People v Garcia
2007 NY Slip Op 10467 [46 AD3d 461]
December 27, 2007
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 13, 2008


The People of the State of New York, Appellant,
v
PedroGarcia, Respondent. The People of the State of New York, Appellant, v Betzayda Melendez,Respondent.

—[*1]Robert T. Johnson, District Attorney, Bronx (Lawrence H. Cunningham of counsel), forappellant.

Richard M. Greenberg, Office of the Appellate Defender, New York City (Sara Gurwitch ofcounsel), for Pedro Garcia, respondent.

Robert S. Dean, Center for Appellate Litigation, New York City (David J. Klem of counsel),for Betzayda Melendez, respondent.

Order, Supreme Court, Bronx County (Steven Lloyd Barrett, J.), entered November 2, 2006,which granted defendants' CPL 440.10 motions to vacate judgments, rendered November 15,2002, convicting defendants, after a jury trial, of kidnapping in the second degree andendangering the welfare of a child, and imposing sentence, unanimously affirmed.

The court correctly found that the People violated their obligation to turn over materialfavorable to the defense (see Brady v Maryland, 373 US 83 [1963]) and that defendantswere thereby prejudiced. The court properly found that the prosecution wilfully suppressedevidence, in their possession, from flight attendants that contradicted the complainant's claim thatshe created a disturbance and vociferously protested to the attendants that she was being takenagainst her will by defendant Melendez on a flight to Puerto Rico. In opposing defendants'motions to vacate, the People did not dispute defendants' allegations, supported by the affidavitsof all of the flight attendants, that each of the flight attendants had informed the prosecution priorto trial that no such incident had taken place. To the contrary, the Assistant District Attorney whotried the case expressly acknowledged that he had spoken by telephone or in person with eachflight attendant prior to the trial, and that after being told of an alleged incident in which a13-year-old child aboard the flight "cried out for help, and physically grabbed one of the flightattendants, each flight attendant responded that if the incident had happened that way, she wouldhave remembered it." With respect to the one flight attendant he interviewed in person prior totrial, the Assistant District Attorney affirmed that his "recollection of this interview is thatgenerally, [she] insisted that no such incident could have occurred on any flight she workedbecause, if it had, she would have remembered it."

The suppressed evidence was clearly favorable to the defense as it was inconsistent with afundamental aspect of the People's case, namely, that Leslie, the then-13-year-old complainant,[*2]was physically restrained by defendants and forced onto aplane by Melendez. The People's theory was not that the child had acquiesced in beingtransported but that such acquiescence was ineffective because she lacked legal capacity. Instead,the People's case was tried on the theory that defendants used physical force, and that the childactively resisted. Accordingly, it is unnecessary to decide whether, and under whatcircumstances, kidnapping can be committed with an underage victim's acquiescence (seePenal Law § 135.00 [1] [b]). The testimony of the flight attendants would have provided amarkedly different account of the events on the airplane, and would have significantly impeachedthe complainant's credibility.

With respect to the issue of prejudice, we adopt the reasoning of the trial court in thecomprehensive written opinion it issued in granting defendants' motions to vacate. As JusticeBarrett stated: "[T]his meaningful impeachment evidence may well have proven determinative tothe evaluation of a case in which serious doubts coexisted with the chilling accusations and inwhich the key witness' credibility was under attack. Leslie's account of how she was kidnappedand held hostage in the very building where she lived with her mother, her mother's boyfriend,and her three siblings presented an unusual scenario, wherein 'kidnappers' choose to 'hide' theirvictim for a full year just two floors from the apartment where her family lived. The question ofmotive similarly is baffling. According to her own testimony, Leslie had a perfectly amicablerelationship with the Garcias, had had no prior disputes with them, and considered the Garcia's[sic] daughter to be her very best friend. Further, during the entire twelve months thatLeslie was held captive, no ransom demands were received and no one heard a word from thekidnappers. Leslie's account of her year-long captivity in the boiler room also had curiousaspects. She claimed that escape was impossible because the door was secured by four locks andthe windows were too high to reach; yet the managing agent for the building testified that in hisfrequent visits, he never saw Leslie in the boiler room nor any indication that anyone was beingheld hostage there, and that in compliance with New York City fire code regulations, the boilerroom door had no locks, and could be opened quite easily from the inside. Leslieexplained that her cries for help proved unavailing because of the loud noise made by theoperating boiler, but when asked why she did not scream when the boiler was not operating,Leslie offered the excuse that she had a sore throat. Even her story of her idyllic life wasundermined by both the testimony of her own mother and by records secured from both theBoard of Education and other city agencies."

We reject the People's claim that the suppressed evidence was available to the defense. ThePeople disclosed nothing more than the flight attendants' names, with no contact information orindication as to what information they possessed. Furthermore, these names were buried in avoluminous amount of discovery provided shortly before trial, and were not identified asBrady material. This type of disclosure did not satisfy the People's obligation (seeBanks v Dretke, 540 US 668, 695 [2004] ["Our decisions lend no support to the notion thatdefendants must scavenge for hints of undisclosed Brady material when the prosecutionrepresents that all such material has been disclosed"]; see also People v Davis, 81 NY2d281 [1993]; United States [*3]v Gil, 297 F3d 93, 105-106[2d Cir 2002]; Leka v Portuondo, 257 F3d 89, 100-103 [2d Cir 2001]).

We note that one of the flight attendants, the one the trial prosecutor had personallyinterviewed, was listed as a potential witness, and thus the defense was given reason to believethat the prosecutor believed that the flight attendant would testify favorably for the prosecution.At bottom, however, it is irrelevant whether defense counsel could have discovered or shouldhave known that the flight attendants would contradict the complainant's account of the flight.The prosecution's constitutional and ethical obligations are independent obligations. The onlyrelevant point here is that the prosecution did know of and did not disclose this significantimpeachment evidence.

It is disquieting that the People's brief refers to this failure to disclose as "an arguable lapseof preferred practice." This was a flagrant violation by the prosecutor of his constitutional andethical obligations. It is all the more disturbing given one of the prosecutor's arguments onsummation. One of the defense attorneys argued on summation that the fact that none of theflight attendants had testified supported an inference that they would not support thecomplainant's account of the flight. In response, the prosecutor argued as follows: "Who else dowe have, airport security, airplane stewardess. Why weren't there people brought in. Think aboutit, ladies and gentlemen, how many times have we seen, just on our daily experience, kids areyelling, screaming in the street, you pay it no mind. Now I'm not going to go into the airport andsecurity, there's no reason to do that in this situation but just understand how in thesecircumstances you're tired, this is an early flight, a lot of people to check with, kids yelling andscreaming, just move on, just move on. Again, another person, not my business, someone elsewill take care of it. That's how this works. This is a conspiracy of passivity. No one getsinvolved, no one wants to be bothered." As Justice Barrett aptly put it, "this argument was, mostcharitably, disingenuous. The prosecutor's own silence with respect to the Brady materialis the more conspicuous and critical passivity found on this record." In this regard, finally, it alsois disquieting that the People assert on this appeal that Justice Barrett's condemnation of thisargument "fails to take into account that the proposed testimony of the flight attendants actuallywould have supported [the] argument." No rational view of the affidavits from the flightattendants supports this assertion.

The People's claim that the court should have used the "reasonable probability" standard forassessing prejudice (see People v Vilardi, 76 NY2d 67, 76-78 [1990]) is unpreserved(see People v Callendar, 90 NY2d 831 [1997]), and this lack of preservation on the partof the prosecution places the issue beyond our powers of review (People v Chavis, 91NY2d 500, 506 [1998]). Were we to find otherwise, we would reject this claim. The courtcorrectly applied the "reasonable possibility" standard since the defense made a specific requestfor Brady material (see People v Scott, 88 NY2d 888, 890-891 [1996]). In anyevent, we find that defendants demonstrated prejudice under either standard, and are entitled to anew trial (see People v Wright, 86 NY2d 591 [1995]).

We have considered and rejected the People's remaining claims. Concur—Saxe, J.P.,Friedman, Marlow, Sullivan and McGuire, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.