Matter of Anumah (Commissioner of Labor)
2009 NY Slip Op 01893 [60 AD3d 1216]
March 19, 2009
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, May 6, 2009


In the Matter of the Claim of Mawuli Anumah, Appellant.Commissioner of Labor, Respondent.

—[*1]Christopher D. Lamb, MFY Legal Services, Inc., New York City (Carolyn E. Coffey ofcounsel), for appellant.

Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, New York City (Mary Hughes of counsel), forrespondent.

Nina Loewenstein, Disability Advocates, Inc., Albany, for Disability Advocates, Inc., andanother, amici curiae.

Kane, J. Appeal from a decision of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, filed August13, 2008, which ruled that claimant was disqualified from receiving unemployment insurancebenefits because her employment was terminated due to misconduct.

Claimant was a senior medical clerk for the employer. She received progressive disciplinerelated to her excessive tardiness and absenteeism, including verbal warnings, written warningsand, finally, a two-day suspension in December 2005. After that suspension, she was tardy orabsent an additional 38 times before her absence on April 17, 2006. The employer thenterminated her employment due to her continued attendance problems. At a hearing followingthe denial of claimant's application for unemployment insurance benefits, she testified andsupplied medical evidence that she was diagnosed with major depressive disorder that caused hertardiness and absenteeism. The Administrative Law Judge found that claimant should haveinformed the employer that her diagnosed disorder caused her attendance problems, and herfailure to do so constituted misconduct. The Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board affirmed,both initially and upon reconsideration. This appeal by claimant ensued.[*2]

Claimant acknowledges that her poor attendancefurnished the employer with sufficient reason to terminate her employment. The issue on thisappeal is whether her absenteeism constituted misconduct that disqualifies her from receivingunemployment insurance benefits, or whether her diagnosis excuses her attendance problems forunemployment insurance purposes (seeMatter of Clum [All-Lifts, Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 51 AD3d 1171,1172-1173 [2008]). Excessive absences and tardiness following prior warnings have been foundto constitute disqualifying misconduct (see Matter of Kazaka [Commissioner of Labor], 46 AD3d 1071,1071 [2007]; Matter of Valenta[Commissioner of Labor], 38 AD3d 1070, 1070 [2007]; Matter of Cuillo [Commissioner ofLabor], 37 AD3d 896, 897 [2007]; Matter of Iglesias [Commissioner of Labor],297 AD2d 849, 849-850 [2002]). On the other hand, loss of employment attributable tosymptoms of a recognized illness will not constitute disqualifying misconduct (see Matter ofFinn [Commissioner of Labor], 307 AD2d 509, 510 [2003]; Matter of Pluckhan[Sweeney], 245 AD2d 997, 998 [1997]). Whether absences are justified so as to removethem from disqualifying misconduct is a factual issue for the Board to resolve, and itsdetermination will be upheld if supported by substantial evidence (see Matter of Sunderland[Nassau County Med. Ctr.—Roberts], 121 AD2d 779, 780 [1986]).

Here, the Board determined that claimant did not take reasonable steps to protect heremployment (see Matter of Hernandez [Commissioner of Labor], 299 AD2d 794, 794[2002]). Claimant was aware, through the employer's progressive discipline spanning more thana year, that her job was in jeopardy. She contends that she took reasonable steps to protect herposition by attending weekly therapy sessions and seeing a psychiatrist to adjust her medication.Yet these actions, about which her employer was unaware, did not resolve the problem. Eachtime the employer counseled and warned claimant about her attendance, the employer inquired ifit could do anything to help; claimant did not respond or offer any explanation for her absences.The employer's witness testified that had claimant mentioned the reason for her absences, itwould have referred her to a company nurse—who would keep specific medicalinformation confidential—or the human resources department to consideraccommodations such as different hours or leave under the Family and Medical Leave Act of1993 (29 USC § 2612 [a] [1] [D]). Substantial evidence supports the Board'sdetermination that by failing to mention the legitimate medical reason for her absences, claimantfailed to take a reasonable step to protect her position (see Matter of Peterson [Commissioner of Labor], 32 AD3d 610,610-611 [2006]; Matter of Hernandez [Commissioner of Labor], 299 AD2d at 794; see also Matter of Miner [Commissioner ofLabor], 49 AD3d 1128, 1129 [2008]; Matter of Cooper [Commissioner ofLabor], 305 AD2d 894, 895 [2003]). Thus, she was not entitled to unemployment insurancebenefits.

The employer did not violate the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (hereinafter ADA)(see 42 USC § 12101 et seq.). The employer did not require claimant toexplain her absences and, even when warnings were given, only a general inquiry was made tosee if the employer could do anything to assist claimant in remedying her attendance problems.Nevertheless, the ADA permits inquiries related to business necessity (see 42 USC§ 12112 [d] [4] [A]), and regular attendance usually is, although it is not always, anessential function of a position (see Brenneman v MedCentral Health Sys., 366 F3d 412,418-420 [6th Cir 2004]; Ramirez v New York City Bd. of Educ., 481 F Supp 2d 209,221-222 [ED NY 2007] [stating that attendance is an essential function of employment];Miller v Verizon Communications, Inc., 474 F Supp 2d 187, 198 [D Mass 2007]; seealso Conroy v New York State Dept. of Correctional Servs., 333 F3d 88, 97-98 [2d Cir2003] [explaining the business necessity standard]). Thus, requiring claimant to take reasonablesteps to protect her employment, by providing a reason for her absences and lateness, does notviolate the ADA.[*3]

Mercure, J.P., Peters, Malone Jr. and Stein, JJ., concur.Ordered that the decision is affirmed, without costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.