| Matter of Revella v Felton |
| 2009 NY Slip Op 01753 [60 AD3d 1184] |
| March 12, 2009 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Christine A. Revella, Petitioner, v Preston L.Felton, as Acting Superintendent of the New York State Police,Respondent. |
—[*1] Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, Albany (Victor Paladino of counsel), forrespondent.
Malone Jr., J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order ofthe Supreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination of respondent which,among other things, found petitioner guilty of misconduct and reassigned her to a lower rank.
Petitioner, a zone sergeant with the State Police, was served with a notice of disciplinecharging her with three violations of State Police regulations as the result of an incident onAugust 12, 2006 involving her off-duty pursuit of another vehicle for reckless driving. Theincident started on Interstate 84 when petitioner was driving her personal vehicle, with herhusband, a captain with the Department of Environmental Conservation police, as a passenger.She noticed a white Toyota Camry, driven by Dana Sano, who was accompanied by a femalepassenger, approaching from behind at a high rate of speed. After the vehicle passed, petitionerobserved that it was being driven erratically. She proceeded to follow the vehicle through atollbooth exit and through a number of red lights until arriving at a hotel in the Town of Fishkill,Dutchess County. During this time, a number of events occurred escalating the intensity of the[*2]pursuit, including an attempt by petitioner's husband to stopthe vehicle as it exited the tollbooth and emergency 911 phone calls by the occupants of bothvehicles, culminating in a confrontation at the hotel to which other law enforcement officersresponded.
The first violation set forth in the notice of discipline charged petitioner with exhibitinginaptitude and failing to assume responsibility or exercise due diligence in the performance ofher duties. The second violation charged petitioner with acting in a manner tending to bringdiscredit upon the State Police. The third violation charged petitioner with failing to act in acourteous, dignified and businesslike manner. A hearing on the charges was subsequentlyconducted, resulting in a decision by the Hearing Board recommending that petitioner be foundguilty of the second charge, and that she receive a letter of censure and be placed on six monthsof probation. Respondent adopted the Hearing Board's recommendation, but rather than placingpetitioner on probation, reassigned her to the rank of sergeant. Petitioner commenced this CPLRarticle 78 proceeding challenging this determination.
Initially, we note that "[o]ur role is limited to determining whether the administrativedecision is supported by substantial evidence" (Matter of Taylor v New York State Div. of State Police, 28 AD3d978, 979 [2006]; see Doolittle v McMahon, 245 AD2d 736, 737-738 [1997]). Inundertaking this inquiry, we "will not 'second guess the credibility determinations of theadministrative factfinder' " (Matter ofMcKinney v Bennett, 31 AD3d 860, 861 [2006], quoting Matter of Stephen FF. v Johnson, 23AD3d 977, 978 [2005]).
In the case at hand, Sano and her passenger testified at the hearing regarding the events thatoccurred on the date in question. Sano related that, after passing the vehicle that petitioner wasdriving, petitioner flashed her lights and began tailgating Sano's vehicle. She stated that, whenshe passed through the tollbooth exit, petitioner's vehicle stopped and that Sano displayed hermiddle finger, at which point petitioner's husband exited the vehicle yelling and flaring his armstrying to get her to stop. She stated that she was fearful and proceeded to drive away, calling 911and traveling through a number of red lights before reaching the hotel where her friends werestaying. She stated that petitioner's vehicle followed her to the hotel and that petitioner's husbandconfronted her and her friends, telling her that she was going to be arrested. She indicated that,during this time, petitioner did not identify herself as a police officer or try to diffuse thesituation. Ultimately, the situation was resolved by police officers who responded to the sceneand no traffic tickets were issued. Sano's testimony was corroborated by her passenger.
Petitioner related a slightly different version of events, but essentially admitted that, in herpursuit of Sano's vehicle, she exceeded the speed limit, crossed official highway markings anddrove through red lights. Given these clear violations of the Vehicle and Traffic Law(see Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1111 [d] [1]; § 1128 [d]; § 1180 [b]),substantial evidence supports respondent's finding that petitioner violated a pertinent regulationand brought discredit upon the State Police. Furthermore, according "deference to an agency'sdetermination regarding a sanction, 'especially in situations where . . . matters ofinternal discipline in a law enforcement organization are concerned' " (Matter of Mokszycki v McMahon, 6AD3d 952, 953 [2004], quoting Matter of Santos v Chesworth, 133 AD2d 1001,1003 [1987]), we do not find petitioner's reassignment to the rank of sergeant shocking to oursense of fairness (see Matter of Tessierov Bennett, 50 AD3d 1368, 1370 [2008]; Matter of Wilburn v McMahon, 296AD2d 805, 807 [2002]). Therefore, respondent's determination must be confirmed.
Cardona, P.J., Lahtinen and Kavanagh, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.