| Russo-Martorana v Theophilakos |
| 2007 NY Slip Op 09840 [46 AD3d 1047] |
| December 13, 2007 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| Monica Russo-Martorana et al., Respondents, v DenoTheophilakos, Respondent, and Town of Lloyd, Appellant. |
—[*1] Anthony M. Barraco, P.C., Highland (Anthony M. Barraco of counsel), for MonicaRusso-Martorana and another, respondents. Eisenberg & Kirsch, Saratoga Springs (Jeffrey D. Wait of counsel), for Deno Theophilakos,respondent.
Lahtinen, J. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Zwack, J.), entered January 26,2007 in Ulster County, which denied a motion by defendant Town of Lloyd for summaryjudgment dismissing the complaint against it.
This case arises from a motor vehicle accident between plaintiff Monica Russo-Martorana(hereinafter plaintiff) and defendant Deno Theophilakos (hereinafter defendant) at the Yintersection of two rural roads in the Town of Lloyd, Ulster County. In addition to suing thedriver of the other vehicle, plaintiff included the Town as a defendant contending that the Yintersection was not reasonably safe for travelers. The Town's motion for summary judgment wasdenied and it now appeals.
It is well-settled law that "[m]unicipalities owe a nondelegable duty to the public to constructand maintain their roads in a reasonably safe condition" (Temple v Chenango County,[*2]228 AD2d 938, 938 [1996]; see Gutelle v City of NewYork, 55 NY2d 794, 795 [1981]; Hill v Town of Reading, 18 AD3d 913, 915-916 [2005]). This dutyis fulfilled if a " 'highway may be said to be reasonably safe for people who obey the rules of theroad' " (Duger v Estate of Carey, 295 AD2d 878, 878-879 [2002], quoting Tomassi vTown of Union, 46 NY2d 91, 97 [1978]). If factual issues exist regarding a breach of thisduty, summary judgment nevertheless is appropriate when the proof negates proximate cause as amatter of law (see Abair v Town of N.Elba, 35 AD3d 935, 936 [2006]; Howard v Tylutki, 305 AD2d 907, 908 [2003]).
The subject Y intersection is comprised of two Town roads, Bellevue Road and ClearwaterRoad. Bellevue Road forms the base and left arm of the Y, with the right arm of the Y beingClearwater Road. The section of Bellevue Road forming the base of the Y is on the north side ofthe intersection and, just prior to the accident, defendant was on that section traveling south at thesame time that plaintiff was traveling in a general northerly direction on Clearwater Road.Immediately before the intersection, a southbound traveler on Bellevue Road would start bearingto the right and, if desiring to continue on Bellevue Road (as was defendant's intent), must thenturn to the left (although at somewhat less than a 90-degree angle). A southbound traveler onBellevue Road who plans to go onto Clearwater Road basically encounters a continuous gentlearch to the right. A northbound traveler on Clearwater Road does not have a stop or yield sign atthe intersection and, likewise, a southbound traveler on Bellevue Road encounters no signage. Anorthbound traveler on the arm of Bellevue Road (i.e., the section south of the intersection) doeshave a stop sign. Visibility is poor in the area of the Y intersection because of the curves, narrowroads and tree growth near the roads. Unfortunately, both drivers entered the intersection at thesame time, resulting in the subject accident.
Construing the evidence most favorably to the nonmovants (see e.g. Card v Brown, 43 AD3d594, 595 [2007]), there is a genuine issue as the whether the configuration of the roads andlack of signage created reasonable confusion as to who had the right-of-way. Plaintiff, who hadlived near the accident site for 17 or 18 years, believed she was free to proceed from ClearwaterRoad onto Bellevue Road without stopping. She did not have a stop or yield sign and the layoutof the roads apparently gave the appearance of a continuous road when approaching theintersection on Clearwater Road. Moreover, as the traveler on the right, she generally would havethe right-of-way over one bearing left across the road (see Vehicle and Traffic Law§§ 1140, 1141). On the other hand, defendant (who occasionally traveled these roadsprior to the accident) was staying on Bellevue Road through the intersection; a continuous roadwith no warning that bearing to the left to stay on the same road required a yield to theintersecting road. Interestingly, the Town's highway superintendent, Frank Lombardi (who hadheld that position for 16 years), opined that a vehicle traveling south on Bellevue Road andstaying on Bellevue Road through the intersection would have the right-of-way over oneproceeding north from Clearwater Road. Upon questioning at his deposition, Lombardiacknowledged the feasibility of confusion caused by the prevailing configuration and lack ofsignage.
The proof in the record reveals the unusual situation of two people who were familiar withthe intersection having reasonable divergent opinions as to the appropriate right-of-way and,thus, unlike many situations, familiarity of the roads by the drivers does not negate proximatecause as to the municipality. It is also apparent from review of the proof submitted by the partiesthat it cannot be said that this Y intersection was reasonably safe for prudent drivers as a matterof law.
Cardona, P.J., Mugglin, Rose and Kane, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is affirmed, withone bill of costs.