MacDonald v New York State Olympic Regional Dev. Auth.
2007 NY Slip Op 09862 [46 AD3d 1085]
December 13, 2007
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 13, 2008


Patricia C. MacDonald et al., Respondents, v New York StateOlympic Regional Development Authority et al., Appellants.

—[*1]Roemer, Wallens & Mineaux, L.L.P., Albany (Matthew J. Kelly of counsel), forappellants.

Brennan & White, L.L.P., Queensbury (Daniel J. Stewart of counsel), forrespondents.

Cardona, P.J. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Dawson, J.), entered March 7,2006 in Essex County, which denied defendants' motion for summary judgment dismissing thecomplaint.

Plaintiff Patricia C. MacDonald (hereinafter plaintiff) was injured in December 2003 in theVillage of Lake Placid, Essex County, when, while wearing ice skates, she stepped off theSheffield Speedskating Oval and into the area inside the skating oval. Plaintiff was attempting toreach a bonfire located inside the skating oval and the benches surrounding it; however, her skateapparently became caught on the interior surface and she fell, breaking her ankle. Plaintiff andher husband, derivatively, commenced this action claiming that defendants, which own andoperate the skating oval, negligently allowed a dangerous condition to exist on the premises andfailed to warn patrons of its existence. Specifically, they contend, among other things, thatdefendants failed to properly maintain the surface inside the skating oval, failed to close off theinterior, and failed to warn of its condition or of a two-inch differential between the surface ofthe skating oval and the interior.

Defendants moved for summary judgment dismissing the complaint, arguing that they [*2]had no duty to maintain the interior area, that its condition wasopen and obvious and thus required no warning, and that plaintiff assumed the risk by choosingto walk across the ungroomed interior rather than using the designated path to the bonfire area.Supreme Court rejected defendants' contention that they owed no duty to plaintiffs, and foundthat questions of fact existed on the issues of whether defendants breached their duty either byfailing to maintain the area or by failing to warn of its condition. The court also found questionsof fact as to whether plaintiff assumed the risk of injury when she left the skating oval.Accordingly, the court denied the motion, and defendants now appeal.

We agree with Supreme Court that defendants owed plaintiff "a duty of reasonable careunder the circumstances to maintain their property in a safe condition" (Tagle v Jakob, 97NY2d 165, 168 [2001]; see Galindo vTown of Clarkstown, 2 NY3d 633, 636 [2004]), including that part of the propertywhere the injury occurred, since it is undisputed that defendants were aware that skaters crossedthe interior to approach the bonfire area from different directions, not always using thedesignated path. We further agree with Supreme Court that questions of fact preclude summaryjudgment dismissing the complaint. In general, it is for the factfinder to determine "whether andto what extent a particular duty was breached" (Tagle v Jakob, 97 NY2d at 168; seeMacDonald v City of Schenectady, 308 AD2d 125, 127 [2003]). Here, whether the interiorarea where the accident occurred was properly maintained under thecircumstances—considering prevailing weather conditions, the level of lighting, thepurported differential between the two surfaces and any other relevant factors—presents aquestion of fact.

We further note that whether the allegedly hazardous condition of the interior area was openand obvious is also disputed, and bears on whether defendants had a duty to warn of suchcondition (see MacDonald v City of Schenectady, 308 AD2d at 128; Leckanby vCohoes Community Ctr., 299 AD2d 625, 625 [2002]). And finally, the foregoingconsiderations, along with the foreseeability of the hazard, also bear on the applicability of thedoctrine of assumption of the risk (see Turcotte v Fell, 68 NY2d 432, 439 [1986]; Tuttle v TRC Enters., Inc., 38 AD3d992, 993 [2007]). Accordingly, Supreme Court properly denied defendants' motion forsummary judgment.

Crew III, Peters, Spain and Carpinello, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is affirmed,without costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.