| Matter of 80 Lafayette Assoc. v Gibson |
| 2009 NY Slip Op 01159 [59 AD3d 231] |
| February 17, 2009 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| In the Matter of 80 Lafayette Associates,Petitioner, v Kumiki Gibson, as Commissioner of the New York State Division ofHuman Rights, on the Complaint of Ashraf Samann, Waheeb Wassef, Nageeb Wassef, HennaSamaan and Nashat Atalla, Respondent. |
—[*1] Caroline J. Downey, Bronx (Michael K. Swirsky of counsel), for respondent.
Determination of respondent Commissioner of the New York State Division of HumanRights, dated March 30, 2007, which, insofar as challenged in this proceeding brought pursuantto Executive Law § 298 (transferred to this Court by order of the Supreme Court, NewYork County [Joan A. Madden, J.], entered on or about July 12, 2007), found that petitionerdiscriminated against complainant Nashat Atalla on the basis of national origin, and rendered anaward in Atalla's favor, unanimously annulled, on the law, without costs, the petition granted, thecross petition for judicial enforcement of the award denied, and Atalla's complaint dismissed.
Administrative proceedings were commenced against petitioner 80 Lafayette Associates (80Lafayette), the owner of the commercial office building at 80 Lafayette Street in Manhattan,based on complaints filed with the State Division of Human Rights (DHR) by five of 80Lafayette's former employees. The complainants, each of whom was of Egyptian descent,charged that 80 Lafayette had discriminated against them on the basis of their national origin.After a hearing at which the five complainants and certain 80 Lafayette managers testified, thepresiding administrative law judge (ALJ) found that none of the complainants had sustained theburden of proving discrimination, and recommended that all of the complaints be dismissed.While the Commissioner adopted the ALJ's recommendation to the extent of dismissing four ofthe complaints, she rejected the recommendation to dismiss the complaint of Nashat Atalla, andinstead rendered an award in Atalla's favor, predicated on his claim that 80 Lafayette haddischarged him in September 1989 on the basis of his national origin. As this determination isnot supported by "sufficient evidence on the record considered as a whole" (Executive Law§ 298), we now annul it.
Atalla conceded having committed the act that 80 Lafayette adduced as the basis for histermination. Specifically, Atalla admitted that, in defiance of the direct order of his superior, hetook an envelope from a desk in the 80 Lafayette manager's office and left with it. This blatantlyinsubordinate act plainly constituted a legitimate, nondiscriminatory business reason forterminating Atalla, thereby rebutting his prima facie case (Ferrante v American LungAssn., 90 NY2d 623, 629 [1997]). Accordingly, the burden shifted to Atalla to prove that thefacially valid [*2]reason for his termination was merely a pretextfor an action that was, in fact, motivated by invidious bias (id. at 629-630).
As found by the ALJ, Atalla failed to carry the burden of proving that he was terminatedbased on his national origin, especially in view of the prior determination rendered in Atalla'sunion grievance proceeding. The arbitrator in that proceeding determined that Atalla hadcommitted the acts complained of in 80 Lafayette's termination letter and that such actsconstituted misconduct that permitted his summary dismissal. The sole evidence Atalla offeredto show that the discharge was based on his national origin was his hearing testimony (givenmore than a decade after the relevant events) that the manager who fired him told him at the timethat he did not want "Egyptians working in the building." However, the four-page handwrittencomplaint that Atalla filed with DHR in February 1990, a few months after his termination, madeno mention of any such statement. Neither was any such statement mentioned in the complaintsubmitted on Atalla's behalf in the union grievance proceeding, which complaint is quoted in thearbitrator's decision.
In rejecting the ALJ's findings as to Atalla, the Commissioner simply ignored the fact (whichthe ALJ had acknowledged) that, in Atalla's unsuccessful union grievance proceeding, thearbitrator had determined in 1992 that 80 Lafayette "had just cause to discharge [him]." Whilethe arbitrator's finding was not binding on the Commissioner, it was inappropriate for her toreach a contrary conclusion without explanation (see Collins v New York City Tr. Auth.,305 F3d 113, 119 [2d Cir 2002]). Further, the Commissioner's determination in favor of Atallawas also based in substantial part on a mischaracterization of the record. Specifically, contrary tothe assertion in the Commissioner's decision that the manager who fired Atalla "did not deny thathe made derogatory comments [about Egyptians] upon terminating [Atalla's] employment," therecord shows that the manager did deny making such comments.
In sum, the Commissioner's rejection of the findings of the ALJ is not supported by"sufficient evidence on the record considered as a whole" (Executive Law § 298), giventhat those findings, involving primarily issues of credibility, were entitled to substantial weightinasmuch as it was the ALJ, not the Commissioner, who had the opportunity to see and hear thelive testimony of the witnesses, and the Commissioner failed to articulate sufficient reasons fordeparting from the ALJ's findings (see Matter of Kelly v Murphy, 20 NY2d 205,209-210 [1967]; Matter of Alegre Deli v New York State Liq. Auth., 298 AD2d 581, 582[2002]; Matter of Lewis v Cambridge Filter Corp., 132 AD2d 802, 803 [1987]; cf.Matter of Berenhaus v Ward, 70 NY2d 436, 443 [1987]). Accordingly, the Commissioner'sdetermination is annulled, and Atalla's complaint is dismissed. Concur—Tom, J.P.,Andrias, Friedman, Catterson and Acosta, JJ.