,however, the People repeatedly overlook the statutory provision (CPL § 245.20[2]) thatdeems all police paperwork to be in the possession of the prosecution. Thus, the assertion thatknown discovery materials are not in their physical possession does not in any way excuse theirfailure to provide them. For the reasons that follow, this court can only conclude that thecertificate filed by the People in this case was inadequate.

First, addressing several missing items in their opposition to the defendant's challenge, thePeople state only, "No such evidence or information is known at this time." (See People's[*4]Opposition, ¶ 2 [handwritten complaint worksheet],¶ 3 [typed complaint report], ¶ 4 [handwritten arrest report].) This bare assertion doesnot provide the court with any information from which it can assess the People's due diligenceand good faith in filing their certificate. It is entirely possible that these items do not exist in thiscase. The People, however, cannot merely rely on the fact that they do not know whether suchmaterial exists without articulating their attempts to discern whether the items exist and obtainthem. If the People determine that certain material does not, in fact, exist, they should explain theinquiries they made that led to that conclusion. For example, if the prosecutor had a conversationwith the arresting officer and the arresting officer advised them that he did not fill out ahand-written complaint, the People should say as much in their affirmation. On the other hand, iftheir search for the material was ultimately inconclusive, they should describe the search itself.

By itself, a failure to locate discovery material that may or may not exist would not invalidatea certificate of compliance, so long as the People demonstrated that they exercised due diligenceand good faith in seeking to find it. Indeed, in many cases a simple oversight may also beexcusable, so long as it is corrected and addressed with due diligence once it is brought to theprosecutor's attention. As discussed above, the absence of a few discovery items does not vitiatean otherwise-valid certificate of compliance. Consistent with that reasoning, it is not the absenceof these materials on its own that this court finds inadequate, but rather, the People's failure toprovide even a cursory explanation of why they are absent and how they sought to obtainthem. Without that information, the People have not provided the court with any basis on whichit could determine whether they exercised the requisite diligence.

Similarly, in the instances where the People do provide some explanation for missingdiscovery items in this case, it still falls short of evincing the diligence required by CPL §245. For example, the People address their failure to provide the command log from the 112thPrecinct as follows: "The People are not in possession of the command log from the 112thPrecinct and the People last requested the command log from PO Lewis on 4/16/21. Once thePeople receive the command log, the People will file a supplemental certificate of complianceand will turn over the command log." The People do not detail or even outline in summaryfashion their attempts, if any, to locate and disclose this material before filing their certificate ofcompliance. Indeed, the People do not describe any such attempts at any point in theirentire response with respect to any item. Nor do they offer some reason here why thecommand log was not provided at the time they filed their certificate — such as a lack ofawareness that this material even existed — that would excuse or mitigate the lapse.Further, they do not offer any legal argument that the material sought is outside the ambit of CPL§ 245.20(1)(e). Again, from this sparse description, it is impossible for the court to find thatthe People exercised due diligence with respect to obtaining this material.

Importantly, this is not to say that this specific item is in fact discoverable, though thePeople's response seems to concede that it is. Moreover, this determination should not be read toamount to a finding that a certificate of compliance should always be nullified because thePeople failed to provide something like a command log. On the contrary, in this court's view, thatwould rarely, if ever, be the case. Instead, the problem is not the missing material itself, but thePeople's cumulative failure to provide explanations of their efforts to comply with their discoveryobligations.

In that respect, they provide similarly meager explanations for the absence of two otheritems. (See People's Opposition, ¶ 1 [Report of Refusal], ¶ 7 [IDTU unit log]).While one such [*5]instance might not be an issue in the contextof an otherwise-sufficient response, the People's repeated failure to illuminate this court as totheir efforts in the furtherance of discovery compliance leaves the court without any basis onwhich it could find that this certificate met the standard set forth in CPL § 245.50.

As alluded to above, another recurring problem in the People's papers is their reliance on theassertion that certain materials are not in their possession. They do so with respect to nine of thefourteen items at issue in this challenge. (See People's Opposition, ¶ 1 [Report ofRefusal]; ¶ 6 [command log from the 112th Precinct]; ¶ 7 [IDTU unit log]; ¶ 9[tow receipts and paperwork for the vehicle]; ¶ 10 [dashboard camera video of theincident]; ¶ a [bench notes and laboratory information management system records for theportable breath test]; ¶ b[i] [maintenance and repair records and records of calibration forthe portable breath test]; ¶ b [ii] [maintenance and repair records and records of calibrationfor moving radar instrument]; ¶ b [iii] [proof of certification for Police Officer Lewis]).This argument is misguided.

As noted above, CPL § 245.20(2) states, "all items and information related to theprosecution of a charge in the possession of any New York state or local police or lawenforcement agency shall be deemed to be in the possession of the prosecution." Dovetailingwith that provision, CPL § 245.55(1) dictates that, "The district attorney and the assistantresponsible for the case, . . . shall endeavor to ensure that a flow of information is maintainedbetween the police and other investigative personnel and his or her office sufficient to placewithin his or her possession or control all material and information pertinent to the defendant andthe offense or offenses charged . . . ." Accordingly, all police paperwork is imputed to be in thePeople's control and it is the prosecutor's duty to work with the police to obtain such materials.As a result, it is never sufficient for the People to affirm that an item is not in their physicalpossession to defeat a certificate of compliance challenge. If the item at issue is policepaperwork, that argument must always fail. If it is not, the People should explain the nature ofthe material sought and make some legal argument for why the material is not in theirconstructive control. Here, the failure to do either renders this explanation insufficient.

With respect to two other items at issue, the People explain that they obtained them in thecourse of answering the defendant's motion and disclosed them in a supplemental certificate ofcompliance filed April 19, 2021, the same day the People filed their opposition papers. (SeePeople's Opposition, ¶ 5 [memo book of Police Officer Carney]; ¶ 8 [voucher forvehicle]). Under certain circumstances, this could be an entirely appropriate response, if thePeople demonstrated that they exercised due diligence but for some articulable reason could notobtain the specific materials before that point. Here, that is not the case. Once again, the People'sopposition papers are bereft of any explanation of why these materials were not provided withoriginal certificate of compliance. Nor do they provide an account of their efforts to get theseitems before filing their certificate. Even assuming that for some legitimate reason the Peoplecould not obtain these materials before filing their certificate, they fail to give any reason why ittook so long thereafter for them to disclose these materials. The People filed their originalcertificate on October 30, 2020, some six months ago, and supplemented it with these materialsjust last week. Although such a lag in disclosure could have a valid explanation in somescenarios, the People provide none here. This unexplained inaction invites the inference that thePeople made no attempt to obtain these items, which are not uncommon in any type ofprosecution, until faced with a certificate of compliance challenge and, even then, only did somore than two months after the defendant's motion challenging the certificate was filed. In any[*6]event, People have failed to establish that they exercised duediligence with respect to these items.

One final item that bears discussion is the dashboard-mounted camera video of the stop ofthe vehicle in this case. This evidence is not only undeniably discoverable, but also potentiallyextremely significant evidence for the defense at both the suppression hearing and trial.Nonetheless, in an apparent typo, the People offered only this as their explanation for itsnon-disclosure: "The People are not in possession of a dash cam video of the incident. As per thePeople's Certificate of Compliance dated October 30, 2020, the dash cam video from February28, 2019."

The sentence intended to explain the absence of this important evidence cuts offmid-thought. But in the People's original certificate of compliance, they designate the dashboardcamera video under the category of "[c]ertain materials [that] have been lost or destroyed."Neither in the certificate itself, nor in their motion response do the People explain how thisundoubtedly relevant evidence was either lost or destroyed. To be sure, as discussed above, acourt may find the People ready even where evidence has been lost or destroyed, "despite diligentand good faith efforts, reasonable under the circumstances." (CPL § 245.50[3].) Thatstandard was not met here. Because the validity of a certificate depends on its good faith as wellas due diligence, the People should have provided some explanation for this loss or destructionof evidence, especially considering the evidentiary value of a dashboard camera video in adriving while intoxicated case. Under these facts, the People's complete failure to address thisissue also undermines the validity of their certificate.

Finally, the certificate itself raises a number of concerns. Most troubling, the certificate ofcompliance repeatedly refers to a list of all materials disclosed to defense counsel, but the Peoplefailed to attach either the referenced list or a computer print-out logging their disclosures, as iscommon practice, to the certificate. This is a significant omission. CPL § 245.50(1)specifically requires that a certificate of compliance must "identify the items provided." Here, thePeople have failed to do so. Moreover, there are serious discrepancies between the certificate andthe People's assertions in their opposition to the challenge. In the People's certificate, theyaffirmed that they had electronically provided the defense with both "Complaint Report typed"and "Refusal Paperwork." In their opposition papers, however, the People state that they are notaware of the existence of a complaint report and that they do not possess the Report of Refusal.These inconsistencies cast serious doubt upon the accuracy of their certificate.

As discussed in detail above, by filing a certificate of compliance, a prosecutor is averringthat "after exercising due diligence and making reasonable inquiries to ascertain the existence ofmaterial and information subject to discovery, [he or she] has disclosed and made available allknown material and information subject to discovery." (CPL § 245.50[1].) In this case, thecourt cannot conclude that the People exercised due diligence and made reasonable inquiries toascertain the existence of material and information subject to discovery. Given the seriousdeficiencies in both the certificate of compliance and the People's explanation thereof, the courtfinds that it was not reasonable under the circumstances. Further, the court does not havesufficient information to determine whether it was filed in good faith. Indeed, the People havenot provided an adequate explanation for a single one of the missing items at issue. Accordingly,the court must conclude that the certificate is invalid and the People's concurrent statement ofreadiness was illusory.

For all these reasons, the defendant's motion to challenge the certificate of compliance is[*7]granted and the People are directed to comply with theirdiscovery obligations pursuant to CPL § 245.20(1) and file a new certificate as soon aspracticable.

This constitutes the decision and order of the court.

The Clerk of the court is directed to distribute copies of this decision and order to theattorney for the defendant and to the District Attorney.



Dated: April 29, 2021
_________________________
GENE R. LOPEZ,A.J.S.C.
Footnotes


Footnote 1: Curiously, CPL §245.80(b), part of the section of the discovery law addressing remedies and sanctions fornon-compliance, states, "When material or information is discoverable under this article butcannot be disclosed because it has been lost or destroyed, the court shall impose an appropriateremedy or sanction if the party entitled to disclosure shows that the lost material may havecontained some information relevant to a contested issue." Thus, this section addresses onlysituations in which material is "lost" or "destroyed," leaving unclear the meaning of "otherwiseunavailable" in CPL § 245.50(3).




NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.