Stivers v Brownell
2009 NY Slip Op 04463 [63 AD3d 1516]
June 5, 2009
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 5, 2009


Robert Stivers et al., Appellants, v Jeffrey L. Brownell,Respondent.

—[*1]Davidson Fink LLP, Rochester (Paul D. Kelly of counsel), for plaintiffs-appellants.Vanhorn & Nabinger, Geneva (Schuyler T. Vanhorn of counsel), fordefendant-respondent.

Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Seneca County (Dennis F. Bender, A.J.),entered January 4, 2008. The order denied the motion of plaintiffs for summary judgment.

It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously modified on the law bygranting that part of the motion for partial summary judgment on liability on the claim for breachof contract based on unlawful eviction and by providing that the claim for punitive damages isdismissed and as modified the order is affirmed without costs.

Memorandum: Plaintiffs and defendant executed a lease for a restaurant for a two-yearperiod to end on April 30, 2005 and, in March 2005, defendant padlocked the doors of therestaurant, thus preventing plaintiffs from entering it. Plaintiffs commenced this action seeking,inter alia, damages for the allegedly wrongful eviction and seeking the return of a $25,000"inventory deposit." Defendant asserted numerous counterclaims in his answer seeking, interalia, compensation for damage to the property. Plaintiffs moved for summary judgment on thecomplaint as well as dismissal of the counterclaims. Supreme Court denied the motion and, in itsbench decision, dismissed the claim for punitive damages sought by plaintiffs in their motion.We note that, although the order does not address the issue of punitive damages, the decision iscontrolling in the event that "there is a conflict between an order and a decision" (Innovative Transmission & Engine Co.,LLC v Massaro, 37 AD3d 1199, 1201 [2007]). We therefore modify the orderaccordingly.

We conclude that Supreme Court erred in denying that part of plaintiffs' motion for partialsummary judgment on liability on the claim for breach of contract based on defendant's unlawfuleviction. Pursuant to the terms of the lease, defendant had the right to reenter the premises and toterminate the lease "without further demand or notice of any kind" in the event of a default byplaintiffs. Although defendant contends that he evicted plaintiffs on the ground that they were indefault for failing to pay rent and for damaging the property, the lease requires in relevant partthat plaintiffs first be given written notice of their alleged default and the opportunity to cure thedefault 30 days before defendant is entitled to terminate the lease. In support of their motion,plaintiffs submitted the deposition testimony of defendant in which he [*2]admitted that he did not give them any written notice beforeentering the premises and padlocking the doors, and defendant submitted no evidenceestablishing that he had a valid basis to reenter the restaurant and padlock the doors before theexpiration of the term of the lease. We therefore conclude that plaintiffs established theirentitlement to partial summary judgment on liability as a matter of law with respect to theirclaim for breach of contract based on unlawful eviction (see generally Zuckerman v City ofNew York, 49 NY2d 557, 562 [1980]), and further modify the order accordingly.

Contrary to the further contention of plaintiffs, however, they failed to establish as a matterof law that defendant breached the terms of the lease based on his failure to return the $25,000"inventory deposit." We thus conclude that the court properly denied that part of plaintiffs'motion seeking reimbursement of the $25,000 deposit. Pursuant to the terms of the lease,plaintiffs were required to pay defendant "the sum of $25,000.00 for inventory and supplies,i.e.[,] glasses, silverware, napkins, etc." upon entering into the lease. The lease further providedthat, in the event that plaintiffs did not purchase the premises at the end of the term of the lease,defendant "shall repurchase said inventory" for $25,000. We conclude on the record before usthat there is an issue of fact whether "said inventory" was on the premises, for defendant torepurchase (see generally id.). According to the deposition testimony of defendant, manyitems were missing when he repossessed the property, and defendant also submitted evidencethat the missing items included the glasses and silverware that were mentioned in the lease.

We further conclude that the court properly denied that part of plaintiffs' motion seekingdismissal of defendant's counterclaims. Although plaintiffs correctly contend that " 'a party to acontract cannot rely on the failure of another to perform when he [or she] has frustrated orprevented the performance' " (Hidden Meadows Dev. Co. v Parmelee's Forest Prods.,289 AD2d 642, 644 [2001]; see Kooleraire Serv. & Installation Corp. v Board of Educ. ofCity of N.Y., 28 NY2d 101, 106 [1971]), plaintiffs submitted evidence raising an issue offact whether they could have performed under the terms of the contract. The submissions of bothplaintiffs and defendant include evidence that the damage to the property may have been tooextensive for repairs to have been completed before the lease expired.

Finally, in view of the issues of fact on the record before us, we conclude that the courtproperly denied that part of plaintiffs' motion seeking an award of attorneys' fees under the termsof the lease. The determination whether plaintiffs are entitled to an award of attorneys' feesshould await the outcome of a trial (see Meysar Realty Corp. v Anndon Rest. Corp., 277AD2d 99 [2000]). Present—Hurlbutt, J.P., Martoche, Carni, Green and Pine, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.