Matter of Benson Point Realty Corp. v Town of E. Hampton
2009 NY Slip Op 04229 [62 AD3d 989]
May 26, 2009
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, July 1, 2009


In the Matter of Benson Point Realty Corporation,Respondent,
v
Town of East Hampton, Appellant.

—[*1]Jaspan Schlesinger Hoffman LLP, Garden City, N.Y. (Maureen T. Liccione of counsel),for appellant.

MacLachlan & Eagan LLP, East Hampton, N.Y. (David E. Eagan and Brian E. Matthews ofcounsel), for respondent.

In a proceeding, inter alia, pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review a determination of theTown of East Hampton dated May 6, 2005, which enacted Local Law No. 16 (2005) of Town ofEast Hampton, among other things, rezoning a parcel of real property owned by the petitioner,the Town of East Hampton appeals, by permission, from an order of the Supreme Court, SuffolkCounty (Costello, J.), dated November 28, 2007, which granted those branches of the amendedpetition which were to annul so much of the determination as rezoned the subject parcel on theground that the Town of East Hampton failed to comply with or provide proper notice pursuantto Town of East Hampton Town Code § 255-9-30 (G), Town Law § 264, andGeneral Municipal Law § 239-m.

Ordered that the order is reversed, on the law, with costs, those branches of the amendedpetition which were to annul so much of the determination as rezoned the subject parcel on theground that the Town of East Hampton failed to comply with or provide proper notice pursuantto Town of East Hampton Town Code § 255-9-30 (G), Town Law § 264, andGeneral Municipal Law § 239-m are denied, and the matter is remitted to the SupremeCourt, Suffolk County, for further proceedings on the remaining branches of the amendedpetition.

In April 2003 the petitioner applied to the Town of East Hampton Planning Board(hereinafter the Planning Board) for approval of its application to subdivide its 13-acre parcelinto nine residential lots. At that time, the parcel was zoned residence district A, which requireda minimum of one acre for each residential building lot.

In September 2004, while the petitioner's application was pending, the Town Board of theTown of East Hampton (hereinafter the Town Board) approved a draft comprehensive plan and adraft generic environmental impact statement, proposing town-wide zoning reclassifications,which included rezoning the petitioner's parcel from residence district A to residence district A5.Residence district A5 required a minimum of five acres for each residential lot.[*2]

It is undisputed that the petitioner received written noticeof the proposed rezoning and of the public hearing to consider the proposal, which took place onNovember 4, 2004. The petitioner thereafter submitted written objections to the rezoning of itsparcel, wherein it advocated that the parcel be rezoned as residence district A2, which required aminimum of two acres for each residential lot. The petitioner also submitted a letter prepared byan environmental consulting firm, identifying numerous purported inconsistencies with respectto the proposed rezoning of the parcel, based upon the protection of ground and surface water.

After reviewing the public input, the Town Board adopted a final generic environmentalimpact statement (hereinafter FGEIS) on April 14, 2005. The FGEIS contained a response to thepetitioner's objections and recommended that the parcel be rezoned residential district A3, whichrequired a minimum of three acres for each residential lot.

On May 6, 2005, the Town Board enacted Local Law No. 16 (2005) of Town of EastHampton, and thus voted to rezone the petitioner's parcel so as to include it in a residence districtA3. The petitioner thereafter commenced this proceeding to review the rezoning of its parcel,arguing, inter alia, that the Town failed to comply with Town Law § 264, GeneralMunicipal Law § 239-m, and the heightened notice and hearing requirements set forth inthe Town of East Hampton Town Code (hereinafter Town Code) § 255-9-30.

The Supreme Court granted those branches of the petition which were to annul thedetermination on the ground of insufficient notice, concluding that the notice requirementsarticulated in the Town of East Hampton Town Code are more stringent than the requirementsunder state law, and mandate a second notice and hearing to address the decision to rezone thepetitioner's parcel so as to include it in a residence district A3. We conclude that new notice andanother public hearing are not required.

Town Law §§ 264 and 265 "require a town board to give the public at least 10days' notice of the time and place of the public hearing at which proposed amendments to a localzoning ordinance will be discussed so that those interested in the amendments may attend andparticipate in the hearing. To facilitate regional review of amendments to a local zoningordinance, General Municipal Law § 239-m requires the local municipality to refer itsproposed amendments to the county planning board" (Matter of Gernatt Asphalt Prods. vTown of Sardinia, 87 NY2d 668, 677 [1996]). The notice must "fairly apprise[ ] the publicof the fundamental character of the proposed zoning change [and] not mislead interested partiesinto foregoing attendance at the public hearing" (id. at 678).

Where changes are made to a proposed zoning amendment following the conclusion of aproperly noticed public hearing, new notice and another public hearing are not required if the"amendment as adopted is embraced within the public notice" (id. at 679) or if theamendment as adopted is not substantially different from the amendment as noticed (seeCaruso v Town of Oyster Bay, 250 AD2d 639 [1998]; Marcus v Incorporated Vil. ofSpring Val., 24 AD2d 1021 [1965]; Matter of Suffolk Pines v Harwood, 14 Misc 2d826, 828 [1958], affd 10 AD2d 867 [1960]; cf. Matter of LCS Realty Co. vIncorporated Vil. of Roslyn, 273 AD2d 474 [2000]; Callanan Rd. Improvement Co. vTown of Newburgh, 5 AD2d 1003 [1958]; Village of Mill Neck v Nolan, 233 AppDiv 248 [1931], affd 259 NY 596 [1932]).

In the case at bar, the local law amending the Town's use district map (hereinafter theamendment), and thus rezoning the petitioner's parcel from a one-acre residential lot minimum toa three-acre residential lot minimum, was embraced within the original notice, and theamendment, as adopted, was not substantially different from the amendment as noticed. TheTown modified the amendment as initially proposed, based on the petitioner's objections, and theultimate zoning classification was more favorable to the petitioner's interests than that initiallyproposed. Thus, the Town complied with Town Law § 264.

In addition, the Town complied with General Municipal Law § 239-m since theparticulars of the amendment were embraced within the original referral.

Town Code § 255-9-30 (A) recites that "[a]ny amendment to the Use District Map. . . shall [*3]be adopted only after compliance withthe notification provision set forth in Subsection G hereof." Subsection G states: "Where anamendment . . . is proposed, the Town Clerk shall serve . . . a notice. . . at least 30 days prior to the date set for the public hearing to consider theproposed amendment(s). Said notice shall contain a description of the proposed change,including the existing zoning and the proposed change(s) together with a map depicting theproperties whose zoning classification will be amended with the proposed changes notedthereon."

We disagree with the Supreme Court's interpretation of Town Code § 255-9-30 asrequiring the Town to provide notice and a hearing on every modification to a proposed zoningamendment made after the conclusion of a properly-noticed public hearing. "Although statuteswill ordinarily be accorded their plain meaning, it is well settled that courts should construe themto avoid objectionable, unreasonable or absurd consequences" (Long v State of New York, 7 NY3d269, 273 [2006]). The notice of enactment for Town Code § 255-9-30 (G) indicatesthat it was intended to give property owners "ample opportunity to understand any proposedchanges and to provide the Town Board with their comments with regard to the same." Underthe circumstances of this case, no purpose is served by requiring the Town to expend theresources to renotice the amendment and hold a new hearing since the petitioner was fully awareof the nature of the proposed amendment and had ample opportunity to voice its objections.

The petitioner's remaining contentions are without merit. Rivera, J.P., Santucci, Chambersand Hall, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.