Matter of Fisher v Bothar Constr.
2008 NY Slip Op 02519 [49 AD3d 1042]
March 20, 2008
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, May 14, 2008


In the Matter of the Claim of Gregory L. Fisher, Appellant, vBothar Construction, Respondent. Workers' Compensation Board,Respondent.

—[*1]Coughlin & Gerhart, L.L.P., Binghamton (Jeffrey A. Brown of counsel), for appellant.

Levene, Gouldin & Thompson, L.L.P., Binghamton (Cynthia Ann K. Manchester ofcounsel), for Bothar Construction, respondent.

Kane, J. Appeals (1) from a decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filed April 28,2006, which ruled that claimant's reduced earnings did not arise out of his compensable injury,and (2) from a decision of said Board, filed November 9, 2006, which denied claimant's requestfor reconsideration or full Board review.

Claimant worked for the employer as a construction supervisor, a position that requiredheavy lifting. In July 2001, he injured his head and neck when some barrels fell on his head.Claimant continued to work without restrictions until October 2001, when he was laid off forreasons unrelated to the work accident. He began applying for other employment in theconstruction field without mentioning any injury or restrictions, but received no offers until April2002. In December 2001 or January 2002, he sought medical treatment for the first time since hisaccident. A doctor imposed a lifting restriction of 30 pounds. On January 28, 2002, claimantapplied for workers' compensation benefits. In April 2002, he obtained new employment as aconstruction inspector, a position which did not require physical labor but which paid less thanhis construction supervisor position. Although medical restrictions had been imposed at thattime, he did not mention them to his new employer.[*2]

Following a hearing, a Workers' Compensation LawJudge found that claimant suffered a permanent partial disability and that his reduced earningswere causally related to the July 2001 accident. On the employer's appeal, the Workers'Compensation Board found that claimant's reduced earnings were not causally related to hiscompensable injury. The Board later denied claimant's request for full Board review. Claimantappeals.

Initially, the employer's appeal to the Board was timely. Claimant argues that the employercould not contest his entitlement to reduced earnings because it did not appeal a prior decisionawarding reduced earnings. But the prior decision awarded only tentative reduced earnings. Anappeal need not be taken from a decision making a tentative award; an appeal is properly takenfrom a final decision (see Matter of Donovan v Knickerbocker Warehousing Corp., 72AD2d 870, 870 [1979]).

The issue of whether a claimant's reduced earnings are causally related to the work-relatedinjury is a factual one for the Board to resolve, and its findings will not be disturbed if supportedby substantial evidence (see Matter ofWoodworth v Clifton Springs Hosp., 35 AD3d 1062, 1063 [2006]; Matter of Katsaris v Lockheed Martin Fed.Sys., 9 AD3d 701, 702 [2004]). While a finding of permanent partial disability givesrise to an inference that a reduction in earnings is attributable to the disability, the Board maydeny a reduced earnings award "where the reduction in earning capacity results from factors otherthan the claimant's work-related injury" (Matter of Thompson v Saucke Bros. Constr. Co., 2 AD3d 993, 993[2003], lv denied 2 NY3d 703 [2004]; see Matter of Millner v Cablevision, 2 AD3d 1146, 1147 [2003]).Claimant, having lost his employment due to factors other than his work-related injury, bore theburden of establishing by substantial evidence that his disability contributed to his subsequentreduction in earnings (see Matter ofFurrer v Suffolk County Police Dept., 45 AD3d 996, 997 [2007]; Matter ofWoodworth v Clifton Springs Hosp., 35 AD3d at 1062; Matter of Walby v Volt Info.Science, 292 AD2d 740, 740 [2002]). Claimant worked without restrictions for three monthsafter his accident, only ceasing employment when he was laid off. He testified that after he waslaid off, he did not inform potential employers of his injury or limitations, and his medicalrestrictions had no bearing on his search for other employment. He also testified that he appliedto an engineering firm but was not hired simply because he did not want to travel. The Board'sdetermination was thus supported by claimant's own testimony, which established that his failureto find other employment was not caused, even in part, by his disability, but by economic factorsand his personal preference not to travel (compare Matter of O'Shea v Initial Cleaning Serv., 32 AD3d 592,593-594 [2006]; Matter of Turetzky-Santaniello v Vassar Bros. Hosp., 302 AD2d 706,708 [2003]).

Cardona, P.J., Peters, Spain and Lahtinen, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisions areaffirmed, without costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.