Mirkin v Mirkin
2007 NY Slip Op 06959 [43 AD3d 1115]
September 25, 2007
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, November 7, 2007


Lauren L. Mirkin, Respondent,
v
Gary Mirkin,Appellant.

—[*1]Harold, Salant, Strassfield & Spielberg, White Plains, N.Y. (Donna E. Abrams ofcounsel), for appellant.

Luis Andrew Penichet, White Plains, N.Y. (Jeanna M. Alberga of counsel), forrespondent.

In a matrimonial action in which the parties were divorced by judgment dated January 11,1999, the defendant appeals, as limited by his brief, from so much of an order of the SupremeCourt, Westchester County (Tolbert, J.), entered January 23, 2006, as, after a hearing, grantedthose branches of the plaintiff's motion which were to apply certain payments he received in theyears 2000 and 2004 toward his annual income for the purpose of calculating his requisite annualchild support payments, for child support arrears, and for an award of an attorney's fee, anddirected him to pay the sum of $275,364.99 in child support arrears, and the sum of $32,354.96as an attorney's fee.

Ordered that the order is affirmed insofar as appealed from, with costs.

The parties were divorced in 1999. Pursuant to the terms of the stipulation of settlement thatwas incorporated but not merged into the judgment of divorce, the defendant's child supportobligation was to be established on February 1st of each year in an amount equal to 25% of hisincome for the previous year. The stipulation obligates the defendant to "provide to theWife/Mother copies of his final annual pay stub and earnings report from all his employers so asto enable the parties to fairly and properly apply the twenty-five (25%) percent fraction to thethen current income so as to establish the correct child support amount by either increasing ordecreasing [*2]or maintaining the current payment, as each year'sincome performance dictates." It defines the term "income" by reference to the definition of thatterm in the Child Support Standards Act (Domestic Relations Law § 240 [1-b] [hereinafterthe CSSA]). The stipulation further provides that if the defendant defaulted in his obligations andfailed to cure the default within 15 days of notice, he was obligated to indemnify the plaintiff forany costs, including reasonable attorney's fees, that she incurs in successfully enforcing the termsof the stipulation.

A stipulation of settlement entered into by spouses in contemplation of divorce is a contractto be enforced according to its plain and ordinary meaning (see Awerman v Awerman, 36 AD3d 842, 843 [2007]; Fishler v Fishler, 2 AD3d 487, 488[2003]; Barna v Barna, 279 AD2d 441 [2001]). Under the CSSA, income consists of,among other things, "gross (total) income as should have been or should be reported in the mostrecent federal income tax return" (Domestic Relations Law § 240 [1-b] [b] [5] [i]). Theamounts in issue here, a $625,000 bonus the defendant received in 2000, and a $75,000 paymentreceived in 2004 as settlement of a lawsuit against his former employer, fall within thisdefinition, as evidenced by the fact that both were reported on the defendant's earningsstatements for the respective years (seeHolterman v Holterman, 3 NY3d 1, 10 [2004]; Matter of Graby v Graby, 87NY2d 605, 609-610 [1996]). Although certain nonrecurring income may be excluded incalculating the ongoing child support obligation of a noncustodial parent (see Gina P. v Stephen S., 33 AD3d412, 414 [2006]; Skinner v Skinner, 271 AD2d 679, 680 [2000]; O'Connor vO'Connor, 241 AD2d 648, 649 [1997]; Huebscher v Huebscher, 206 AD2d 295, 296[1994]), the stipulation of settlement at issue here requires that the defendant's child supportobligation be recalculated each year on the basis of his actual income for the previous year. TheSupreme Court correctly concluded, therefore, that the stipulation of settlement required theinclusion of these amounts in the defendant's income for the purpose of defining his child supportobligation for the years in question.

Contrary to the defendant's argument, Domestic Relations Law § 240 (1-b) (e) is notcontrolling here. That provision permits a court to allocate a portion of a parent's nonrecurringincome to child support (see Matter of Cody v Evans-Cody, 291 AD2d 27, 30 [2001];LaBombardi v LaBombardi, 220 AD2d 642, 644 [1995]). It does not alter the definitionof income to which the stipulation refers. In any event, the amounts in issue here do notconstitute "non-recurring payments from extraordinary sources not otherwise considered asincome pursuant to this section" (Domestic Relations Law § 240 [1-b] [e]).

The Supreme Court also correctly concluded that the defendant's willful default in failing toprovide his earnings statement and to pay child support as required by the terms of the stipulationof settlement warranted the award of attorney's fees (see Shanon v Patterson, 38 AD3d 519 [2007]; Sieratzki v Sieratzki, 8 AD3d 552,554 [2004]; Matter of Tito v Tito, 276 AD2d 559, 560 [2000]; Zeitlin v Zeitlin,250 AD2d 607, 608-609 [1998]). The defendant's argument that an attorney's fee should havebeen denied to the plaintiff because he incurred the additional cost of a second hearing allegedlyas a result of the plaintiff's fault does not abrogate his contractual obligation to indemnify her forthe expenses she incurred in enforcing the stipulation.

Motion by the respondent on an appeal from an order of the of the Supreme Court,Westchester County, entered January 23, 2006, to strike the appellant's reply brief on the groundthat it contains matter dehors the record, and for an award of costs. By decision and order onmotion of this Court dated April 30, 2007, the motion was held in abeyance and was referred tothe Justices hearing the appeal for determination upon the argument or submission thereof.

Upon the papers filed in support of the motion, the papers filed in opposition thereto, andupon the submission of the appeal, it is

Ordered that the motion is denied. Spolzino, J.P., Ritter, Dillon and Dickerson, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.