| Matter of Norton v Town of Islip |
| 2009 NY Slip Op 02609 [60 AD3d 1069] |
| March 31, 2009 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Howard Norton,Appellant-Respondent, v Town of Islip et al.,Respondents-Appellants. |
—[*1] Lewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP, Riverhead, N.Y. (Michael G. Kruzynski and Jessica Klotzof counsel), for respondents-appellants.
In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to compel production of certain documentspursuant to the Freedom of Information Law (Public Officers Law art 6), the petitioner appealsfrom so much of an order of the Supreme Court, Suffolk County (Mullen, J.), dated July 26,2007, as denied his motion, inter alia, to hold the Town of Islip, Patricia Pasciutti, MichelleRemsen, and Richard Hoffman in civil contempt for their violation of a judgment of the samecourt entered January 31, 2006, and to impose sanctions upon them for frivolous conduct, andthe Town of Islip, Patricia Pasciutti, Michelle Remsen, and Richard Hoffman cross-appeal, aslimited by their brief, from so much of the same order as denied their cross motion to imposesanctions upon the petitioner for frivolous conduct.
Ordered that the order is reversed, on the law, without costs or disbursements, and the matteris remitted to the Supreme Court, Suffolk County, for a hearing to determine whether the Townof Islip, Patricia Pasciutti, Michelle Remsen, and Richard Hoffman violated the judgmententered January 31, 2006, and a new determination thereafter on the motion and cross motion.
On January 27, 2003, the petitioner, Howard Norton, filed with the Town of Islip a requestfor the production of certain Town records pursuant to the Freedom of Information Law(hereinafter FOIL) (see [*2]Public Officers Law §84 et seq.). Through various proceedings challenging the Town's failure to produce therecords, and one prior appeal to this Court (Matter of Norton v Town of Islip, 17 AD3d468 [2005]), production has proceeded fitfully. In a judgment entered January 31, 2006, theSupreme Court granted the petition in part and directed the Town, inter alia, to produceunredacted copies of the records Norton sought. In May 2007, after concluding that certainrequested records had not been produced and that others had been provided with redactions,Norton moved to hold the Town and several of its officers (hereinafter the respondents) incontempt for violating the judgment entered January 31, 2006. He also sought the imposition ofsanctions, and an award of an attorney's fee. The respondents cross-moved for the imposition ofsanctions upon Norton and his attorney for engaging in frivolous conduct.
After an in camera review of the Town's records, including records not previously produced,to determine whether they were the subject of Norton's FOIL request, the Supreme Court deniedthe motion and cross motion, but directed the Town to disclose the records not previouslyproduced, with references to matters that were not the subject of Norton's FOIL request redacted.The court held that such redactions and the redactions in the records previously disclosed did notviolate the terms of the judgment, inasmuch as the redacted matter did not pertain to the subjectof Norton's FOIL request. The court did not determine, however, whether the respondents had, infact, violated the judgment by virtue of their nonproduction of certain requested documents. Theparties appeal and cross-appeal from those portions of the order as are adverse to them.
Without first determining whether the respondents, in fact, violated the judgment, it was notpossible for the Supreme Court to make proper determinations on the motion and cross motion.We therefore reverse and remit the matter to the Supreme Court, Suffolk County, for a hearing todetermine whether, by virtue of their nonproduction of certain documents, the respondentsviolated the judgment, and for a new determination thereafter on the motion and cross motion.
We note that the Supreme Court properly found that the redactions in the documents alreadyprovided did not relate to the subject matter of Norton's FOIL request. Thus, the Town'sredactions in this regard did not violate the judgment and, consequently, did not provide a basisfor finding the respondents in civil contempt (see Antonacci v Antonacci, 273 AD2d185, 186 [2000]; Matter of Whiteco Metrocom Div. of Whiteco Indus. v Lambert, 221AD2d 750, 751 [1995]; Educational Reading Aids Corp. v Young, 175 AD2d 152[1991]). Fisher, J.P., Miller, Carni and Balkin, JJ., concur.
[Recalled and vacated by 70 AD3d 833.]