| Matter of Justice v Gamache |
| 2007 NY Slip Op 08304 [45 AD3d 508] |
| November 5, 2007 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Michael Justice et al., Appellants, v DavidGamache et al., Respondents. (Proceeding No. 1.) In the Matter of Marlene Fredericks,Appellant, v David Gamache et al., Respondents. (Proceeding No.2.) |
—[*1]
In related proceedings pursuant to Election Law § 16-102, inter alia, to invalidate threecertificates of disqualification filed with the Dutchess County Board of Elections by LeeKyriacou, nominated as a candidate of the Democratic Party, Working Families Party, andBeacon First Party for the public office of Member of the City Council, At Large, City ofBeacon, in a general election to be held on November 6, 2007, and to invalidate three certificatesof substitution filed with the Dutchess County Board of Elections by the Democratic Party,Working Families Party, and Beacon First Party, respectively, nominating Eleanor Thompson tofill the vacancy created by the disqualification of Lee Kyriacou, the petitioners appeal from afinal order of the Supreme Court, Dutchess County (Dolan, J.), dated October 26, 2007, which, ineffect, denied the petitions and dismissed the proceedings.
Ordered that the final order is modified, on the law, by deleting the provision thereof denyingthose branches of the petitions which were to invalidate the certificate of substitution filed withthe Dutchess County Board of Elections by the Working Families Party nominating EleanorThompson to fill the vacancy created by the disqualification of Lee Kyriacou, and substitutingtherefor a provision granting those branches of the petitions; as so modified, the final [*2]order is affirmed, without costs or disbursements.
Lee Kyriacou, a Member of the City Council, At Large, City of Beacon, since 1993, acceptedthe nomination of the Democratic Party, Working Families Party, and Beacon First Party to runfor reelection in the general election to be held on November 6, 2007. On September 15, 2007,Kyriacou was appointed by the Governor to the position of Executive Director of New YorkState Office of Real Property Services. Kyriacou accepted the position, which was in Albany, andwas informed by the Governor's office that he would be required to resign from his position onthe City Council to avoid any potential conflict. As a result, on September 28, 2007, Kyriacoufiled three certificates of disqualification with the Dutchess County Board of Elections indicatingthat he had been "disqualified from running for said office by reason of moving and no longerresiding in said district with no intention of returning prior to the date of the General Election,November 6, 2007." Shortly thereafter, the Democratic Party, Working Families Party, andBeacon First Party, respectively, filed three certificates of substitution nominating EleanorThompson to fill the vacancy created by Kyriacou's disqualification. Subsequently, thepetitioners commenced the instant proceedings to invalidate the certificates of disqualification onthe ground that Kyriacou fraudulently stated that he was no longer a resident of the City ofBeacon at the time he filed those documents with the Dutchess County Board of Elections. Inaddition, the petitioners sought, inter alia, to invalidate the certificate of substitution filed withthe Dutchess County Board of Elections by the Working Families Party on the basis that therewas no affidavit of consent from Thompson appended to the certificate. The Supreme Court, ineffect, denied the petitions and dismissed the proceedings.
A nominated candidate who seeks to disqualify himself or herself (see Election Law§ 6-148 [1]), must present a legal basis for doing so (see generally Matter of Aurelio vCohen, 266 App Div 603, 606 [1943], affd 291 NY 645 [1943]; 49 NYJurisprudence 2d, Elections § 277). One such basis may be that the candidate will notsatisfy the residency requirement at the time of the general election (see Public OfficersLaw § 3 [1]; Matter of Keith v King, 220 AD2d 471, 471-472 [1995]; Matter ofClark v McCoy, 196 AD2d 607 [1993]). The term "residence" is defined as "that place wherea person maintains a fixed, permanent and principal home and to which he, wherever temporarilylocated, always intends to return" (Election Law § 1-104 [22]; see Matter of Hosley vCurry, 85 NY2d 447, 451 [1995]; Matter of Fernandez v Monegro, 10 AD3d 429 [2004]).
We do not read the certificates of disqualification as narrowly as the petitioners would haveus, that is, that Kyriacou stated he was no longer a resident of the City of Beacon at the time hefiled those documents. Rather, a fair reading of those documents reveals that Kyriacou indicatedthat he would no longer be able to satisfy the residency requirement at the time of the generalelection, a statement which is supported by the evidence presented. Specifically, Kyriacouresigned from his position on the Beacon City Council effective October 17, 2007, andcommenced his position with the State two days later. He began living in an apartment in Troywith his daughter, who was attending high school in the area. Moreover, he registered to vote inRensselaer County (cf. Matter of Camardi v Sinawski, 297 AD2d 357, 358 [2002]).Accordingly, the certificates of disqualification were valid and were not permeated with fraud.
Election Law § 6-148 (5) requires that a certificate to fill a vacancy "shall haveappended thereto" the substituted candidate's "written consent to be so designated or nominated,duly acknowledged." Here, with the certificate of substitution of the Working Families Partyfiled with the Dutchess County Board of Elections on October 2, 2007, there was no affidavit"appended thereto" from Thompson consenting to the nomination. Although three days later theWorking [*3]Families Party attempted to cure this defect by filingan affidavit from Thompson consenting to the nomination, that document was not appended to acompleted certificate of substitution. In both instances, the Working Families Party failed tocomply with the requirements of Election Law § 6-148 (5). Contrary to the respondents'contention that these two separate filings should be considered together, where, as here, thematter is "of prescribed content," there must be strict compliance with the statutory requirements(see Matter of Rhodes v Salerno, 57 NY2d 885, 887 [1982]; Matter of Hutson v Bass,54 NY2d 772, 774 [1981]; Matter of Flach v De Benedictus, 265 AD2d 670, 671[1999]). Accordingly, the certificate of substitution filed by the Working Families Partynominating Thompson to fill the vacancy created by Kyriacou's disqualification must beinvalidated (see Matter of Flach v De Benedictus, 265 AD2d 670 [1999]; Matter ofFarley v Mahoney, 115 AD2d 350 [1985]; Matter of Scott v Curran, 277 App Div344, 345 [1950], affd 301 NY 693 [1950]; see also Diaz v New York City Bd. ofElections, 335 F Supp 2d 364, 366-367 [2004]).
The petitioners' remaining contentions are without merit. Schmidt, J.P., Rivera, Florio andBalkin, JJ., concur.