| Matter of Meister (Commissioner of Labor) |
| 2007 NY Slip Op 06786 [43 AD3d 1243] |
| September 20, 2007 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of Elizabeth L. Meister, Appellant.Commissioner of Labor, Respondent. |
—[*1] Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, New York City (Mary Hughes of counsel), forrespondent.
Appeal from a decision of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, filed May 5, 2006,which, among other things, ruled that claimant was ineligible to receive unemployment insurancebenefits because she was not totally unemployed.
Claimant, a freelance video editor, applied for unemployment insurance benefits effectiveNovember 18, 2002 and January 11, 2005. The first claim covered the base period fromDecember 2, 2002 until February 9, 2003, and the second covered the base period from January10, 2005 until August 21, 2005. Both applications were granted and claimant received a total of$5,778.75 in benefits. During the time periods at issue, claimant engaged in activities infurtherance of promoting a film she had produced as part of her Master's thesis. She also wrotescreenplays and attended workshops as well as professional group meetings. As a result, theUnemployment Insurance Appeal Board ruled that she was ineligible to receive benefits becauseshe was not totally unemployed. It also charged her with a recoverable overpayment of benefitspursuant to Labor Law § 597 (4) and reduced her right to receive future benefits by 192days pursuant to Labor Law § 594. Claimant now appeals.
"It is well settled that a claimant who performs activities on behalf of an ongoing businesswill not be considered totally unemployed even if such activities are minimal, provided that theclaimant stands to benefit financially from the continued existence of the business" (Matter of Swan [Commissioner ofLabor], 40 AD3d 1295, 1295 [2007] [citation omitted]; see Matter of Brinn [Commissioner ofLabor], 38 AD3d 1080, 1080-1081 [2007]). Notably, "[t]he deduction of businessexpenses on a personal income tax return may constitute disqualifying [*2]income" (Matter of Whylie [Commissioner of Labor], 38 AD3d 1037, 1038[2007]; see Matter of Singer[Commissioner of Labor], 30 AD3d 928 [2006]). Here, during the first base period,claimant wrote checks to various film festivals for the purpose of promoting her film and tookdeductions for business expenses related thereto on her personal income tax returns. While sheceased this activity during the second base period, she worked on screenplays and attendedmeetings and functions of a professional group during this time. Claimant admitted to receivingan unemployment insurance handbook advising her of her obligation to report activities likely toproduce income, but maintained that she did not realize that the activities at issue constitutedwork that she was obligated to report. It was the province of the Board to evaluate the credibilityof her statements (see Matter ofArmbruster [Commissioner of Labor], 36 AD3d 1037, 1038 [2007]), and its denial ofbenefits on the ground that claimant was not totally unemployed is supported by substantialevidence.
The Board assessed a recoverable overpayment of $5,778.75 against claimant under theprovisions of Labor Law § 597. A majority of this assessed overpayment was attributableto claimant's January 2005 claim (see Labor Law § 597 [3]). To the extent that$1,316.25 was attributable to her November 2002 claim, the Board specifically found that hercertifications of no work "constitute[d] willful misrepresentations" such that the entire sum couldbe recouped under Labor Law § 597 (4) (see e.g. Matter of Valvo [Ross], 57 NY2d116, 127-128 [1982]; Matter of Kansu[Commissioner of Labor], 36 AD3d 1185, 1187 [2007]), and the forfeiture penaltyunder Labor Law § 594 was also proper (see e.g. Matter of Small [Commissioner of Labor], 23 AD3d 873,874 [2005]).
Peters, J.P., Spain, Carpinello, Mugglin and Rose, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision isaffirmed, without costs.