| Matter of Takser (New York Compensation Ins. RatingBd.\MCommissioner of Labor) |
| 2009 NY Slip Op 05237 [63 AD3d 1478] |
| June 25, 2009 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of Vadim Takser, Respondent. NewYork Compensation Insurance Rating Board, Appellant; Commissioner of Labor,Respondent. |
—[*1] James W. Cooper, Warrensburg, for Vadim Takser, respondent.
Appeal from a decision of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, filed March 27,2008, which ruled that claimant was eligible to receive unemployment insurance benefits.
While claimant was employed as an actuarial analyst, his employer received a letter datedAugust 30, 2006 that contained three checks—dated October 29, 2004, November 8, 2004and November 28, 2004—each of which had been made payable to the employer. Thechecks in question had been sent to the employer from financial institutions representing interestpayments owed to the employer and, apparently, had been misappropriated from the employer'splace of business some time in late 2004. The author of the letter stated that, upon taking upresidence in claimant's former apartment, she found the three checks and had been trying toreturn the checks to claimant, but could not locate him. Each check was endorsed with what ispurported to be claimant's signature and his personal bank account number. None of the checkshad been negotiated, and claimant denied taking them or endorsing them with his signature.Concluding that claimant had misappropriated the checks and intended to convert them, theemployer terminated him. Claimant subsequently applied for unemployment insurance benefitsand the Department of Labor initially found that claimant was entitled to benefits. AnAdministrative Law Judge found, however, that claimant was disqualified from receivingbenefits because he lost his employment through misconduct. The Unemployment InsuranceAppeal Board reversed [*2]that decision and a new hearing washeld. A second Administrative Law Judge concluded that claimant was disqualified fromreceiving benefits. Upon its review, the Board determined that claimant's "discharge cannot besaid to have been due to misconduct" and found that claimant was entitled to receive benefits,prompting this appeal by the employer.
Surely, the question of "whether a claimant has engaged in disqualifying misconductpresents a factual issue for the Board to resolve and its decision will be upheld if supported bysubstantial evidence" (Matter ofWilliams [City of New York—Commissioner of Labor], 47 AD3d 994, 994[2008]; see Matter of Kuryla [FingerLakes Community Coll.—Commissioner of Labor], 45 AD3d 1129, 1130[2007]). Moreover, it is within the province of the Board to resolve credibility determinations inreaching that factual determination (seeMatter of Powers [L. Schieffelin & Co., LLC—Commissioner of Labor], 42 AD3d610, 611 [2007]; Matter of Tobin[Commissioner of Labor], 20 AD3d 839, 839 [2005]). Here, however, the record as awhole does not support the Board's conclusion that "[t]here is no evidence, other than theemployer's unsubstantiated suspicions, that the claimant misappropriated the three checks."Therefore, we must reverse.
It is undisputed that the three checks—all of which were issued almost two yearsbefore the employer had received them with the letter—bore what appeared to beclaimant's signature as well as his personal bank account numbers. In fact, claimant, wheninitially confronted with the checks, conceded that he had formerly resided in the apartmentwhere the checks had apparently been found, that the numbers on each check were for hispersonal bank account and that each appeared to be endorsed with his signature. In response,claimant gave an explanation that, on its face, is not plausible. He suggested, without presentingany evidence, that other employees had taken the checks, endorsed them with what appeared tobe his signature and personal bank account numbers and did so in retaliation for claimant havingfiled workplace complaints against them. However, this explanation failed to account for the factthat the checks had been misappropriated in late 2004, prior to any workplace complaints havingbeen filed by claimant against any of these employees. If true, the claims that these employeeswere responsible for the checks being misappropriated and subsequently sent to the employerwould have involved the employees misappropriating these checks long before any disputeexisted between them and claimant and holding the checks for a prolonged period of time, duringwhich they forged his signature and obtained the numbers of his personal bank account, whichthey then placed on the back of each check. Finally, these employees would also have had toobtain the name, as well as the cooperation, of the tenant who took possession of claimant'sapartment in 2006 and wrote the letter claiming to have found the checks in question uponobtaining her tenancy. This explanation, when viewed against the uncontroverted evidenceintroduced at the hearing, provides ample justification for the employer's conclusion thatclaimant had misappropriated these checks and, at some point while they were in his possession,intended to negotiate them. While the Board is obviously free to give appropriate considerationto the evidence that has been presented to it, it cannot, as it appears to have done here, disregardcompelling evidence that claimant was guilty of employee misconduct.
As a result, we must reverse and remit for a new hearing and decision before the Board.
Cardona, P.J., Peters, Rose, Kavanagh and McCarthy, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisionis reversed, on the law, without costs, and matter remitted [*3]tothe Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board for further proceedings not inconsistent with thisCourt's decision.