M Entertainment, Inc. v Leydier
2009 NY Slip Op 04169 [62 AD3d 627]
May 28, 2009
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Wednesday, July 1, 2009


M Entertainment, Inc., et al., Appellants,
v
LaurenceLeydier et al., Respondents.

—[*1]Bienstock & Michael, P.C., New York (Randall S.D. Jacobs of counsel), for appellants.

Satterlee, Stephens, Burke & Burke, LLP, New York (Christopher R. Belmonte of counsel),for Laurence Leydier, respondent.

Gogick, Byrne & O'Neill, LLP, New York (John M. Rondello, Jr., of counsel), for WardropEngineering Inc. and J.C. "Cam" Thompson, respondents.

Judgment, Supreme Court, New York County (Karen S. Smith, J.), entered November 27,2007, to the extent it dismissed the complaint as against defendants Wardrop and Thompson,unanimously affirmed, and appeal, to the extent it dismissed the complaint as against defendantLeydier, dismissed, without costs. Appeal from amended order, same court and Justice, enteredon or about October 17, 2007, which, after a nonjury trial, directed entry of a judgmentdismissing the complaint, unanimously dismissed as subsumed in appeal from judgment, and,with respect to plaintiff's claims against Leydier, dismissed for failure to obtain appellatejurisdiction, without costs.

An appeal as of right must be taken within 30 days after service by a party upon theappellant of a copy of the judgment or order appealed from, with notice of entry (CPLR 5513[a]). An appellant takes such an appeal by serving upon adverse parties a notice of appeal, andfiling same with the clerk of the court in which the judgment or order has been entered (CPLR5515 [1]). Where applicable, CPLR 2103 (b) (2) provides for service of papers upon an attorneyby mailing to the address designated for that purpose. "Mailing," under the statute, requires thedeposit of those papers "in a post office or official depository under the exclusive care andcustody of the United States Postal Service within the state" (CPLR 2103 [f] [1][emphasis added]). It is undisputed that plaintiffs, who opted for service by mail, did not placethe notice of appeal to be served upon Leydier in a post office or depository within this State.Accordingly, the notice of appeal is of no effect with respect to Leydier because service was notcompleted within the meaning of CPLR 2103 (see Cipriani v Green, 96 NY2d 821[2001]; National Org. for Women v Metropolitan Life Ins. Co., 70 NY2d 939 [1988]).We note that the Third Department has excused late service of a notice of appeal upon a showingof mistake or excusable neglect (Peck v Ernst Bros., 81 AD2d 940 [1981]), but the Courtof Appeals has [*2]categorically held that "[t]he power of anappellate court to review a judgment is subject to an appeal being timely taken" (Hecht vCity of New York, 60 NY2d 57, 61 [1983]). We thus find plaintiffs' improper service oftheir notice of appeal upon Leydier to be a fatal jurisdictional defect.

The evidence supports the trial court's finding that defendants Wardrop and Thompson didnot fraudulently induce plaintiffs to enter into the memorandum of understanding or the licensingagreement that are the subjects of this lawsuit. These defendants were not parties to eitheragreement, nor did plaintiffs pay them anything in connection with the subject transaction. Therecord shows that these defendants' involvement consisted of the presence of Thompson and theCEO of Wardrop's affiliate at two meetings between plaintiffs and Leydier, Leydier's use ofWardrop's boardroom for one of those meetings, and Thompson's presentation of his businesscards to plaintiffs, identifying himself as a principal of the Wardrop affiliate. Contrary toplaintiffs' contentions, Wardrop did nothing to give rise to the appearance and belief that Leydieror Thompson possessed authority to enter into a transaction with plaintiffs on its behalf, and tothe extent that Leydier and/or Thompson made such representations, the words or conduct of aputative agent are insufficient to create apparent authority (see Hallock v State of NewYork, 64 NY2d 224, 231 [1984]).

We have considered plaintiffs' remaining contentions and find them without merit.Concur—Andrias, DeGrasse and Richter, JJ.

Tom, J.P., and Buckley, J., dissent in part in a memorandum by Tom, J.P., as follows: Themajority deprives plaintiffs of the opportunity to appeal as of right the dismissal of their claimsagainst defendant Leydier without engaging in any analysis of the law and equities. Moreover,the cases relied upon in support of dismissal offer no guidance on the jurisdictional issue themajority resolves against plaintiffs.

It is Leydier's position that because a notice of appeal is deposited into a mailbox locatedoutside, rather than within New York State, this Court is jurisdictionally barred from entertainingthat party's appeal as of right against the recipient of the notice. The two cases he relies upon tosupport this result state, in the entirety and in virtually identical language: "Motion for leave toappeal dismissed as untimely. Service was not completed within the meaning of CPLR 2103 (b)(2) by the mailing in Washington, D.C. The statute provides for mailing 'within the state' "(National Org. for Women v Metropolitan Life Ins. Co., 70 NY2d 939 [1988]; seealso Cipriani v Green, 96 NY2d 821 [2001] [Nevada mailing]). Neither of these rulingssuggests that the basis for the Court's disposition is jurisdictional. Both cases involve whether togrant permission to appeal, an application addressed to the Court's [*3]discretion (see Matter of Newman v Gordon, 31 NY2d 676[1972]; American Banana Co. v Venezolana Internacional de Aviacion S.A. [VIASA],69 AD2d 762 [1979]), and reflect no more than the Court of Appeals' disinclination to excuse aprocedural irregularity in the exercise of a discretionary function (CPLR 2001; see e.g. Matter of Ancona, 17 AD3d584 [2005] [pro hac vice]). The decisions do not state, as Leydier urges, that the movant'sdeviation from the manner of service prescribed by statute defeats the Court's appellatejurisdiction.

Generally, the failure to comply with a provision for service of papers can be disregarded inthe absence of substantial prejudice to the right of a party (see e.g. Matter of Brown vCasier, 95 AD2d 574, 577 [1983] [failure to serve petition 20 days before return date]).Significantly, Leydier identifies no prejudice incurred by him as a result of the disputedirregularity in service and concedes that he timely received plaintiffs' notice of appeal, whichwas duly filed within the time prescribed by statute (CPLR 5515 [1]). Thus, there is no questionthat the appeal was seasonably brought, thereby removing any question of a jurisdictional bar onthe ground of untimeliness (CPLR 5513 [a]; see Hecht v City of New York, 60 NY2d 57,61 [1983]).

Leydier's sole objection to the service of the notice of appeal is that it was deposited in thewrong mailbox, i.e., one located in the State of New Jersey rather than New York. While,historically, the point of mailing has been a requirement for the completion of service of papersupon an attorney, it has not been accorded the universal jurisdictional significance Leydier andthe majority ascribe to it.

Rule 20 of the Rules of Civil Practice (the predecessor to CPLR 2103 [b] [2] and [f] [1])provided that service could be made on an attorney "through the post-office, by depositing thepaper properly inclosed in a postpaid wrapper in a post-office or in any post-office box regularlymaintained by the government of the United States in the city, village or town of the party or theattorney serving it, directed to the person to be served at the address within the state theretoforedesignated by him for that purpose." (Civ Prac Act § 20 [1].) The requirement fordepositing papers "in the city, village or town of the party or the attorney serving it" has beenliberalized to provide for deposit "in a post office or official depository under the exclusive careand custody of the United States Postal Service within the state" (CPLR 2103 [f] [1]).Furthermore, mailing is no longer the only means of delivering papers to an attorney; CPLR2103 now permits papers to be sent by the alternative means of "facsimile transmission,""overnight delivery service" and "electronic means" (CPLR 2103 [b] [5], [6], [7]).

Under the statute, an overnight delivery service is one "which regularly accepts items forovernight delivery to any address in the state" (CPLR 2103 [b] [6]). By contrast with serviceeffected by utilizing the United States Postal Service to make delivery, no restriction is imposedon the location from which service by overnight delivery originates, which can be made fromanywhere on earth so long as the papers are deposited "into the custody of the overnight deliveryservice for overnight delivery, prior to the latest time designated by the overnight deliveryservice for overnight delivery" (id.). Thus, such service can be effected from across thecountry or even around the world, as long as the delivery service customarily effects overnightdelivery to any address within New York State and the papers are received by the chosendelivery service by the designated time. Likewise, there is no geographic constraint on theservice of papers by facsimile transmission (CPLR 2103 [b] [5]).

The lack of any restriction under CPLR 2103 (b) (6) on the location where "deposit. . . [*4]into the custody of the overnight deliveryservice" must be made strongly suggests that the location from which service is initiated is notintended to be a jurisdictional requirement. Case law bears this out. As stated in Vita vHeller (97 AD2d 464, 464 [1983]), "Service of papers by mail is deemed complete upondeposit of such papers in the mail and such manner of service creates a presumption of propermailing to the addressee. The burden then falls upon the addressee to present evidence sufficientto overcome the presumption and establish nonreceipt." (Citations omitted.) The rationale behindthe presumption is that "the failure of the mails is not to be ascribed to the parties" (Seifert vCaverly, 18 NYS 327, 328 [1892]). Service is "complete" (CPLR 2103 [b] [2]) even if thepapers are not received in a timely fashion (see Matter of Coppola v Motor Veh. Acc. Indem.Corp., 59 AD2d 1023, 1024 [1977]) or not received at all (see Engel v Lichterman,62 NY2d 943 [1984]). Thus, what is forfeited by a party failing to effect service in accordancewith the statute is the "presumption of proper mailing to the addressee" (Vita, 97 AD2dat 464; see Ortega v Trefz, 44AD3d 916, 917 [2007] ["A properly executed affidavit of service raises a presumption thatproper mailing occurred"]), requiring the party to establish actual receipt of the papers. SinceLeydier concedes timely receipt of the notice of appeal, plaintiffs are relieved of this evidentiaryburden.

Even if it were granted, for the sake of argument, that strict compliance with CPLR 2103 (b)(2) is required, it would be appropriate to exercise this Court's discretion to excuse plaintiffs'failure to comply with the in-state restriction on mailing. As to matters not clearly jurisdictional,CPLR 2001 reflects the intent to avoid elevating form over substance by incorporating theessence of Civil Practice Act § 105 "to the end that slight mistakes or irregularities notaffecting the merits or the substantial right of a party shall not become fatal in theirconsequences" (Alexander, Practice Commentaries, McKinney's Cons Laws of NY, Book 7B,CPLR C2001, at 626, quoting People ex rel. Di Leo v Edwards, 247 App Div 331, 334[1936]).

In sum, there is no question that the appeal from so much of the order as granted dismissal ofthe complaint to Leydier was timely brought. Neither has any prejudice been demonstrated byLeydier, who concededly received the notice of appeal in timely fashion, thereby obviating anyfactual question concerning actual delivery. Under these circumstances, plaintiffs should not bedeprived of the right to appeal from the dismissal of the complaint as against him.

Accordingly, I would affirm the order in all respects.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.