| Matter of Siepierski v New York State & Local RetirementSys. |
| 2007 NY Slip Op 10456 [46 AD3d 1316] |
| December 27, 2007 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Paul Siepierski, Petitioner, v New York State andLocal Retirement System, Respondent. |
—[*1] Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, Albany (William E. Storrs of counsel), forrespondent.
Mugglin, J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order of theSupreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination of the Comptroller whichdenied petitioner's application for additional service credit in the calculation of his retirementbenefits.
Petitioner, a member of respondent, seeks review of the Comptroller's determination that heis not entitled to retirement service credit for the period of December 18, 1984 through February11, 1994, during which he worked for the Niagara Frontier Transportation Authority (hereinafterNFTA). Petitioner obtained the position at issue with the assistance of an employment agency,EGW Associates, Inc., and began working for NFTA in December 1984.
At all times relevant to the instant proceeding, petitioner's salary was paid by EGW oranother employment agency, Superior Design, and the funds were drawn from the pertinentagency's bank account. Although petitioner worked on NFTA's premises, was issued anemployee identification card and was supervised by NFTA employees, petitioner's wage and taxstatements indicate that he was, in fact, employed by either EGW or Superior Design for the[*2]years in question. Additionally, petitioner acknowledges thathis term of employment was not continuous in nature due to NFTA's imposition of unpaid,involuntary leave at various times.
After respondent rejected petitioner's application for retirement service credit, petitionerrequested an administrative hearing and determination. Following the hearing, the HearingOfficer determined that petitioner was not an employee during the subject time period and, assuch, was not entitled to service credit. The Comptroller adopted the Hearing Officer's findingsof fact and conclusions of law, and petitioner's CPLR article 78 proceeding was transferred tothis Court (see CPLR 7804 [g]).
Petitioner claims that he engaged in paid "[g]overnment service" as defined in Retirementand Social Security Law § 2 (11) and was an employee of NFTA. As an initial matter, "theComptroller has the 'exclusive authority to determine all applications for any form of retirementor benefit,' and those determinations must be upheld if supported by substantial evidence"(Matter of Meegan v New York State Retirement Sys., 285 AD2d 892, 893 [2001],quoting Matter of Jarek v McCall, 268 AD2d 654, 655 [2000]; see Retirementand Social Security Law § 74 [b]; Matter of Douroyiannis v New York State & LocalEmpls. Retirement Sys., 261 AD2d 776, 776-777 [1999]).
Under Retirement and Social Security Law § 41 (c) (1), "[a] member who has notpreviously been a member [of respondent] may purchase credit . . . for all allowablemember service." Where, as here, an individual seeks credit for "[g]overnment service,"Retirement and Social Security Law § 2 (11) requires the petitioner to show that he or sheprovided "[p]aid service" as an employee of a participating employer in one of the state'sretirement systems (see Retirement and Social Security Law § 2 [8]). Here, theparties do not dispute that NFTA is a participating employer (see Public Authorities Law§ 1299-c). Thus, the outcome of the instant proceeding hinges entirely upon review of theComptroller's finding that petitioner did not provide paid service within the meaning ofRetirement and Social Security Law § 2 (11).
In our view, to resolve this issue, it was entirely rational for the Comptroller to consider, as amajor determinative factor, whether petitioner was on the payroll of a participating publicemployer (see Matter of Catena v New York State Employees' Retirement Sys., 91 AD2d1138, 1139 [1983]). Moreover, while there is evidence that supports petitioner's claim that hewas an employee of NFTA, we are unable to conclude that substantial evidence does not supportthe Comptroller's decision to the contrary (see Matter of Meegan v New York StateRetirement Sys., 285 AD2d at 893). Petitioner's reliance on Matter of Fay v Regan(97 AD2d 192, 195 [1983]) is misplaced. There, because the petitioning harness racing judgeswere hired directly by the State Harness Racing Commission, the Comptroller did not disputethat the Commission exercised sufficient control to warrant a finding of an employer-employeerelationship. Moreover, that case does not support petitioner's argument that since he was paid byfunds from the public treasury, simply processed through the employment agency, he should bedeemed to be in the paid service of a participating employer. While the source of the funds maybe an indicator, it is not determinative. In Fay, whether the petitioners were paid by theindividual track associations or by the state, which was then reimbursed by assessment againsteach racing association, the source of the funds was never the public treasury.
Crew III, J.P., Peters, Spain and Carpinello, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.