| Matter of City of Middletown v Town Bd. of Town ofWallkill |
| 2008 NY Slip Op 06563 [54 AD3d 333] |
| August 5, 2008 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of City of Middletown, Petitioner, v TownBoard of Town of Wallkill et al., Respondents. |
—[*1] Gary I. Greenwald, Chester, N.Y. (Joseph G. McKay of counsel), for respondents.
Consolidated proceeding (1) pursuant to General Municipal Law § 712, in effect, todetermine whether the proposed annexation of the City of Middletown of certain real propertylocated in the Town of Wallkill is in the overall public interest, and (2) pursuant to CPLR article78 to review so much of a determination of the Town Board of the Town of Wallkill datedAugust 17, 2006, as, after a public hearing, denied the petition for annexation submitted withrespect to the territory by Mt. Hope Development Corp. and Montrose VA Project, LLC, on thegrounds that it failed to comply with the requirements of General Municipal Law article 17, thatannexation would affect the boundaries of state senate and assembly districts, and that anenvironmental impact statement was required to be prepared and circulated in accordance withthe State Environmental Quality Review Act (ECL art 8).
Adjudged that the branch of the consolidated petition which is pursuant to CPLR article 78 toreview so much of the determination dated August 17, 2006, as denied the petition forannexation on the grounds that it failed to comply with the requirements of General MunicipalLaw article 17, that annexation would affect the boundaries of state senate and assembly districts,and that an environmental impact statement was required to be prepared and circulated inaccordance with the State Environmental Quality Review Act is granted, without costs ordisbursements, and that portion of the determination is annulled; the branch of the consolidatedpetition which is pursuant to CPLR article 78 is severed, and the Referees designated to hear andreport on the issue of whether [*2]the proposed annexation is inthe overall public interest pursuant to General Municipal Law § 712 (6) shall proceedexpeditiously to hear and report on such issues, and the proceeding pursuant to GeneralMunicipal Law § 712 shall continue to be held in abeyance.
Mt. Hope Development Corp. (hereinafter Mt. Hope) and Montrose VA Project, LLC(hereinafter Montrose), are the owners of certain real property located in the Town of Wallkill. In2003 Mt. Hope and Montrose requested that the Town provide water and sewer service to theirproperty. Various meetings were held at which the parties discussed the possibility of creating acooperative water and sewer district with the City of Middletown, which was servicing propertiesadjacent to those owned by Mt. Hope and Montrose. After two years had passed without anyaction by the Town on the request for water and sewer service, Mt. Hope and Montrosesubmitted a petition for annexation to the Town Board of the Town of Wallkill (hereinafter theTown Board), seeking annexation, to the City, of their real property and adjacent public propertyowned by the County of Orange. After a public hearing, the Town Board, in a determinationdated August 17, 2006, denied the petition for annexation, finding that the proposed annexationwas not in the public interest, that the petition failed to comply with the requirements of article17 of the General Municipal Law, that annexation would violate General Municipal Law §716 (1) in that it would affect state senate and assembly districts, and that Mt. Hope andMontrose failed to prepare and circulate a full environmental impact statement in accordancewith the State Environmental Quality Review Act (ECL art 8, hereinafter SEQRA). In responseto that determination, the City simultaneously commenced a proceeding in this Court pursuant toGeneral Municipal Law § 712 (1) to determine whether the proposed annexation is in theoverall public interest, and a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 in the Supreme Court,Orange County, to review the Town Board's determination in all other respects. In a decision andorder on motion of this Court dated March 17, 2008, the proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78was transferred to this Court, and consolidated with the proceeding pursuant to GeneralMunicipal Law § 712 (1) (see General Municipal Law § 712 [3]).
General Municipal Law § 703 (1), (2) requires that a petition for annexation satisfycertain requirements, including a directive that it "describ[e] the territory," that it be signed "bythe owners of a majority in assessed valuation of the real property in such territory," and that it"be authenticated as to all signatures upon each separate sheet by appending at the bottom of suchsheet an affidavit of a witness as to the subscription thereof." At any public hearing upon apetition for annexation, the governing boards of the local governments involved "shall hear anytestimony and receive evidence and information which may be presented concerning the petition. . . including but not limited to testimony, evidence, and information concerning"whether the petition complies with the requirements of General Municipal Law § 703 andotherwise substantially complies in form and content with the provisions of article 17 of theGeneral Municipal Law (see General Municipal Law § 705 [1]). Objections onthose grounds are required to be placed on the record through "oral testimony" and submitted "inwriting" to the governing boards holding the public hearing (General Municipal Law § 705[2]; see City of Batavia v Howland, 43 AD2d 787 [1973]).
Here, the Town Board erred in denying the petition for annexation on the ground that it didnot comply with the various requirements of article 17 of the General Municipal Law, since noobjections were placed on the record (see Matter of Wright v Ransom, 307 NY 317, 321[1954]; cf. City of Batavia v Howland, 43 AD2d at 787). By failing to object, or entertainobjections from others, the Town Board conceded that the petition for annexation complied withthe requirements of article 17 of the General Municipal Law. In any event, the petition forannexation satisfied the requirements of General Municipal Law § 703 and otherwisesubstantially complied in form and content with the [*3]provisions of article 17 of the General Municipal Law (seeGeneral Municipal Law § 705 [1]; Matter of Cutler v Herman, 2 AD2d 782 [1956],affd 3 NY2d 334 [1957]; Matter of Skidmore Coll. v Cline, 58 Misc 2d 582, 584[1969], affd 32 AD2d 985 [1969]).
Contrary to the Town Board's contention, Mt. Hope and Montrose have standing to seekannexation, to the City, of adjacent property belonging to the County that is presently located inthe Town. General Municipal Law § 703 (1) merely requires that the owners of a majorityin assessed valuation of the real property in the territory sought to be annexed sign the petition.Moreover, the fact that the County's property, County Route 78, is located within the boundariesof the property sought to be annexed to the City does not destroy the necessary contiguity of thesubject parcels (see Matter of Common Council of City of Gloversville v Town Bd. of Townof Johnstown, 32 NY2d 1, 4 [1973]).
General Municipal Law § 716 (1) provides that "[a]n annexation shall not affect theboundaries of any congressional district, senate district or assembly district." Contrary to theTown Board's contention, this provision merely acts as a restriction on the effect of annexationand not as an outright prohibition. In other words, while the properties to be annexed wouldbecome part of the City, the boundaries of state legislative districts would remain the same(see 1968 Ops Atty Gen [Inf Ops] 99). This interpretation is in accordance with otherprovisions of General Municipal Law § 716 (see General Municipal Law §716 [12]; 2002 Ops Atty Gen No. 2002-14; 1990 Ops Atty Gen No. 90-59; 1989 Ops Atty GenNo. 89-19; see generally Matter ofCharter Dev. Co., L.L.C. v City of Buffalo, 6 NY3d 578, 581 [2006]). By way ofcontrast, where the Legislature desired to prohibit certain types of annexation, it has used clearprohibitive language (see General Municipal Law § 716 [3]-[6]).
Under SEQRA, the annexation of more than 100 acres of land constitutes a type I action,requiring not only the preparation of an environmental assessment form (hereinafter EAF) inorder to determine the significance of such action, but creating a presumption of environmentalsignificance that triggers the preparation of an environmental impact statement (hereinafter EIS)(see Matter of City Council of City ofWatervliet v Town Bd. of Town of Colonie, 3 NY3d 508, 517-520 [2004]; 6 NYCRR617.2 [b] [4]; 617.6 [a] [2]). However, where "the annexation proposal lacks a specific projectplan that has been officially submitted or a rezoning proposal that changes the use for which theproperty may be utilized, the EAF will necessarily be limited to the annexation itself and itseffects" (Matter of City Council of City of Watervliet v Town Bd. of Town of Colonie, 3NY3d at 520; see Cross Westchester Dev. Corp. v Town Bd. of Town of Greenburgh,141 AD2d 796, 797 [1988]). After reviewing an EAF, if the lead agency determines "that theaction may include the potential for at least one significant adverse environmental impact," apositive declaration must be issued and the preparation and circulation of an EIS becomesnecessary (Matter of City Council of City of Watervliet v Town Bd. of Town of Colonie,3 NY3d at 519; see 6 NYCRR 617.7 [a] [1]). Conversely, if the lead agency determinesthat there will be "no adverse environmental impacts [from the action] or that the identifiedadverse environmental impacts will not be significant," a negative declaration may be issued andthe preparation and circulation of an EIS is not required (Matter of New York City Coalitionto End Lead Poisoning v Vallone, 100 NY2d 337, 347 [2003]; 6 NYCRR 617.7 [a] [2]).
Here, since no specific plan for the property had been officially submitted or a rezoningproposal made that would change the use of the property, the EAF was limited to the annexationitself and its effects (see Matter of City Council of City of Watervliet v Town Bd. of Town ofColonie, 3 NY3d at 520; Matter of Programming & Sys. v New York State Urban Dev.Corp., 61 NY2d 738, [*4]739 [1984]; Cross WestchesterDev. Corp. v Town Bd. of Town of Greenburgh, 141 AD2d at 797). Thus, the Town Board'sdetermination that an EIS was required to be prepared and circulated was premised on itsspeculative conclusion as to how Mt. Hope and Montrose intended to use the property. However,a town board may not require an EIS "based on a speculative possibility of use of the property"(Cross Westchester Dev. Corp. v Town Bd. of Town of Greenburgh, 141 AD2d at 797).
Accordingly, that branch of the petition which is to review so much of the Town Board'sdetermination as denied the petition for annexation on the grounds that it failed to comply withthe requirements of article 17 of the General Municipal Law, that annexation would affect theboundaries of state senate and assembly districts, and that an EIS was required to be prepared andcirculated in accordance with the SEQRA, is granted, and the Town Board's determination isannulled to that extent. Spolzino, J.P., Fisher, Carni and Dickerson, JJ., concur.