Matter of Romaine v Suffolk County Bd. of Elections
2009 NY Slip Op 06373 [65 AD3d 993]
September 2, 2009
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, November 4, 2009


In the Matter of Keith Romaine,Appellant-Respondent,
v
Suffolk County Board of Elections, Respondent, andChristopher Marshall, Respondent-Appellant.

—[*1]

In a proceeding pursuant to Election Law § 16-102, inter alia, to invalidate a petitiondesignating Christopher Marshall as a candidate in a primary election to be held on September15, 2009 for the nomination of the Conservative Party as its candidate for the public office ofCouncilmember, Council District 6, Town of Brookhaven, the petitioner appeals from a finalorder of the Supreme Court, Suffolk County (Jones, J.), dated August 14, 2009, which, upon adecision of the same court dated August 6, 2009, made after a hearing, and, among other things,upon granting, in part, the application of Christopher Marshall to preclude him from adducingevidence of certain alleged defects in the designating petition, denied the petition and dismissedthe proceeding, and Christopher Marshall cross-appeals, as limited by his brief, from statedportions of the same final order.

Ordered that the cross appeal is dismissed, without costs or disbursements, as ChristopherMarshall is not aggrieved by the final order (see CPLR 5511; Parochial Bus Sys. vBoard of Educ. of City of N.Y., 60 NY2d 539 [1983]); and it is further,

Ordered that the final order is affirmed, without costs or disbursements.

The contentions of the petitioner, Keith Romaine, that sheet No. 5 of the designating petitionwas permeated with fraud and that the Suffolk County Conservative Party failed to comply withElection Law § 6-120 are raised for the first time on appeal and, therefore, are not properlybefore this Court (see Matter of Leroy vBoard of Elections in City of N.Y., 65 AD3d 645 [2d Dept 2009]; Matter of Maherv Coads, 297 AD2d 397 [2002]).

Romaine's contention that the Supreme Court should have denied the application ofcandidate Christopher Marshall to preclude Romaine from adducing evidence of certain allegeddefects in the designating petition is without merit, since those alleged defects were not set forthin or incorporated into the pleadings as specific objections, and Marshall was not otherwisesufficiently or fairly apprised of which signatures were being challenged and the grounds forthose challenges (see Matter of O'Toole v D'Apice, 112 AD2d 1078 [1985]; Matterof Belak v Rossi, 96 AD2d 1011, 1011-1012 [1983]; cf. Matter of Venuti v Westchester County Bd. of Elections, 43 AD3d482, 484 [2007]; Matter of Mazza v Board of Elections of County of Albany, 196AD2d 679, 680 [1993]; Matter of Smith v Marchi, 143 AD2d 325 [1988]).

Contrary to Romaine's contentions, there was insufficient proof that Mark Allen, one [*2]of the subscribing witnesses, made false statements on sheet No. 2of the designating petition. Moreover, Allen both initialed and explained the contestedalterations (see Matter of Jonas v Velez, 65 NY2d 954, 955 [1985]; Matter of Rosmarin v Belcastro, 44AD3d 1055, 1056 [2007]; Matter of Sternberg v Hill, 269 AD2d 730, 731 [2000];Matter of Coleman v Boone, 230 AD2d 872 [1996]; Matter of Brown v Phillips,185 AD2d 953 [1992]; Matter of Smith v McNab, 96 AD2d 922 [1983]).

Furthermore, we find no basis in the record to disturb the Supreme Court's finding that thedate set forth at sheet No. 3, line 14, of the designating petition properly indicated the day,month, and year when the signature was affixed (see Election Law § 6-130;see generally Matter of Pringle v Spanakos, 207 AD2d 515, 516 [1994]; cf. Matter ofPurtell v Kuczek, 112 AD2d 1092, 1094 [1985]). Even if there were such an error, under thecircumstances, it would not serve to invalidate the subsequent signatures (see Matter of Kentv Bass, 83 AD2d 898 [1981], affd 54 NY2d 776 [1981]).

Additionally, there is no basis in the record to disturb the Supreme Court's finding that theidentities of the signers on sheet No. 1, line 18, and on sheet No. 6, line 1, of the designatingpetition "as . . . registered voter[s]" were "established by reference to thesignature[s] on the petition and that of [ ] person[s] whose name[s] appear[ ] in the registrationpoll ledgers" (Election Law § 6-134 [5]; cf. Matter of Fusco v Miele, 275 AD2d426 [2000]). Moreover, the Supreme Court properly denied Romaine's objection with respect tothe signature appearing at sheet No. 1, line 12, of the designating petition, in light of theuncontradicted testimony of the signer, who unequivocally testified that he had signed on thatline (see Matter of Jaffee v Kelly,32 AD3d 485, 485-486 [2006]; cf.Matter of Henry v Trotto, 54 AD3d 424, 426 [2008]).

In light of the foregoing, the parties' remaining contentions are not properly before this Courtor need not be considered. Mastro, J.P., Leventhal, Chambers and Roman, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.