| Matter of Piesco v Hollihan |
| 2008 NY Slip Op 00699 [47 AD3d 938] |
| January 29, 2008 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Frederick E. Piesco, Jr., et al.,Appellants, v Margaret Hollihan et al., Respondents. (Proceeding No. 1.) In the Matterof Frederick E. Piesco, Jr., et al., Appellants, v Margaret Hollihan et al., Respondents.(Proceeding No. 2.) |
—[*1] MacCartney, MacCartney, Kerrigan & MacCartney, Nyack, N.Y. (Harold Y. MacCartney,Jr., of counsel), for respondents Margaret Hollihan, John D'Angelis and Incorporated Village ofPiermont. Montalbano, Condon & Frank, P.C., New City, N.Y. (Richard H. Sarajian of counsel), forrespondents Suren Kilerciyan, Kilerciyan Properties, and Cornetta's Restaurant, Inc.
In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review a determination of the Zoning Boardof Appeals of the Incorporated Village of Piermont dated March 7, 2005, which, after a hearing,upheld the issuance of a revised zoning certificate of occupancy by the Village Building Inspector(proceeding No. 1), and a related proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review adetermination of the Zoning Board of Appeals of the Incorporated Village of Piermont datedSeptember 22, 2005, which, after a hearing, upheld the issuance of a building permit and acertificate of occupancy by the Village Building Inspector (proceeding No. 2), the petitioners inboth proceedings appeal from two judgments of the Supreme Court, Rockland County (Nelson,J.), dated October 14, 2005 (proceeding No. 1), and March 24, 2006 (proceeding No. 2),respectively, which denied the respective petitions and dismissed the respective proceedings.[*2]
Ordered that the judgments are affirmed, with one bill ofcosts to the respondents.
The respondents Suren Kilerciyan and Kilerciyan Properties operate a marina and arestaurant on the Hudson River, in the Village of Piermont. The property has been used for theoperation of a restaurant and a marina since 1963, if not for years prior thereto. The restaurantoffered seasonal outdoor food and beverage service since as early as 1972.
In or about 1996-1997, Kilerciyan began erecting an unenclosed tent or canopy (hereinafterthe tent/canopy) over the area used for outside dining. The Zoning Board of Appeals of theVillage of Piermont (hereinafter the Board) determined the tent/canopy did not require a permit,as it was neither a "structure" nor a "building" within the meaning of the village zoning law, as itwas not permanently placed on the land it occupies, and the zoning law did not provide for theregulation of temporary or seasonal buildings.
A question was subsequently raised, by the petitioners, who live across the street from themarina and the restaurant, as to the tent/canopy's compliance with the Fire Code of New YorkState. The New York State Department of State determined that, notwithstanding the localdetermination that no building permit was required for the tent/canopy, under section F2401.2 ofthe Fire Code of New York State the tent/canopy could not be erected or maintained withoutapproval from the local code enforcement official. The position of the New York StateDepartment of State Division of Code Enforcement and Administration was that the Village ofPiermont "should issue or deny" [sic] any necessary building permits or certificates ofoccupancy.
The Village Building Inspector issued a revised zoning certificate of occupancy on May 6,2004, identifying the respondent Cornetta's Restaurant, Inc., as a restaurant with a seasonaltent/canopy, and declaring that the property "predates zoning." The Village Building Inspectorissued a building permit on May 3, 2005, and a certificate of occupancy for the tent/canopy onMay 13, 2005.
The property is presently zoned WF-2, a waterfront district where there are no uses permittedas of right, but marinas and restaurants are permitted by special permit. Contrary to thepetitioners' contention that a special permit is required, the record before the Board establishedthat the use of the property for a marina and a restaurant significantly pre-dated the enactment ofthe provision of the Village of Piermont zoning ordinance which requires a special permit. Therestaurant use, the use in question on this appeal, and the other use of the property, are thuspreexisting nonconforming uses (see Matter of Syracuse Aggregate Corp. v Weise, 51NY2d 278 [1980]).
The erection of a tent/canopy over the outdoor dining area is neither a separate "use" nor anexpansion of the nonconforming use of the property for a restaurant. The zoning ordinance of theVillage of Piermont does not distinguish between indoor or outdoor food and beverage serviceand consumption as regards a restaurant use. An increase in volume or intensity of the samenonconforming use as has occurred on the property for decades is not an expansion of thatnonconforming use, and any interruption of the outdoor service occasioned by the lack ofcompliance with the requirements of the New York State Liquor Authority was not anabandonment of the restaurant use of the property (see Town of Clarkstown v M.R.O. Pump & Tank, Inc., 32 AD3d925 [2006]).
As the Board's determinations in both instances were rational and not arbitrary and [*3]capricious, those determinations were properly upheld (see Matter of Pecoraro v Board of Appealsof Town of Hempstead, 2 NY3d 608, 613 [2004]; Matter of Ifrah v Utschig, 98NY2d 304, 308 [2002]). Crane, J.P., Florio, Angiolillo and Carni, JJ., concur.