| Matter of Calapai v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Vil. of Babylon |
| 2008 NY Slip Op 10620 [57 AD3d 987] |
| December 30, 2008 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Pamela Calapai, Respondent, v ZoningBoard of Appeals of Village of Babylon, Appellant. |
—[*1] Law Offices of Bruce Kennedy, P.C., Amityville, N.Y., for respondent.
In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review a determination of the Zoning Boardof Appeals of Village of Babylon dated April 24, 2007, which granted the petitioner's applicationto amend certain restrictions on a variance permitting her to maintain her garage for use as livingspace only to the extent of permitting such use for a period of three years, the appeal is from anorder and judgment (one paper) of the Supreme Court, Suffolk County (Sgroi, J.), dated October29, 2007, which denied the motion of the Zoning Board of Appeals of Village of Babylon todismiss the petition pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) and 7804 (f), inter alia, in effect, on the ground ofthe doctrine of res judicata, granted the petition, annulled the determination, and remitted thematter to the Zoning Board of Appeals of Village of Babylon for the issuance of documentationrequired for a certificate of occupancy permitting the garage to be used indefinitely as livingspace.
Ordered that the order and judgment is reversed, on the law, with costs, that branch ofmotion which was to dismiss the petition pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) and 7804 (f) on the groundof, in effect, the doctrine of res judicata, is granted, the proceeding is dismissed, and thedetermination is confirmed.[*2]
In 2000 the petitioner requested approval from the ZoningBoard of Appeals of the Village of Babylon (hereinafter the ZBA) for a variance to allow her toconvert her one-car garage into a bedroom and bathroom to accommodate the special needs ofher severely-disabled, paraplegic son. On October 18, 2000 the ZBA granted the application,upon the condition that, inter alia, the petitioner restore the property to its original use as a garageshould any change in circumstances occur.
The petitioner converted the garage to living quarters, spending a sum in excess of than$80,000, financed by a loan secured by the property, and met the requirements set by the ZBAwith regard to the alteration. In September 2006 following the death of her son at 18 years of age,the petitioner applied to the ZBA to remove the conditions imposed upon the original varianceand allow her to retain the property as renovated.
The ZBA granted the petitioner's application to the extent of permitting her to maintain theconversion for one year, after which she was to restore the property to its former condition. Thepetitioner then reapplied to delete that condition, and her reapplication was heard at a publichearing on February 28, 2007.
On April 18, 2007 the ZBA voted to amend the restrictions to allow the petitioner tomaintain her garage as living space for an additional period of three years and required her toreapply for a continuation of the approval every three years hence. The ZBA further determinedthat, if she were to sell the property, she would be obligated to restore it to its formerconfiguration.
The petitioner then commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding to annul the determinationand thus vacate the conditions that were imposed. Prior to answering, the ZBA moved to dismissthe petition based on objections in point of law, alleging that the petitioner was not aggrieved bythe determination and, in effect, that the proceeding was barred by res judicata.
The doctrine of res judicata applies to quasi-judicial determinations of administrativeagencies, including municipal zoning tribunals, and precludes relitigation of claims whichpreviously were litigated on the merits or might have been so litigated at the time (see Matterof Freddolino v Village of Warwick Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 192 AD2d 839 [1993];Matter of Palm Mgt. Corp. v Goldstein, 29 AD3d 801 [2006]; Town of Wallkill vLachmann, 27 AD3d 724 [2006]).
The issues raised on the variance application that is the subject of this appeal were raised inthe petitioner's initial 2000 application to make alterations to her garage, and the change incircumstances that occurred, to wit, the death of the petitioner's son, cannot be viewed asunanticipated. Consequently, that branch of ZBA's motion which was to dismiss the petition onthe ground of, in effect, the doctrine of res judicata should have been granted (see Matter ofPalm Mgt. Corp. v Goldstein, 29 AD3d 801, 803-804 [2006]; Matter of Waylonis vBaum, 281 AD2d 636, 638 [2001]), and the determination dated April 24, 2007, requiringthe petitioner to reapply for the extension of the variance three years from that date, should nothave been annulled.
In light of our determination, the ZBA's remaining contention has been rendered academic.Lifson, J.P., Santucci, Balkin and Belen, JJ., concur.