| Matter of Gustus v Fischer |
| 2009 NY Slip Op 05903 [64 AD3d 1034] |
| July 16, 2009 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Bashir Gustus, Appellant, v Brian Fischer, asCommissioner of Correctional Services, Respondent. |
—[*1] Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, Albany (Martin A. Hotvet of counsel), forrespondent.
Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Sackett, J.), entered May 23, 2008 in AlbanyCounty, which dismissed petitioner's application, in a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78, toreview a determination of respondent finding petitioner guilty of violating certain prisondisciplinary rules.
On April 17, 2007, petitioner was involved in a physical altercation with another inmate.After a correction officer intervened, he directed petitioner to remain in a specific location, butpetitioner slipped away into the crowd. As a result, petitioner was charged in a misbehaviorreport with fighting and refusing a direct order. He was found guilty of both charges following atier III disciplinary hearing. Upon administrative appeal, the charge of fighting was dismissed,but the charge of refusing a direct order was sustained. A few days after the incident in question,and as the result of an investigation of the same incident during which confidential informationwas received, petitioner was charged in a second misbehavior report with assaulting an inmateand engaging in violent conduct. Following a tier III disciplinary hearing, he was found guilty ofthese charges and the determination was affirmed on administrative appeal with a modifiedpenalty. Petitioner then commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding asserting that the seconddetermination is barred by the doctrine of res judicata. Following joinder of issue, SupremeCourt dismissed the petition. This appeal ensued.[*2]
We reverse. The doctrine of res judicata "bars a cause ofaction that was raised and adjudicated, or which could have been raised and adjudicated, in aprior action or proceeding" (Matter of Burgess v Goord, 285 AD2d 753, 755 [2001]).Under the transactional analysis approach to this doctrine, " 'once a claim is brought to a finalconclusion, all other claims arising out of the same transaction or series of transactions arebarred, even if based upon different theories or if seeking a different remedy' " (Matter of Josey v Goord, 9 NY3d386, 389-390 [2007], quoting O'Brien v City of Syracuse, 54 NY2d 353, 357[1981]).
Here, both misbehavior reports charged petitioner with rule violations related to his conductin the April 17, 2007 altercation. Although additional information became available through aninvestigation after the first misbehavior report was filed, which led to the filing of the secondmisbehavior report, all of that information was available before the first hearing began. In fact,the hearing on the second report commenced approximately one hour after completion of thehearing on the first report. This was not a situation where two reports charged different ruleviolations for separate but somehow related conduct, permitting separate hearings anddeterminations (see Matter of Thomas vSelsky, 23 AD3d 868, 869 [2005]; cf. Matter of Griffith v Selsky, 32 AD3d 595, 596 [2006]).Because the two misbehavior reports charged violations concerning one incident and all of theinformation necessary to support the charges was available before commencement of the firsthearing, the hearing on the second misbehavior report was barred by the doctrine of res judicata(see Matter of Burgess v Goord, 285 AD2d at 754-755).
Peters, J.P., Rose, Kane, Stein and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is reversed,on the law, without costs, petition granted, determination on the second misbehavior reportannulled and respondent is directed to expunge all references thereto from petitioner'sinstitutional record.