| 905 5th Assoc., Inc. v 907 Corp. |
| 2008 NY Slip Op 00032 [47 AD3d 401] |
| January 3, 2008 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| 905 5th Associates, Inc., et al.,Appellants-Respondents, v 907 Corporation et al., Respondents, and My HomeRemodeling, Inc., Respondent-Appellant. |
—[*1] Faust Goetz Schenker & Blee LLP, New York City (Lisa L. Gokhulsingh of counsel), forrespondent-appellant. Pillinger Miller Tarallo, LLP, Elmsford (C. William Yanuck of counsel), for 907 Corporationand Brown Harris Stevens Residential Management, LLC, respondents. Gallet Dreyer & Berkey, LLP, New York City (Morrell I. Berkowitz of counsel), for Richard& Liane Weintraub, respondents.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Faviola Soto, J.), entered July 13, 2006, which, tothe extent appealed from, granted the cross motion of defendants 907 Corporation and BrownHarris Stevens Residential Management, LLC for summary judgment dismissing the complaintas against them, and granted the motion by the Weintraub defendants and the cross motion bydefendant My Home Remodeling, Inc. (My Home) for summary judgment only to the extent ofdismissing the seventh cause of action for punitive damages as against them, unanimouslymodified, on the law, the third and sixth causes of action dismissed as against My Home and,upon a search of the record, as against the Weintraub defendants, and otherwise affirmed,without costs.
In this action to recover alleged damages resulting from renovation work being performed,with the cooperative's approval, by defendant contractor My Home for plaintiff Pamela Lipkin'supstairs neighbors, the Weintraub defendants, the case against the cooperative corporation and itsresidential managing agent was properly dismissed for lack of evidence that the cooperativecommitted any wrongful act leading to Dr. Lipkin's constructive eviction from her medicaloffices (see Barash v Pennsylvania Term. Real Estate Corp., 26 NY2d 77, 82 [1970]). Itis arguably the cooperative's duty, pursuant to the proprietary lease, to keep the concrete slabbetween Dr. Lipkin's offices and her upstairs neighbors in good repair unless the damage hasbeen caused by a tenant (cf. Hauptman v 222 E. 80th St. Corp., 100 Misc 2d 153, [*2]154-155 [1979]). However, plaintiffs failed to present any evidencethat the damage was in any way caused by the cooperative rather than by the Weintraubs andtheir contractor or by Dr. Lipkin herself, who had previously made renovations to her offices,including work on the same slab. Other than by speculation, plaintiffs failed to demonstrate thatthe cooperative controlled the means and methods of the work or that it was negligent in itsapproval of the renovation plan in the first place. Plaintiffs' reliance on a notice of violationissued against the cooperative as evidence of its negligence is unavailing, as the notice does notallege any affirmative acts of negligence by the cooperative. Moreover, without any evidence ofnegligence on its part, the cooperative is shielded from liability pursuant to language in theparties' proprietary lease specifically providing that the cooperative "shall not be liable for. . . injury or damage to person or property caused by . . . anothertenant . . . unless caused by the negligence of the [cooperative]." Furthermore, tothe extent that plaintiffs claim the cooperative acted unreasonably in addressing Dr. Lipkin'scomplaints and determining that there was nothing more it was required to do with respect tothose complaints, they present no evidence in support of such contention. Thus, any decisionmade by the cooperative and its managing agent with regard to such complaints, which the recordreflects were primarily handled by plaintiffs' attorney and representatives of the Weintraubs andMy Home, would be insulated from further judicial review (see generally Matter ofLevandusky v One Fifth Ave. Apt. Corp., 75 NY2d 530 [1990]).
My Home's cross motion for summary judgment was properly denied; plaintiffs' expertaffidavits raised issues of fact as to whether the work the contractor performed proximatelycaused debris and dust to infiltrate Dr. Lipkin's office, and whether the protective measures itrecommended but Dr. Lipkin allegedly rejected would have been effective. Furthermore, an issueof fact exists as to whether My Home agreed to indemnify the Weintraub defendants for claimssuch as plaintiffs'; accordingly, that part of its cross motion seeking dismissal of the Weintraubdefendants' cross claims was also properly denied. However, the court should have dismissed thethird cause of action against the Weintraub defendants and My Home for constructive eviction,as that claim can only be brought against a landlord (see Barash, 26 NY2d at 82).Similarly, the sixth cause of action for tortious interference with Dr. Lipkin's leasehold rightsshould have been dismissed as against the Weintraub defendants and My Home, as that claimnecessarily assumes liability on the part of the cooperative.
Finally, plaintiffs' claim for punitive damages was properly dismissed since the complaintdoes not allege egregious culpable conduct or wrongdoing aimed at the general public(Silverman v 145 Tenants Corp., 248 AD2d 261, 262 [1998]). Concur—Lippman,P.J., Andrias, Marlow, Buckley and Catterson, JJ.