| Matter of McComb v Reasoner |
| 2008 NY Slip Op 01762 [48 AD3d 815] |
| February 26, 2008 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Jean McComb, Respondent, v AnneReasoner et al., Appellants, et al., Defendant. |
—[*1] Lovett & Gould, LLP, White Plains, N.Y. (Jonathan Lovett and Jane Bilus Gould ofcounsel), for respondent.
In a proceeding, inter alia, pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review a determination of theBudget Director of the City of White Plains dated August 2, 2004, which adopted therecommendation of a hearing officer dated January 2, 2004, made after a hearing, and confirmedby a "final and binding determination" of an arbitrator dated July 23, 2004, finding that thepetitioner was guilty of two charges of "insubordination and/or misconduct," and one charge of"neglect of duty and/or incompetence," and terminating her employment, Anne Reasoner, JosephM. Delfino, and the City of White Plains, N.Y., appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court,Westchester County (Dickerson, J.), dated October 27, 2006, which granted the petition, annulledthe determination, and reinstated the petitioner with back pay.
Ordered that the judgment is affirmed, with costs.
The petitioner Jean McComb was appointed Deputy Budget Director for the City of WhitePlains by Eileen M. Earl, the City's Budget Director. Based, inter alia, on allegations ofmisconduct made by both Earl and Chief Deputy Budget Director Anne Reasoner, the City'sMayor Joseph M. Delfino preferred charges against the petitioner, and, in writing, designatedDavid N. Stein to conduct a disciplinary hearing, make findings of fact and a recommendation asto any discipline. During the hearing, both Earl and Reasoner testified that the petitioner hadmade threats of physical violence against each of them. After Stein conducted the hearing for sixdays, the petitioner moved [*2]to dismiss the charges pendingagainst her, arguing that Stein was without authority to preside over the hearing because neitherEarl nor Reasoner had delegated authority to him to act as a hearing officer, and no one else hadthat authority. Stein denied the motion and completed the hearing, finding the petitioner guilty oftwo charges of "insubordination and/or misconduct," and one charge of "neglect of duty and/orincompetence," and recommending her termination. Thereafter, Mayor Delfino, rather thanrendering a final determination himself, designated arbitrator Martin F. Scheinman to review thehearing testimony and Stein's findings and recommendations, and to render "a final and binding"determination. In his "final and binding determination" dated July 23, 2004, Scheinman adoptedStein's findings and recommendations, and directed the termination of the petitioner'semployment. By letter dated August 2, 2004, Reasoner, who, by that time, had become theBudget Director, notified the petitioner that she was terminated in accordance with Scheinman'sdetermination.
The petitioner commenced the instant CPLR article 78 proceeding, contending, inter alia,that Mayor Delfino improperly designated both Stein as the hearing officer to conduct thehearing on the charges, and Scheinman as the ultimate decision maker, and that therefore, thehearing was held, and the final determination rendered, without jurisdiction. The Supreme Courtgranted the motion of Reasoner, Mayor Delfino, and the City pursuant to CPLR 3211 to dismissthe petition based on an objection in point of law, specifically, that the petition failed to state acause of action. However, upon the petitioner's appeal, this Court held, among other things, thatthe petition stated valid causes of action alleging that the designations of Stein as hearing officerand Scheinman as final decision maker were without authority (see Matter of McComb vReasoner, 29 AD3d 795, 798-800 [2006]). This Court remitted the proceeding to theSupreme Court to allow an answer to be interposed (id.). Subsequently, in a judgmententered October 27, 2006, the Supreme Court granted the petition, annulled the determination,and reinstated the petitioner with back pay. This appeal ensued.
The affidavits submitted by the appellants upon remittitur to the Supreme Court wereinsufficient to establish either that Earl and Reasoner were unavailable to designate the hearingofficer, or that the Mayor had any authority to delegate his final decision-making authority to anarbitrator with no connection to the City. Therefore, the Supreme Court properly granted thepetition. Ritter, J.P., Santucci, Covello and Carni, JJ., concur.