Matter of Tadasky Corp. v Village of Ellenville
2007 NY Slip Op 09156 [45 AD3d 1131]
November 21, 2007
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, January 16, 2008


In the Matter of Tadasky Corporation, Petitioner, v Village ofEllenville, Respondent.

—[*1]J. Philip Zand, New Paltz, for petitioner.

Collier & Berger, P.L.L.C., Accord (Philip M. Cataldi of counsel), for respondent.

Carpinello, J. Proceeding initiated in this Court pursuant to EDPL 207 to review adetermination of respondent which condemned a portion of petitioner's land for the completionof a village park.

Petitioner commenced this proceeding pursuant to EDPL 207 seeking to annul respondent'sdetermination to condemn a portion of its property for use as a public park. In the petition, it isclaimed that respondent failed to comply with all statutory directives in condemning the propertybecause no record of the public hearing was kept and because an inadequate description of theproperty was provided at such hearing. It is further alleged in the petition that respondent had animproper motive for acquiring the property. In answering the petition and moving to dismiss it,respondent replied to each of these challenges. In its brief to this Court, petitioner raises for thefirst time an additional challenge, namely, that respondent failed to provide proof of propernotice of the hearing.

We reject petitioner's argument that respondent failed to comply with all statutory [*2]directives in conducting the hearing. EDPL 203 does require that"[a] record of the hearing shall be kept." Here, minutes of the public hearing were indeedrecorded by respondent's clerk. Moreover, these minutes reflect that the scope and purpose of theproposed acquisition were reviewed by respondent's attorney, that a "public response" wassolicited, that petitioner's attorney spoke on its behalf and that the hearing was thereafter closed.To the extent that petitioner argues that respondent had an obligation to actually transcribe eachword of the public hearing and/or take "testimony" at it, there is simply no statutory requirementto do so. Rather, as noted by the Court of Appeals in Matter of Jackson v New York StateUrban Dev. Corp. (67 NY2d 400 [1986]): "[N]othing in article 2 of the EDPL requires atrial-type hearing to challenge a tentative decision to condemn. To the contrary, EDPL 203provides only that 'any person in attendance [at a hearing] shall be given a reasonable opportunityto present an oral or written statement and to submit other documents concerning the proposedpublic project' " (id. at 424). Here, the minutes of the hearing reflect that petitioner wasindeed given this opportunity.

We also find that the description of the property to be condemned was in all respectsadequate (see EDPL 204 [B] [2]). We find this particular argument on petitioner's part tobe disingenuous since its president had been involved in unsuccessful negotiations withrespondent over the very property being condemned for quite some time before the decision toacquire it through condemnation was made. Moreover, there is no indication in the minutes ofthe public hearing that petitioner was somehow uncertain about the scope of the proposedacquisition. To the contrary, there is a notation that his attorney made specific reference to "thepiece of property in question" in discussing petitioner's objection to the acquistion. We likewisereject the contention that there was an inadequate showing that "a public use, benefit or purposewill be served by the proposed acquisition" (EDPL 207 [C] [4]; see EDPL 204 [B] [1]).Respondent sufficiently established that the declared use of the property—to expand anadjacent public park area—will serve a legitimate public purpose (see e.g. Matter of Woodfield Equities LLCv Incorporated Vil. of Patchogue, 28 AD3d 488, 490 [2006]).

As a final matter, we find that petitioner's challenge to notice in this proceeding is notproperly before us as this precise issue was not timely raised in the petition (see EDPL207 [A]). In any event, petitioner readily concedes that it received timely notice of the hearingand has demonstrated no prejudice as a result of the alleged failure to file proof of publication ofthe notice of the hearing. Thus, any alleged notice deficiency is not fatal to respondent'sdetermination (see Matter of Erie Blvd.Hydropower, L.P. v Stuyvesant Falls Hydro Corp., 30 AD3d 641, 644 [2006], appealdismissed 7 NY3d 843 [2006], lv denied 7 NY3d 718 [2006]; Matter of City of Mechanicville v Town ofHalfmoon, 23 AD3d 897, 899-900 [2005]; Matter of Engels v Village ofPotsdam, 285 AD2d 699 [2001]; see also EDPL 202 [D]).

Cardona, P.J., Mercure, Peters and Spain, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.