| Drapaniotis v 36-08 33rd St. Corp. |
| 2008 NY Slip Op 01699 [48 AD3d 736] |
| February 26, 2008 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| Vasiliki Drapaniotis, Appellant, v 36-08 33rd Street Corp.et al., Respondents. (Action No. 1.) Valid Entertainment, Inc., Appellant, v Katse Ke Bresta, Inc.,Respondent, et al., Defendants. (Action No. 2.) |
—[*1] Finkel Goldstein Rosenbloom & Nash, LLP, New York, N.Y. (Kevin J. Nash of counsel), forrespondents.
In a shareholder derivative action, inter alia, to recover damages for wrongful eviction andconversion (action No. 1), the plaintiff appeals, as limited by his brief, from so much of ajudgment of the Supreme Court, Queens County (Rosen, R.), entered September 9, 2005, upon adecision of the same court dated January 13, 2005, made after a nonjury trial, as is in favor of thedefendants and against him, dismissing the complaint, and in an action, inter alia, to foreclose amechanic's lien (action No. 2), the plaintiff appeals, as limited by its brief, from so much of ajudgment of the same court (Kitzes, J,), entered January 10, 2006, upon a decision of the samecourt (Rosen, R.), dated January 13, 2005, made after a nonjury trial, as is in favor of thedefendant Katse Ke Bresta, Inc., and against it, dismissing the complaint and vacating themechanic's lien.[*2]
Ordered that the judgments are affirmed insofar asappealed from, with one bill of costs.
At the trial of action No. 1, evidence was introduced showing that in December 1997, thedefendant 36-08 33rd Street Corp. (hereinafter the corporation) entered into a lease with thedefendant Katse Ke Bresta, Inc. (hereinafter Katse) for the purpose of opening a nightclub oncommercial property owned by Katse. The corporation did not make any rent payments. In June1998 a demand was made for back rent. The corporation did not comply with the demand andsoon thereafter the electric box to the property was locked.
Under the circumstances of this case, the locking of the electric box by Katse constituted aconstructive eviction, since it substantially and materially deprived the corporation of thebeneficial use and enjoyment of the premises (see generally Barash v Pennsylvania Term.Real Estate Corp., 26 NY2d 77, 82-83 [1970]; City of New York v Pike Realty Corp.,247 NY 245 [1928]). However, pursuant to a right reserved in the lease, Katse had a right topeaceably re-enter the commercial premises and regain possession once the corporation breachedits lease obligation to pay rent (seeNorth Main St. Bagel Corp. v Duncan, 6 AD3d 590 [2004]; Bozewicz v NashMetalware Co., 284 AD2d 288 [2001]). A contractor who performs work for, or providesequipment to, a tenant may impose a mechanic's lien against the premises where the owner of thepremises affirmatively gave consent for the work or equipment directly to the contractor, but notwhere the owner has merely approved or acquiesced in the undertaking of such work or theprovision of such equipment (see Lien Law § 3; Elliott-Williams Co., Inc. v ImpromptuGourmet, Inc., 28 AD3d 706, 707 [2006]; GCDM Ironworks v GJF Constr. Corp.,292 AD2d 495, 496 [2002]; Paul Mock, Inc. v 118 E. 25th St. Realty Co., 87 AD2d756 [1982]). To sustain the lien, "the owner must either be an affirmative factor in procuring theimprovement to be made, or having possession and control of the premises assent to theimprovement in the expectation that he [or she] will reap the benefit of it" (Elliott-Williams Co., Inc. v ImpromptuGourmet, Inc., 28 AD3d 706, 707 [2006], quoting Rice v Culver, 172 NY 60,65-66 [1902]).
Here, there was no evidence presented at the trial in action No. 2 showing that Katse, theowner of the premises, gave consent for the work to be performed by the plaintiff ValidEntertainment, Inc. (hereinafter Valid). Katse was not an affirmative factor in procuring theimprovements, nor did it assent to the improvements while in possession or control of thepremises. Therefore, the trial court correctly found that Valid failed to sustain its burden inseeking to foreclose the mechanic's lien and properly dismissed the complaint and vacated themechanic's lien.
The remaining contentions of the plaintiff in action No. 1 are without merit. Rivera, J.P.,Lifson, Angiolillo and Balkin, JJ., concur.