| Chiarizia v Xtreme Rydz Custom Cycles |
| 2007 NY Slip Op 07160 [43 AD3d 1353] |
| September 28, 2007 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
| Richard Chiarizia, Appellant, v Xtreme Rydz Custom Cycles et al.,Defendants, and Fournier's Automotive, Inc., Doing Business as Xtreme Rydz of Orlando,Respondent. |
—[*1]
Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Onondaga County (Thomas J. Murphy, J.),entered June 14, 2006 in a personal injury action. The order granted the motion of defendantFournier's Automotive, Inc., doing business as Xtreme Rydz of Orlando, seeking dismissal of thecomplaint against it.
It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from be and the same hereby is unanimouslyaffirmed without costs.
Memorandum: Plaintiff commenced this action seeking damages for injuries he sustainedwhen the handlebars of his motorcycle broke off while he was riding it. Plaintiff purchased themotorcycle in Florida from Fournier's Automotive, Inc., doing business as Xtreme Rydz ofOrlando (defendant), and at that time he signed a document entitled "Disclaimer of Safety andWaiver of Liability." That document provides in relevant part that "[p]urchaser agrees that anylegal action or litigation against Fournier's Automotive Inc. or Xtreme Rydz of Orlando, will besubmitted only in Orange County, Florida." We conclude that Supreme Court properly grantedthe motion of defendant seeking dismissal of the complaint against it based upon that forumselection clause.
A contractual forum selection clause is "prima facie valid and enforceable unless it is shownby the challenging party to be unreasonable, unjust, in contravention of public policy, invalid dueto fraud or overreaching, or it is shown that a trial in the selected forum would be so gravelydifficult that the challenging party would, for all practical purposes, be deprived of its day incourt" (Premium Risk Group v Legion Ins. Co., 294 AD2d 345, 346 [2002]; see BellConstructors v Evergreen Caissons, 236 AD2d 859, 860 [1997]). We note in addition that aperson who " 'signs a document is conclusively bound by its terms absent a valid excuse forhaving failed to read it' " (Fleet CapitalLeasing/Global Vendor Fin. v Angiuli Motors, Inc., 15 AD3d 535, 536 [2005]).
Here, plaintiff's sole challenge to the forum selection clause was that New York was themore convenient forum because all of the witnesses and the motorcycle itself are located in NewYork, and it would be a great economic hardship on him to pay for all of the witnesses to travel[*2]to Florida for a trial of this action. That challenge isinsufficient, however, because plaintiff has failed to demonstrate that enforcement of the forumselection clause would, in effect, deny him his day in court, and he has failed to allege that theclause was the result of fraud or overreaching (see Bell Constructors, 236 AD2d at 860).The fact that New York may be a more convenient forum is immaterial because defendant'smotion is based on the parties' contract and not on the doctrine of forum non conveniens (cf.Islamic Republic of Iran v Pahlavi, 62 NY2d 474, 477 [1984], cert denied 469 US1108 [1985]; Allen v Marais, S.A., 307 AD2d 613 [2003]). Plaintiff contends for the firsttime on appeal that, pursuant to the General Business Law and the Uniform Commercial Code,the document at issue is void as against public policy and thus that the forum selection clause isalso unenforceable. That contention is not preserved for our review (see Earley v Town ofAllegany, 298 AD2d 906, 907 [2002], lv denied 7 NY3d 713 [2006]) and, in anyevent, it is without merit. " 'Whether a contract is entire or severable generally is a question ofintention, to be determined from the language employed by the parties, viewed in the light of thecircumstances surrounding them at the time they contracted' " (Barden & Robeson Corp. vTimmerman, 116 AD2d 814, 815-816 [1986], quoting Christian v Christian, 42NY2d 63, 73 [1977]). The document at issue contains several discrete provisions that are notintertwined, and we conclude therefrom that the parties intended that each of those provisions isseverable. Thus, even if the waiver of liability provision of the disclaimer is unenforceable, theforum selection clause remains viable (see Scavenger, Inc. v GT Interactive Software,273 AD2d 60, 61 [2000]).Plaintiff's remaining contention is not preserved for our review and is, in any event, withoutmerit. Present—Hurlbutt, J.P., Martoche, Smith, Lunn and Peradotto, JJ.