| Cassevah v Mack |
| 2008 NY Slip Op 04037 [51 AD3d 1132] |
| May 1, 2008 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| Lisa Cassevah, Appellant, v Stephanie Mack et al., Doing Businessas Lighthouse Properties, Respondents. |
—[*1] O'Connell & Aronowitz, P.C., Plattsburgh (Donald W. Biggs of counsel), forrespondents.
Cardona, P.J. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Dawson, J.), entered November28, 2007 in Clinton County, which granted defendants' motion for summary judgment dismissingthe complaint.
Defendants are mother and daughter who operated a partnership known as LighthouseProperties. Through the partnership, defendants purchased residential property located in theTown of Plattsburgh, Clinton County at a tax foreclosure auction and, after renovations, sold theproperty to plaintiff. Three and a half years later, plaintiff discovered that portions of the subfloorand floor joists were rotten. Based upon the representation in the listing agreement that "allcarpet and flooring ha[d] been replaced," plaintiff commenced this action against defendants fordeceptive business practices pursuant to General Business Law § 349, fraud and breach ofcontract.
Supreme Court granted plaintiff's subsequent motion for issuance of an open commission,seeking depositions in Vermont of defendants' husbands, who are not parties to the action butwere involved in the renovations. Shortly thereafter but before the depositions were held,defendants moved for summary judgment dismissing the complaint. Supreme Court [*2]granted that motion and this appeal ensued.
A court is authorized to deny a summary judgment motion or grant a continuance thereofpending discovery when "facts essential to justify opposition may exist but cannot then be stated"(CPLR 3212 [f]; see Billy v Consolidated Mach. Tool Corp., 51 NY2d 152, 163-164[1980]). Here, in opposition to defendants' motion for summary judgment, plaintiff's counselaverred that essential facts to justify opposition to the summary judgment motion may exist butcould not be stated until defendants' husbands were deposed. In support of this contention,counsel referred to Supreme Court's prior order issuing an open commission to deposedefendants' husbands wherein the court found that defendants' spouses "may have knowledgeabout the problems with the property" inasmuch as they were directly involved in the renovationsof the property, having hired individuals to work on the property as well as giving advice anddirection regarding the renovations. Importantly, in issuing that order, the court specificallyconcluded that such depositions "could lead to relevant evidence." Under these circumstances, itwould have been more appropriate for the court to have stayed defendants' summary judgmentmotion pending those depositions (see e.g. Alston v Golub Corp., 129 AD2d 916, 918[1987]; cf. Long v Fitzgerald, 240 AD2d 971, 974 [1997]).
Mercure, Spain, Lahtinen and Kavanagh, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is reversed, onthe law and the facts, without costs, and motion for summary judgment stayed pending plaintiff'scompletion of discovery pursuant to Supreme Court's order of open commission for depositions.