| Matter of Mulderig v New York State Dept. of Taxation & Fin. |
| 2008 NY Slip Op 08210 [55 AD3d 1159] |
| October 30, 2008 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of William M. Mulderig, Petitioner, v New York StateDepartment of Taxation and Finance et al., Respondents. |
—[*1] Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, Albany (Julie S. Mereson of counsel), for Department ofTaxation and Finance, respondent.
Kane, J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (initiated in this Court pursuant to Tax Law§ 2016) to review a determination of respondent Tax Appeals Tribunal which concluded thatpetitioner failed to comply with Tax Law § 659.
In 1991, the Internal Revenue Service determined that petitioner should have reported a greatertaxable income on his 1982 federal income tax return and that he owed over $1,000,000 in additionaltaxes for that tax year. He challenged that determination in federal court. The United States Tax Courtrevised the deficiency and held that petitioner owed $769,096 in additional income tax, plus a penaltyof $38,455. By decision entered November 9, 1995, the United States Court of Appeals for theSecond Circuit affirmed (Mulderig v Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 89 F3d 825 [1995]).In 1997, respondent Department of Taxation and Finance issued petitioner a deficiency notice basedupon his failure to report the federal audit changes, asserting that he owed $217,274 in additional stateincome tax for 1982, along with a negligence penalty of $10,863.70 and interest of $475,960.16.Following an unsuccessful conciliation conference, a hearing was held before an Administrative LawJudge (hereinafter ALJ), who denied the petition and sustained the deficiency notice. Respondent TaxAppeals Tribunal accepted the ALJ's findings of fact and affirmed his determination. Petitioner nowseeks review [*2]by this Court.
Petitioner does not contest the factual underpinnings of the Department's imposition of additionaltax, nor can he, as he lost his appeal of the federal tax determination upon which the Department'sdeficiency notice was based. As best as we can discern from petitioner's brief, his main arguments arethat he timely reported a change in his federal taxable income, the Department is barred from imposingadditional tax due to its failure to timely file a deficiency notice after his report, and he was deprived ofdue process. We find these arguments unpersuasive.
Substantial evidence supports the Tribunal's determination that petitioner failed to comply with TaxLaw § 659 and was thus required to pay additional income tax. Tax Law § 659 requirestaxpayers to report any changes or corrections to their federal taxable income within 90 days after thefinal determination of such change or correction, either conceding that the federal change is correct orstating how it is erroneous (see Tax Law § 659; see also 20 NYCRR 159.1). Ifa taxpayer fails to timely report changes to the Department, the statute of limitations for assessment ofadditional state taxes is inapplicable (see Tax Law § 681 [e] [1]; § 683 [c] [1][C]; 20 NYCRR 159.6; Matter of Fund v New York State Dept. of Taxation & Fin., 132AD2d 787, 787 [1987]).
Here, the final determination regarding petitioner's federal taxable income for 1982 was renderedby the Second Circuit in November 1995, requiring him to file the prescribed form with the Departmentby February 1996 (see 20 NYCRR 159.2 [a]; 159.5 [c]). Two Department employeestestified that they searched the Department's records for petitioner and did not find the prescribed formto report changes to federal taxable income, nor an amended state tax return for 1982. Petitionertestified that he filed an amended return in 1996 or 1997 and his accountant averred that an amendedstate return was filed about the same time that an amended federal return was filed in 1997. Whilepetitioner contends that he filed an amended state return in 1995, the figures in the unsigned andundated amended return in the record correspond with his 1997 amended federal return. He did nottestify that he ever filed the prescribed form to notify the Department of the adjustment to his federaltaxable income (see 20 NYCRR 159.2 [a]). Considering the record, substantial evidencesupports the Tribunal's determination that petitioner did not comply with Tax Law § 659 bytimely reporting the change in his federal taxable income (see Matter of Fund v New York StateDept. of Taxation & Fin., 132 AD2d at 788; Matter of Corin, 2003 WL 1954824, 2003NY Tax LEXIS 94 [2003], affd 2003 WL 22867392, 2003 NY Tax LEXIS 298 [2003]).Thus, the statute of limitations never began to run against the Department and its notice of deficiencywas timely filed (see Tax Law § 681 [e] [1]; § 683 [c] [1] [C]).
Petitioner was not deprived of due process despite the destruction of part of the Department'soriginal audit file in the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001. He was afforded a hearing tocontest the deficiency notice. At that hearing, the Department employees testified that scanned imagesof any filed amended returns would be stored in and retrievable from the Department's computerizedfiles. Multiple searches of the computerized files were conducted and no amended return was located.While petitioner contends that his amended return may have been included in the original file, thatcontention is mere speculation which is contradicted by the Department's proof concerning itsrecord-keeping processes. At most, petitioner established that he sent a copy of an amended return tothe Department as a document to be considered during the conciliation process. He did not meet hisburden of proving by clear [*3]and convincing evidence that such anamended return was ever filed, let alone in a timely fashion, or that the presence of the original filewould aid his case (see Tax Law § 689 [e]; Matter of Clapes v Tax Appeals Trib.of State of N.Y., 34 AD3d 1092, 1093-1094 [2006], appeal dismissed 8 NY3d 975[2007]; Matter of Phillips v New York State Dept. of Taxation & Fin., 267 AD2d 927, 929[1999], lv denied 94 NY2d 763 [2000]; Matter of Hoffmann v Commissioner of Taxation& Fin. of State of N.Y., 228 AD2d 732, 734 [1996]).
Petitioner's remaining contentions are without merit.
Peters, J.P., Rose, Lahtinen and Kavanagh, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.