Matter of Humane Socy. of U.S., Inc. v Brennan
2009 NY Slip Op 05062 [63 AD3d 1419]
June 18, 2009
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 5, 2009


In the Matter of Humane Society of United States, Inc., et al.,Appellants, v Patrick H. Brennan, as Commissioner of Agriculture and Markets, et al.,Respondents, et al., Respondents.

—[*1]Carter J. Dillard, Washington, D.C., for appellants.

Ruth A. Moore Law Offices, Albany (Sarah Hall Peak of counsel), for Patrick H. Brennanand another, respondents.

David Lanefsky, New York City, for H.V.F.G., L.L.C., respondent.

Malone Jr., J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Egan, Jr., J.), entered March20, 2008 in Albany County, which, among other things, in a combined proceeding pursuant toCPLR article 78 and action for a declaratory judgment, granted respondents' motion to dismissthe petition/complaint.

Pursuant to State Administrative Procedure Act § 204 (2), petitioners, variousorganizations and individuals generally opposed to the production of foie gras,[FN1]submitted a [*2]petition to respondent Department of Agricultureand Markets seeking a declaration that foie gras is an adulterated food product within themeaning of Agriculture and Markets Law § 200. After respondent Commissioner ofAgriculture and Markets issued a statement declining to issue the requested declaration,petitioners commenced the instant combined proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 anddeclaratory action against the Department and the Commissioner (hereinafter collectivelyreferred to as respondents), among others,[FN2]seeking to compel the Commissioner to issue the requested declaration or, in the alternative, areview of his determination not to issue such declaration. Petitioners also sought a judicialpronouncement that foie gras is an adulterated food product. Citing, among other things,petitioners' lack of standing to maintain the proceeding, Supreme Court granted respondents'motion to dismiss the petition/complaint and denied petitioners' cross motion to amend thepetition/complaint. Petitioners appeal.

In order to establish standing, petitioners were required to demonstrate that theCommissioner's declination to issue a declaratory ruling caused them an injury-in-fact differentfrom the general public and one that falls within the zone of interest protected by StateAdministrative Procedure Act § 204 (see New York State Assn. of Nurse Anesthetists v Novello, 2 NY3d207, 211 [2004]; Matter of Transactive Corp. v New York State Dept. of SocialServs., 92 NY2d 579, 587 [1998]). That statute provides that, when petitioned to issue adeclaratory ruling, an agency must either issue the ruling or issue a statement declining to issuesuch ruling (see State Administrative Procedure Act § 204 [2] [a]; see also1 NYCRR 368.1). There is no requirement that the agency issue a declaratory ruling whenrequested and a petitioner has no rights under the statute other than a timely response by theagency (see Matter of Bonar v Shaffer, 140 AD2d 153, 156 [1988]). Indeed, theDepartment's regulations specifically state that "[t]he issuance of a declaratory ruling shall bewholly within the discretion of the commissioner" (1 NYCRR 368.1 [c]).

Here, even assuming petitioners' alleged injuries to be true—i.e., that force-feedingducks causes the birds to become diseased animals, rendering their harvested livers adulteratedfood products within the meaning of Agriculture and Markets Law § 200—becausethe Commissioner issued a timely response to their request, they did not suffer an injury withinthe zone of interests protected by State Administrative Procedure Act § 204. Nor are wepersuaded that petitioners established either statutory (see State Finance Law §123-b) or common-law taxpayer standing. As such, Supreme Court properly granted respondents'motion to dismiss the petition based on petitioners' lack of standing.

In light of the above, it is unnecessary to address petitioners' remaining contentions.

Mercure, J.P., Spain, Kavanagh and McCarthy, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment isaffirmed, without costs.

Footnotes


Footnote 1: Foie gras is a food productderived from the intentionally enlarged livers of ducks and geese. The livers are typicallyenlarged by force-feeding the birds for approximately two weeks before their slaughter.

Footnote 2: Three producers of foie graslocated in New York—H.V.F.G., LLC, Bella Poultry, Inc., and La Belle Farm,Inc.—were also named as respondents.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.