Baranek v Baranek
2008 NY Slip Op 06945 [54 AD3d 789]
September 16, 2008
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, October 29, 2008


Mark Baranek, Appellant,
v
Karin Baranek,Respondent.

—[*1]Mace H. Greenfield, Jericho, N.Y., for appellant.

In an action to set aside a stipulation of settlement dated October 7, 2004, which wasincorporated but not merged into the parties' judgment of divorce, the plaintiff appeals from anorder of the Supreme Court, Suffolk County (Weber, J.), dated December 13, 2006, which deniedhis motion for summary judgment on the first cause of action to set aside the stipulation ofsettlement on the ground that it failed to comply with Domestic Relations Law § 240 (1-b)(h), and searched the record and awarded the defendant summary judgment dismissing thecomplaint in its entirety.

Ordered that the order is modified, on the law, (1) by deleting the provision thereof whichsearched the record and awarded the defendant summary judgment dismissing the complaint inits entirety, and (2) by deleting the provisions thereof denying those branches of the plaintiff'smotion which were for summary judgment on so much of his first cause of action as sought to setaside the provisions of the stipulation of settlement awarding the defendant basic child support inthe sum of $900 per month and directing the parties to split all future unreimbursed medicalexpenses for the children, and substituting therefor provisions granting those branches of themotion; as so modified, the order is affirmed, without costs or disbursements.

Preliminarily, we note that the Supreme Court erred in awarding the defendant summaryjudgment dismissing the complaint on the ground that the parties' minor children were necessaryor indispensable parties who should have been joined in the action. In this plenary action to setaside the stipulation of settlement between the plaintiff and the defendant, the children were notparties to the contract whose rights may be prejudiced by the rescission thereof (see Manningv Manning, 97 AD2d 910, 911 [1983]). We further note that the Supreme Court improperlysearched the record and awarded the defendant summary judgment dismissing the second, third,and fourth causes of action in the complaint, since the viability of the second, third, and fourthcauses of action was not an issue [*2]presented in the plaintiff'smotion papers (see Dunham v Hilco Constr. Co., 89 NY2d 425, 427 [1996]).

The parties' stipulation of settlement, set forth on the record in open court on October 7,2004, stated that the parties had been made aware of the Child Support Standards Act(hereinafter CSSA) and stated the amount of basic child support pursuant to the CSSA was $861per month, which was less than the $900 per month awarded. However, the stipulation did notrecite that the parties were aware that the application of the CSSA guidelines would result in thecalculation of the presumptively correct amount of support and the parties' reasons for theirdeparture from the guidelines (see Domestic Relations Law § 240 [1-b] [h]).Domestic Relations Law § 240 (1-b) (h) requires these specific recitals, which were not inthe parties' stipulation. The recitals in the findings of fact and conclusions of law and thejudgment of divorce cannot rectify these defects since those documents were prepared andsubmitted by the attorney for the defendant approximately 11 months after the stipulation wasentered into (see Matter of Sievers v Estelle, 211 AD2d 173 [1995]).

Accordingly, the provision of the stipulation of settlement which awarded basic child supportin the sum of $900 per month is not enforceable and must be vacated (see Calian v Calian, 28 AD3d 506,507 [2006]). Similarly, the provision of the parties' stipulation which provided that "[t]he partieswill split all future unreimbursed medical expenses for the children" must be set aside on theground that that obligation is "directly connected with the basic child support calculation" (Cimons v Cimons, 53 AD3d 125,130 [2008]). However, it does not appear from this record that the basic child support provisionwas intertwined with other provisions of the stipulation, which included custody and visitation,equitable distribution of property, and a waiver of maintenance based upon equitable distributionof property (id.; cf. Lepore v Lepore, 276 AD2d 677, 678 [2000]). Accordingly,only the provisions awarding the defendant basic child support in the sum of $900 per month,and the provision which states that "[t]he parties will split all future unreimbursed medicalexpenses for the children," must be set aside. Fisher, J.P., Miller, McCarthy and Chambers, JJ.,concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.