| Stalker v Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. |
| 2009 NY Slip Op 01743 [60 AD3d 1173] |
| March 12, 2009 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| Betty Stalker, Individually and as Administrator of the Estate ofGeorge R. Stalker, Deceased, Appellant, v Goodyear Tire and Rubber Company et al.,Respondents. (And a Third-Party Action.) |
—[*1] McNamee, Lochner, Titus & Williams, P.C., Albany (Alan D. Kaplan of Herrick Feinstein,L.L.P., New York City, of counsel), for Goodyear Tire and Rubber Company, respondent. Ryan & Smallacombe, P.L.L.C., Albany (James D. Taylor of counsel), for Rua & Sons, Inc.,respondent.
Lahtinen, J. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Donohue, J.), entered April 23,2008 in Columbia County, which granted defendants' motions for summary judgment dismissingthe complaint.
George R. Stalker (hereinafter decedent) died after a truck tire on which he was workingexploded in what is known in the tire industry as a zipper rupture.[FN1]Decedent operated a truck [*2]repair business, as well as atrucking business, and he had over 20 years of experience working on commercial trucks,including tire repair. In March 2001, a flat tire was discovered on the rear dual wheels of one ofdecedent's flatbed trailers. The tire was replaced and, later in the day, decedent attempted torepair the tire in his shop. As he was standing in front of the tire inflating it, a zipper ruptureoccurred. The explosion propelled decedent across the room and resulted in his death. Thesubject radial truck tire had been manufactured in 1993 by defendant Goodyear Tire and RubberCompany and retreaded in 1996 by defendant Rua & Sons, Inc.
Plaintiff, decedent's widow, commenced this products liability action against Goodyear.Goodyear brought a third-party action against, among another, Rua, which unsuccessfully movedfor summary judgment dismissing the third-party complaint (35 AD3d 1050 [2006]). Plaintiffamended her complaint to include both Goodyear and Rua as defendants. Following disclosure,defendants made separate motions for summary judgment dismissing the action. Supreme Courtgranted the motions. Plaintiff appeals.
"A party injured as a result of a defective product may seek relief against the productmanufacturer or others in the distribution chain if the defect was a substantial factor in causingthe injury" (Speller v Sears, Roebuck & Co., 100 NY2d 38, 41 [2003]). A strict productsliability cause of action may be presented upon "a mistake in the manufacturing process," "animproper design" or a "fail[ure] to provide adequate warnings regarding the use of the product"(Voss v Black & Decker Mfg. Co., 59 NY2d 102, 106-107 [1983]). Plaintiff argues onappeal that she raised factual issues regarding design defect and failure to warn.
"A defectively designed product is one which, at the time it leaves the seller's hands, is in acondition not reasonably contemplated by the ultimate consumer and is unreasonably dangerousfor its intended use; that is one whose utility does not outweigh the danger inherent in itsintroduction into the stream of commerce" (Scarangella v Thomas Built Buses, 93 NY2d655, 659 [1999] [internal quotations marks and citation omitted]; see Preston v Peter Luger Enters., Inc.,51 AD3d 1322, 1323 [2008]). Defendants submitted ample proof to shift the burden toplaintiff via several experts who set forth that zipper ruptures occur as a result of low air pressureand poor maintenance rather than defective design and that, had decedent taken standard safetyprecautions, the accident would not have occurred. While Goodyear acknowledged obtaining apatent in 1994 for a process it hoped would address the zipper rupture problem, its expertexplained that the patent was obtained during the idea and study stage (before testing) and thatthe proposed process lacked merit to put into production. The various experts used by defendantsestablished that zipper ruptures are a concern of the entire tire and retreading industry and theycan be minimized by proper inflation, inspection and safety procedures. Industry-wide educationefforts were undertaken in the early to mid-1990s including wall charts, warnings and safetystandards. Safety procedures included, among other things, to remain outside the tire's trajectorythrough use of a clip-on air chuck. The experts explained that zipper ruptures happen in allbrands of tires and no radial sidewall has been designed that prevents zipper ruptures in tires thathave been used in an underinflated condition.
With defendants having satisfied their threshold burden on design defect, it became [*3]incumbent upon plaintiff to produce competent proof that thesubject tire "as designed, was not reasonably safe because there was a substantial likelihood ofharm and it was feasible to design the product in a safer manner" (Voss v Black & DeckerMfg. Co., 59 NY2d at 108; seeCleary v Reliance Fuel Oil Assoc., Inc., 17 AD3d 503, 506 [2005], affd 5 NY3d859 [2005]; Putnick v H.M.C. Assoc., 137 AD2d 179, 184 [1988]). The primary expertevidence submitted by plaintiff on the issue of design defect was an affidavit from DennisCarlson, an engineer.[FN2]Carlson contends that the tire was defectively designed, but he does so with generalizedstatements and in conclusory terms unsupported by analysis or data. While Carlson claims thatthe proposed design in the 1994 Goodyear patent "cures the problem at the heart of this case," heprovides no elaboration or explanation. A factual issue regarding design defect is not establishedby merely pointing to efforts within the industry to make a safer product, without providingsome detail as to how the current product is not reasonably safe and how a feasible alternativewould be safer. Plaintiff's proof was insufficient to raise a triable issue regarding design defect(see generally Preston v Peter Luger Enters., Inc., 51 AD3d at 1325).
Next, we consider plaintiff's inadequate warnings claim. "A manufacturer has a duty to warnagainst latent dangers resulting from foreseeable uses of its product[s] of which it knew orshould have known" (Liriano v Hobart Corp., 92 NY2d 232, 237 [1998]; see Rastelliv Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co., 79 NY2d 289, 297 [1992]). However, "[w]here the personwho would benefit from a warning is already aware of the specific hazard, the manufacturercannot be held liable for failing to warn of that known hazard" (Steuhl v Home Therapy Equip., Inc.,51 AD3d 1101, 1103 [2008]; seeHurlburt v S.W.B. Constr. Co., 20 AD3d 854, 855 [2005]; Schiller v National PrestoIndus., 225 AD2d 1053, 1054 [1996]; cf. Brady v Dunlop Tire Corp., 275 AD2d503, 504 [2000]). Decedent had over 20 years of experience working on commercial truck tires.His son (who started working for his father as a teenager), as well as others who worked at thebusiness, recalled receiving safety directions from decedent. Specifically, decedent warned thattires that had been run underinflated could potentially rupture when inflated because the cords inthe sidewall have a greater risk of failing, and he directed that, when reinflating a tire, to stand tothe side of it and use a clip-on air chuck. A poster on the wall in decedent's shop warnedworkers, when reinflating a tire, to always use a clip-on air chuck and never to stand in the tire'strajectory area. While decedent did not apparently use the precise words "zipper rupture" and"trajectory" when discussing tire safety, the evidence in the record established that he was awareof the specific risk and fully knowledgeable of the proper safety procedures. We conclude thatSupreme Court properly granted defendants' motions and dismissed the action.
Cardona, P.J., Peters, Rose and Kane, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is affirmed, withone bill of costs.
Footnote 1: A zipper rupture is a break inthe sidewall of a tire, from a few inches to several inches in length, between the beam andshoulder of the sidewall where the wires that provide structural support to the tire rupture afterbecoming fatigued due to the tire being used for a period of time while underinflated.
Footnote 2: A report by engineer H.R.Baumgardner (who retired during the litigation) is unsworn, the affidavit of Kenneth Laugherydeals with the issue of warnings, and the affidavit of James Pugh addresses cause of death.