| Chase v Coleman |
| 2007 NY Slip Op 08149 [45 AD3d 936] |
| November 1, 2007 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| George W. Chase, Appellant, v Marianna Coleman,Respondent. |
—[*1] Ward & Murphy, Groton (Liam G.B. Murphy of counsel), for respondent.
Kane, J. Appeal from an order of the County Court of Tompkins County (Rowley, J.),entered June 20, 2006, which affirmed a judgment of the City Court of the City of Ithaca in favorof defendant.
From the late 1980s through approximately 2000, defendant rented an apartment fromplaintiff's wife. Before her death in 1998, plaintiff's wife handled all business pertaining to theapartment. In 1999, plaintiff replaced a water pump which he alleges was damaged bydefendant's actions. He also contends that defendant damaged windows, ceiling tiles and a wallwhile she lived there. In 2005, plaintiff commenced this small claims action. City Court foundthat the action was untimely and, in the alternative, that defendant did not cause the propertydamage. On plaintiff's appeal, County Court affirmed, prompting plaintiff's appeal to this Court.
Plaintiff did not present evidence of a written lease nor of the terms of any oral lease.Likewise, plaintiff failed to present sufficient proof that the damage to the apartment was causedby defendant's intentional or negligent acts. We are satisfied that City Court did substantialjustice between the parties according to the rules and principles of substantive law, and that itsjudgment is not clearly erroneous (see UCCA 1804, 1807; Sten v Desrocher, 8 AD3d915[*2][2004]).
Crew III, J.P., Mugglin, Rose and Lahtinen, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is affirmed,without costs.