Dann v Yeh
2008 NY Slip Op 07731 [55 AD3d 1439]
October 10, 2008
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, December 10, 2008


David L. Dann, Appellant, v Noelle M. Yeh et al.,Respondents.

—[*1]Cellino & Barnes, P.C., Rochester (James E. Maslyn of counsel), for plaintiff-appellant.

Chamberlain, D'Amanda, Oppenheimer & Greenfield, LLP, Rochester (Henry R. Ippolito ofcounsel), for defendant-respondent Noelle M. Yeh.

Burke, Albright, Harter & Reddy, LLP, Rochester (Alexi G. Vackicev of counsel), fordefendant-respondent Christopher E. Dann.

Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Monroe County (Evelyn Frazee, J.), enteredMay 14, 2007 in a personal injury action. The order granted the motions of defendants for, interalia, summary judgment dismissing the complaint.

It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously affirmed without costs.

Memorandum: Plaintiff commenced this action seeking damages for injuries he allegedlysustained while he was a passenger in a motor vehicle operated by defendant Christopher E.Dann. Christopher Dann's vehicle rear-ended a vehicle and was then rear-ended by a vehicleoperated by defendant Noelle M. Yeh. Supreme Court properly granted defendants' respectivemotions for, inter alia, summary judgment dismissing the complaint on the ground that plaintiffdid not sustain a serious injury within the meaning of the significant limitation of use and 90/180categories set forth in Insurance Law § 5102 (d).

With respect to the significant limitation of use category, defendants submitted the report of achiropractor who examined plaintiff and concluded that plaintiff's cervical and lumbar range ofmotion was within normal limits, that all cervical orthopedic testing was negative, and thatplaintiff had sustained a cervical sprain/strain as a result of the accident, which had beenresolved. "Defendant[s] thereby established that plaintiff sustained only a mild injury as a resultof the accident and that there was no objective medical evidence that plaintiff sustained asignificant . . . injury" (Beaton v Jones, 50 AD3d 1500, 1501 [2008]; seeLicari v Elliott, 57 NY2d 230, 236 [1982]; Clark v Perry, 21 AD3d 1378 [2005];Dingeldey v Kuebler, 15 AD3d 961 [2005]). In opposition, plaintiff failed to raise atriable issue of fact with respect to that category. The affirmations of plaintiff's treatingneurologist and treating physician are insufficient to raise a triable issue of fact because they failto set forth the tests conducted to support the conclusions in the affirmations and [*2]whether those tests were objective in nature (see Burke vCarney, 37 AD3d 1107 [2007]; Calucci v Baker, 299 AD2d 897, 898 [2002]).Further, plaintiff's neurologist failed to "provide either 'a numeric percentage of . . .plaintiff's loss of range of motion' or a 'qualitative assessment of . . . plaintiff'scondition' " (Parkhill v Cleary, 305 AD2d 1088, 1089 [2003], quoting Toure v AvisRent A Car Sys., 98 NY2d 345, 350 [2002]; see Robinson v Polasky, 32 AD3d 1215,1216 [2006]), nor did plaintiff's neurologist " 'compare[ ] the plaintiff's limitations to the normalfunction, purpose and use of the affected body organ, member, function or system' "(Parkhill, 305 AD2d at 1089, quoting Toure, 98 NY2d at 350; see Jaromin vNorthrup, 39 AD3d 1264, 1265 [2007]).

In addition, we agree with defendants that the conclusions of plaintiff's treating physicianappear to have been based upon her review of unsworn MRI and CT scan reports, upon whichplaintiff cannot rely (see Goldin v Lee, 275 AD2d 341, 342 [2000]; Merisca vAlford, 243 AD2d 613, 614 [1997]). The physician also appears to rely on plaintiff'ssubjective complaints of pain, because the physician's own notes attached to the affirmation andincorporated therein are replete with statements that plaintiff exhibited full range of motion withno objective evidence of neck or back injury (see Toure, 98 NY2d at 350;Jaromin, 39 AD3d at 1265; Cullen v Treen, 30 AD3d 1086, 1087 [2006];Howard v Rogalski, 291 AD2d 909 [2002]). Finally, with respect to the significantlimitation of use category, the affidavit of plaintiff's attorney lacks evidentiary value (seeZuckerman v City of New York, 49 NY2d 557, 563 [1980]), and the unsworn medicalreports attached thereto "fail to raise an issue of fact because they are not in admissible form"(Butera v Woodhouse, 267 AD2d 1039 [1999]; see Grasso v Angerami, 79 NY2d813, 814 [1991]).

Defendants also met their initial burden of establishing as a matter of law that plaintiff didnot sustain a serious injury under the 90/180 category by submitting the deposition testimony ofplaintiff establishing that she was disabled for only 85 days out of the 180 days following theaccident (see Moore v Gawel, 37 AD3d 1158, 1159 [2007]). Plaintiff's submissions inopposition to the motions fail to raise a triable issue of fact with respect to that category ofserious injury. We note in particular that the affirmation and office notes of plaintiff's treatingphysician fail to identify any objective medical evidence establishing that the accident caused thealleged limitations on plaintiff's activities (see Beaton, 50 AD3d at 1502; Calucci,299 AD2d at 898). Further, the self-serving affidavit of plaintiff stating that he was unable toreturn to work and could no longer participate in many recreational activities as a result of hisinjuries is insufficient to raise a triable issue of fact, in the absence of "a physician's affidavitsubstantiating the existence of a medically determined injury which caused the alleged limitationof [his] activities" (Jackson v New York City Tr. Auth., 273 AD2d 200, 201 [2000];see Kauderer v Penta, 261 AD2d 365, 366 [1999]). Present—Smith, J.P., Lunn,Fahey and Peradotto, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.