| Matter of Attea v Tax Appeals Trib. |
| 2009 NY Slip Op 05703 [64 AD3d 909] |
| July 9, 2009 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Elias H. Attea Jr., Petitioner, v Tax AppealsTribunal et al., Respondents. |
—[*1] Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, Albany (Robert M. Goldfarb of counsel), forCommissioner of Taxation and Finance, respondent.
Mercure, J.P. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (initiated in this Court pursuant to TaxLaw § 2016) to review a determination of respondent Tax Appeals Tribunal whichsustained an assessment of personal income tax imposed under Tax Law article 22.
Petitioner, a federally licensed Indian trader and a resident of Tennessee, commenced thisproceeding challenging a determination assessing additional personal income tax for 1992 and1993 arising from his wholesale tobacco sales, allegedly made in New York. Petitioner is theowner and operator of JR Attea Wholesale, which engages in wholesale distribution of tobaccoproducts to Native Americans living on Indian reservations. In 1992, he filed a nonresidentincome tax return allocating to New York $244,841 of his approximately $7.8 million federaladjusted gross income; in 1993, he reported a federal adjusted gross income of approximately$3.8 million, with $190,827 allocated to New York. According to petitioner, the incomeattributable to JR Attea Wholesale, which was shown on Schedule C of his federal income taxreturn for those years, was generated solely from the sale of tobacco products to NativeAmericans residing on reservations. The Department of Taxation and Finance, however,informed petitioner that it believed the income listed on petitioner's Schedule Cs was New Yorksource income instead, and requested scheduling of an appointment to audit petitioner's 1992 and[*2]1993 tax returns.[FN*]
As in a prior audit (Matter of Attea v Tax Appeals Trib., 288 AD2d 701, 701[2001]), petitioner was less than forthcoming with respect to requested documentation. Althoughsome shipping documentation was provided, the auditor was unable to use that data to "tie-in" tothe information provided on the Schedule Cs. The auditor also met with Robert Haas, a NewYork customs broker, and Daniel Shea, the operator of a foreign trade zone and the warehousewhere petitioner housed his tobacco products. Although petitioner did not substantiate his laborexpenses associated with Haas or Shea on his Schedule Cs, the auditor concluded that they wereacting as petitioner's employee and agent, respectively, in New York. Moreover, while petitionerdid not disclose information regarding inventory on his Schedule Cs, the auditor furtherconcluded that, when stored in Shea's warehouse, much of petitioner's product—upon 62%of which duty had been paid—constituted inventory located in New York, and thatpetitioner was renting warehouse space from Shea to store and prepare his product for shipping.Inasmuch as the documents provided by petitioner did not permit the auditor to substantiate thepurchases, gross receipts, income and expenses listed on petitioner's Schedule Cs, or that allsales were to Native Americans on Indian reservations, the Department issued a notice ofdeficiency assessing additional income tax liability of $716,291.32 plus interest for 1992, and$359,361.98 plus interest for 1993.
Following a hearing at which petitioner submitted voluminous additional documentation, anAdministrative Law Judge sustained the notice of deficiency, concluding that the Departmentwas justified in allocating 100% of petitioner's income to New York—despite his status asa federally-licensed Indian trader—because he failed to provide any evidence tosubstantiate the allocation claimed on his nonresident income tax returns. Respondent TaxAppeals Tribunal affirmed, prompting this proceeding.
We confirm. As in the prior proceeding challenging the assessment of personal income taxfor the years 1990 and 1991, "petitioner bears the burden of proving an erroneous tax assessmentby clear and convincing evidence" (Matter of Clapes v Tax Appeals Trib. of State ofN.Y., 34 AD3d 1092, 1093-1094 [2006], lv dismissed 8 NY3d 975 [2007] [internalquotation marks and citation omitted]; see Matter of Orvis Co. v Tax Appeals Trib. of Stateof N.Y., 86 NY2d 165, 178-179 [1995], cert denied 516 US 989 [1995]). Moreover,"it was incumbent upon petitioner[ ] to come forward with evidence establishing that [he] tradedexclusively with Native Americans residing on Indian reservations and had no income 'derivedfrom or connected with New York sources' (Tax Law § 631 [former (a)]), includingincome earned from 'a business, trade, profession or occupation carried on in this [S]tate' (TaxLaw § 631 [former (b) (1) (B)])" (Matter of Attea v Tax Appeals Trib., 288 AD2dat 702). In that regard, although petitioner [*3]argues that all statetransactional record-keeping requirements are inapplicable to Indian traders due to preemptionby federal law in this area, it is now well established that "Indian traders are not wholly immunefrom state regulation that is reasonably necessary to the assessment or collection of lawful statetaxes" (Department of Taxation & Finance of N.Y. v Milhelm Attea & Bros., 512 US 61,75 [1994]; cf. Warren Trading Post Co. v Arizona Tax Comm'n, 380 US 685, 691[1965]). Thus, having filed a New York nonresident tax return in which he allocated a portion ofhis federal adjusted gross income to New York, petitioner was required to produce books andrecords sufficient to establish the correctness of the amount allocated (see Tax Law§ 697 [b] [1]; 20 NYCRR 158.1 [a]).
As noted by respondent Commissioner of Taxation and Finance, petitioner's licensesauthorized him to sell cigarettes and tobacco products only to Native Americans at the St. Regisand Tuscarora Indian Reservations. Nevertheless, while petitioner produced documentsindicating that he imported and shipped tobacco products to Indian reservations, these recordsincluded no books of original entry for his business, such as sales journals, general ledgers,balance sheets, expense receipts, income statements or bank statements. In light of thesedeficiencies, the Tribunal was again unable to substantiate that the sales made by petitioneractually took place on reservations and were made to qualified tribal members—asrequired by petitioner's Indian trader licenses—or to formulate any allocation of whatpercentage of petitioner's sales might be tax exempt. Accordingly, as in the prior proceeding, weconclude that petitioner failed to meet his "heavy burden of demonstrating by clear andconvincing evidence that [his] business traded exclusively with Native Americans andmaintained no presence in this State," and we will not disturb the Tribunal's determination(Matter of Attea v Tax Appeals Trib., 288 AD2d at 703).
Finally, petitioner has not established by clear and cogent evidence that the taxes imposedwere violative of the US Constitution (see Matter of Zelinsky v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 1 NY3d85, 91, 96-97 [2003], cert denied 541 US 1009 [2004]). Petitioner's remainingarguments have been considered and found to be lacking in merit.
Rose, Kavanagh and Garry, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination is confirmed,without costs, and petition dismissed.
Footnote *: The years 1990 and 1991 wereinitially included in the audit, but ultimately assessed separately due to the impending expirationof the statute of limitations. Respondent Tax Appeals Tribunal concluded that petitioner had notmet his burden of proving that JR Attea Wholesale traded exclusively with Native Americansand maintained no presence in New York, and sustained notices of deficiency for those years;this Court confirmed that determination (288 AD2d 701 [2001], lv denied 98 NY2d 606[2002]).